For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Boognish
Who are you referring to when you say your "boys"?
Quote
Green Lady
Anyway, has that Sympathy solo ever been successfully reproduced on stage?
Quote
larrywallace
my boys...Sympathy for the Bad Guy...Gimmee Shelter...
Quote
with sssoul
... Why does anyone think the aim is to reproduce what's on the record?
That's what records are for. Shows are *supposed* to sound different from that.
If the OP simply means he didn't like Keith's playing on SftD and Gimmie Shelter in Atlanta,
maybe he'll enjoy the discussions on the complaint thread. That's what it's for.
Quote
relms
They dont have to reproduce everything note for note like it is on the record, but that particular guitar riff is pretty famous and sounds really cool when it is played like it (at least close) is on the record...
Quote
stone4ever
funny how when its someones first post or thread everyone jumps down that persons throat.
fair comment about sftd & gs.
new people are treated with suspicion verging on paranoia on here
Quote
Happy24Quote
relms
They dont have to reproduce everything note for note like it is on the record, but that particular guitar riff is pretty famous and sounds really cool when it is played like it (at least close) is on the record...
Would you please explain this to Bob Dylan? Sorry for being off topic, but reading your post, I just can't help it. I like the man, I sort of enjoy his shows, but it would be really refreshing to hear the "old" songs being played in the "old" way. I think that nowadays it would be much bigger surprise and re-invention that all those constant re-inventions he is famous for and which are something that is automatically said whenever Bob is mentioned, but they have been virtually non-existent for many years.
Again, sorry for being off topic :-)
Quote
relmsQuote
with sssoul
... Why does anyone think the aim is to reproduce what's on the record?
That's what records are for. Shows are *supposed* to sound different from that.
If the OP simply means he didn't like Keith's playing on SftD and Gimmie Shelter in Atlanta,
maybe he'll enjoy the discussions on the complaint thread. That's what it's for.
They dont have to reproduce everything note for note like it is on the record,
but that particular guitar riff
is pretty famous and sounds really cool when it is played like it (at least close) is on the record...
and sounds butchered when it is butchered, and I have heard it butchered. But it is not a huge deal, whatever Keith wants to do is OK.
Quote
with sssoulQuote
relmsQuote
with sssoul
... Why does anyone think the aim is to reproduce what's on the record?
That's what records are for. Shows are *supposed* to sound different from that.
If the OP simply means he didn't like Keith's playing on SftD and Gimmie Shelter in Atlanta,
maybe he'll enjoy the discussions on the complaint thread. That's what it's for.
They dont have to reproduce everything note for note like it is on the record,
but that particular guitar riff
is pretty famous and sounds really cool when it is played like it (at least close) is on the record...
and sounds butchered when it is butchered, and I have heard it butchered. But it is not a huge deal, whatever Keith wants to do is OK.
If you mean the SftD solo: Sure, there have been some unimpressive renditions;
I personally even think there was a phase in there when Keith's playing on SftD
was his form of protest against the current arrangement. But that's a different issue.
Solos are supposed to allow the soloist to do something creative. They can blow us away
without reproducing what's on the record. Or not, as the case may be.
Quote
Thrylan
No.....its not getting better ever. IMO, it is painful......like getting embarrassed watching someone embarrass themself.
Quote
stone4everQuote
Thrylan
No.....its not getting better ever. IMO, it is painful......like getting embarrassed watching someone embarrass themself.
going back to the 02 gigs 2012 sympathy sounded much better
did he get lazy again
its not just the guitars the first half is a boring mess
Quote
ThrylanQuote
stone4everQuote
Thrylan
No.....its not getting better ever. IMO, it is painful......like getting embarrassed watching someone embarrass themself.
going back to the 02 gigs 2012 sympathy sounded much better
did he get lazy again
its not just the guitars the first half is a boring mess
Word
Quote
Turner68Quote
ThrylanQuote
stone4everQuote
Thrylan
No.....its not getting better ever. IMO, it is painful......like getting embarrassed watching someone embarrass themself.
going back to the 02 gigs 2012 sympathy sounded much better
did he get lazy again
its not just the guitars the first half is a boring mess
Word
Word ???
the keyboards however do ruin it way before the guitars come in
best song ever ruined
chuck
IMO the keyboards are a disaster and give everyone an excuse to phone it in.
Yeah, I need to obtain a guide, a DIY booklet or something.Quote
Thrylan
You suck at complaining Relms.....