Tantalizing mini review of Shine A Light Documentary
Date: January 25, 2008 03:19
Found this and thought I should share......can't wait for the movie!!!!
Written by Marcelo Hessel
Invited by the Brazilian distributor Imagem Filmes, I watched 20 minutes of "Shine a Light," Martin Scorsese's documentary feature that captured both Rolling Stones' concerts at Beacon Theatre in New York, on October 29th and November 1st last year, part of their "A Bigger Bang Tour."
The relationship between the band and the director started 34 years ago, when "Jumpin ' Jack Flash" and "Tell Me" were featured on the "Mean Streets" soundtrack. And that was just the first of many times the Stones and Scorsese have worked together. "Shine a Light" starts from a rare premise: it's like having two old friends that are meeting each other face to face for the first time.
I arrived at the preview eager to spot Scorsese's style on the screen, but it's obvious that there is almost no space for authorial work when you're filming a concert. It's impossible to foresee what Keith Richards will do next, and this lack of control on stage forces him to film it all: positioning cameras, tracks, dollies and cranes are on every corner of the tiny theatre. Then, it's up to the director, above all, to know how to choose the best angles when in the editing room.
That's why Scorsese brought to this movie only the best cinematographers, like Ellen Kuras ("Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind"), Emmanuel Lubezki ("Children of Men"), Andrew Lesnie ("The Lord of the Rings") and Robert Elswit ("Magnolia," "Good Night, and Good Luck"), among others, all under the orders of director of photography Robert Richardson ("Casino," "The Aviator").
Different Dimensions
In 20 minutes we could only see three songs (and some backstage scenes) - in this case, " Jumpin' Jack Flash," that opened the second day, "Champagne & Reefer" (11th on the set list) and "Tumbling Dice" (12th). Each one of them gains, according to director’s orders, a different dimension from what's shot and how it's done.
In "Jumpin' Jack Flash," Scorsese invests in depth of field, showing all the musicians at the same time. The camera stays on the extreme right side of the stage, capturing Richards in foreground, Mick Jagger in mid-ground and Ron Wood, also in focus, in the background. By choosing the lateral view, instead of the more usual frontal, the director not only captures the three musicians in one single shot, but also inserts them on different levels - as one single being.
"Champagne & Reefer" has a different punch, because the Muddy Water’s blues is full of solos and doesn't have the same volume of the opening track. Scorsese then decides to do close-ups, and gets ready to film a whole variety of points of view. If Richards spits his cigarette, there's a camera there, ready to get it. If Buddy Guy (in a guest appearance) gives Jagger a wink, the audience will see it too.
With some of the best cinematographers by his side, Scorsese does what he does best: in the editing room, he starts to play with the length of each scene, making some of them very quick and others long, giving sense to the image. The Scorsesian characters always define themselves by the speed on which they cross the screen, and Buddy Guy had just become one of them.
The best scene of the screening: after a brief variety of cuts takings us from one side of the stage to the other, the camera freezes on the bluesman's face. He plays his guitar off the frame - it's the intro for "Champagne & Reefer" - but the camera keeps a close-up on him. It stays about ten seconds just like that when suddenly, Buddy Guy, who had his mouth closed so far, releases his powerful voice. Those who have ever listened to him know what has just happened: Scorsese and his crew have just paid a massive homage to the bluesman - and he deserves it!
After that, it is unfair to compare the mise-en-scène for "Tumbling Dice" - mainly because the cameras now start to follow Jagger, but the singer of the Rolling Stones, in his invertebrate ballet, is not an easy target to shoot.
Conventional but also very complex
At the end of the preview screening, I was feeling half happy (the other half of me was asking for more!). As a movie and music fan, I can assure you that the pleasure is gigantic and I say that knowing that those gigs also had guest stars such as Jack White (in "Loving Cup") and Christina Aguilera (in "Live with Me"), and rare songs played live, such as "I'm Free."
"Shine a Light" was scheduled to open in September, but the producers decided to put it off to 2008, saying that this extra time will make the movie even better. And after the 20-minute sample, we can expect something conventional in its form - it's not a conceptual concert, as Jonathan Demme and Talking Heads's "Stop Making Sense," but it's very elaborate in the way it looks. After all, as Jagger says backstage, "it's Marty's show."