For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
LieB
(Crossing my fingers for a complete Sympathy for the Devil performance!)
Quote
Matt
I expected so much from this release, but I'm afraid I'm a little disappointed.
Disc 1 is the original release. OK, I have the original in three different releases, so nothing new there. Disc 2 says unreleased tracks. How many? What's been discussed here before is three tracks. I really hope there are some more, AND I would have wanted them included in the original to make it like a complete show. Disc 3, OK I like BB.King and Ike&Tina Turner, but this disc won't give anything more of the Rolling Stones. Disc 4 is a DVD that we still don't know much about. Let's hope for the complete show from 1969. Most deluxe versions of albums are also better soundwise or remixed, but in this case, we no nothing about that. In the worst case, the sound can be a step down from the 2002 remaster since that was DSP and SACD. And of course nothing said about surround sound, which I would have preferred, since live recordings in surround gives the ultimate experience of almost beeing there.
Mats
Quote
stoneswashed77
well i am not sure what to think about the b.b. king and ike turner cd. do i have to pay for that even if i don´t want it. let me get this clear, i buy a rolling stones product and get 25% b.b. king/turner? i don´t understand this, sorry.
i also think they could have included the extra tracks on the first cd.
that would have been 1 cd and one dvd instead of a expensive 4cd box.
the cd i already have, so all i want is the dvd and (maybe) the extra tracks.
i can download those in an instant shortly anyway.
can i please have that dvd separated, thanks.
and only if it´s really different from gimme shelter.
Quote
DoxaQuote
Father Ted
This looks absolutely T for Tremendous! If it's any good, it will raise the bar for future deluxe editions.
There seems already be a competion between it & EXILE... sometimes this ABKCO vs. RS records non-sense works for great results...
What will be the next round: BEGGARS BANQUET vs. SOME GIRLS?
- Doxa
Quote
LieB
I like the idea with keeping the original Ya-Ya's, but -- in foresight -- I think I actually would prefer the whole concert as it was originally played, more as an "authentic" document of the MSG concerts (both complete concerts would be awesome) rather than a deluxe pack of the album. But I'm not complaining. Not me. Never. I'm always happy with what I get. Always.
Quote
Gazza
Seriously, folks. Some people need to f*ckin' wise up. A 3 disc and 1 DVD deluxe version of Get Yer Ya Yas Out.
How bad can it be?
Quote
GazzaQuote
Matt
I expected so much from this release, but I'm afraid I'm a little disappointed.
Disc 1 is the original release. OK, I have the original in three different releases, so nothing new there. Disc 2 says unreleased tracks. How many? What's been discussed here before is three tracks. I really hope there are some more, AND I would have wanted them included in the original to make it like a complete show. Disc 3, OK I like BB.King and Ike&Tina Turner, but this disc won't give anything more of the Rolling Stones. Disc 4 is a DVD that we still don't know much about. Let's hope for the complete show from 1969. Most deluxe versions of albums are also better soundwise or remixed, but in this case, we no nothing about that. In the worst case, the sound can be a step down from the 2002 remaster since that was DSP and SACD. And of course nothing said about surround sound, which I would have preferred, since live recordings in surround gives the ultimate experience of almost beeing there.
Mats
Congratulations. An in-depth slagging of a release that you haven't heard and of which you don't even know the contents. You've even managed to criticise how it will sound as well.
Inspired.
Quote
nanker phelgeQuote
Gazza
Seriously, folks. Some people need to f*ckin' wise up. A 3 disc and 1 DVD deluxe version of Get Yer Ya Yas Out.
How bad can it be?
Exactly Gaz, this looks like an awesome release!
Quote
Gazza
Both? There's four shows featured on Ya Yas. Three from MSG and one from Baltimore.
Quote
Matt
I expected so much from this release, but I'm afraid I'm a little disappointed.
Disc 1 is the original release. OK, I have the original in three different releases, so nothing new there. Disc 2 says unreleased tracks. How many? What's been discussed here before is three tracks. I really hope there are some more, AND I would have wanted them included in the original to make it like a complete show.