For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
HairballQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
LeonidPQuote
HairballQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
liddas
So many interesting things here since the last time I checked the thread.
I'll try to catch up later, as soon as I recover from the shock for reading on a Stones allegedly "fan" site that Jigsaw Puzzle is one of the weakest tracks on Beggars and a clear example of, what?, Jagger still being a novice at songwriting ...
Puzzle is not Beggars' best track only because we have Devil and Street Fighting man on the same album. Yet it remains one of the most brilliant pieces of music ever put on tape by the stones.
And - since this is a Jagger thread - one of Mick's best vocal interpretations ever. You do not even need to understand what he is raving about with the lyrics, he gets across THAT FEEL just right and perfect!
C
I jumped in my chair when I read that, too, but I've learned through the years here that taste is hard to discuss.
I think many don't like or appreciate the surprising maturity of the track, though.
Lol it's a weak track imo, crucify me all you want!
...
Wow, haven't followed the thread much but this is certainly shocking, figured it would have been HMS to come up w/ this.
It's indeed some HMS kind of thinking, calling Jigsaw Puzzle a "weak track" when there's not one weak track on BEGGARS.
Evidently neither of you have followed the thread much, and to take a quote out of context is your loss!
I suggest rereading the last three or four pages, and report back when you have a proper clue before casting judgement.
But to regurgitate it all and spoon feed for you:
Weak track - especially in the context of the album IMO.
...
Quote
retired_dogQuote
stone4everQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
stone4ever
Excuse me but how does Mick go from writing Memo From Turner to Lets Work
Because Sympathy For The Devil to Winning Ugly? Or Jumpin' Jack Flash to Might As Well Get Juiced? Street Fighting Man to Streets Of Love? Gimme Shelter to Sweet Neo Con? Brown Sugar to Keys To Your Love? Rocks Off to Stealing My Heart?
ETC!!!!!!!!!!
I see what you mean, i know i'm a bit slow but i was thinking that in comparison Keith's solo albums show a connection to Keith's Stones writing with songs like Take It So Hard, How I Wish, Locked Away, Wicked A It Seems, You Don't Move Me, Locked Away etc etc.
We can see a connection in ability, we can see that the same writer took part in these tracks as say Beast Of Burden or BTMMR or Happy.
I just don't see a connection from Mick's writing earlier in his career to Sh'es The Boss.
Sorry just saying
A different view could be that while Keith was always trapped in a limited musical landscape, Mick at least tried to widen his.
But, whatever, and for what it's worth, while there's obviously little connection from Mick's earlier writing to She's The Boss, I can hear one to Wandering Spirit.
Quote
LeonidP
ummm .... so what about that required that we go back 3 or 4 pages? You state it's a weak track, it's brilliant. HMS has accessed your account, perhaps?
Quote
HairballQuote
LeonidP
ummm .... so what about that required that we go back 3 or 4 pages? You state it's a weak track, it's brilliant. HMS has accessed your account, perhaps?
OK don't go back 3 or 4 pages...instead maybe you should understand that others have a different opinion from you. I say weak track. You say brilliant track. Whoopty doo.
I don't cave in to peer pressure, I have a mind of my own, and I usually don't take part in groupthink either which by definition is:
"...occurs when a group values harmony and coherance over accurate analysis and critical evaluation.
It causes individual members of the group to unquestioningly follow the word of the leader and it strongly discourages any disagreement with the concensus".
I've always had a rebellious streak, and have never been a sheep following the herd. That said, I understand others feel safer when they allow others to make their decisions and form their opinions.
Hopefully you truly think it's a great track rather than just following the herd.
By the way, HMS hasn't been as active lately...maybe he's caved in to the attacks on his opinions and retreated?
Quote
LeonidPQuote
HairballQuote
LeonidP
ummm .... so what about that required that we go back 3 or 4 pages? You state it's a weak track, it's brilliant. HMS has accessed your account, perhaps?
OK don't go back 3 or 4 pages...instead maybe you should understand that others have a different opinion from you. I say weak track. You say brilliant track. Whoopty doo.
I don't cave in to peer pressure, I have a mind of my own, and I usually don't take part in groupthink either which by definition is:
"...occurs when a group values harmony and coherance over accurate analysis and critical evaluation.
It causes individual members of the group to unquestioningly follow the word of the leader and it strongly discourages any disagreement with the concensus".
I've always had a rebellious streak, and have never been a sheep following the herd. That said, I understand others feel safer when they allow others to make their decisions and form their opinions.
Hopefully you truly think it's a great track rather than just following the herd.
By the way, HMS hasn't been as active lately...maybe he's caved in to the attacks on his opinions and retreated?
I wasn't stating my opinion. It's a brilliant track, that's a fact!
Quote
HairballQuote
LeonidPQuote
HairballQuote
LeonidP
ummm .... so what about that required that we go back 3 or 4 pages? You state it's a weak track, it's brilliant. HMS has accessed your account, perhaps?
OK don't go back 3 or 4 pages...instead maybe you should understand that others have a different opinion from you. I say weak track. You say brilliant track. Whoopty doo.
I don't cave in to peer pressure, I have a mind of my own, and I usually don't take part in groupthink either which by definition is:
"...occurs when a group values harmony and coherance over accurate analysis and critical evaluation.
It causes individual members of the group to unquestioningly follow the word of the leader and it strongly discourages any disagreement with the concensus".
I've always had a rebellious streak, and have never been a sheep following the herd. That said, I understand others feel safer when they allow others to make their decisions and form their opinions.
Hopefully you truly think it's a great track rather than just following the herd.
By the way, HMS hasn't been as active lately...maybe he's caved in to the attacks on his opinions and retreated?
I wasn't stating my opinion. It's a brilliant track, that's a fact!
LOL...OK now that you put it like that....sometimes I get my facts wrong lol.
Quote
HairballQuote
LeonidP
ummm .... so what about that required that we go back 3 or 4 pages? You state it's a weak track, it's brilliant. HMS has accessed your account, perhaps?
OK don't go back 3 or 4 pages...instead maybe you should understand that others have a different opinion from you. I say weak track. You say brilliant track. Whoopty doo.
I don't cave in to peer pressure, I have a mind of my own, and I usually don't take part in groupthink either which by definition is:
"...occurs when a group values harmony and coherance over accurate analysis and critical evaluation.
It causes individual members of the group to unquestioningly follow the word of the leader and it strongly discourages any disagreement with the concensus".
I've always had a rebellious streak, and have never been a sheep following the herd. That said, I understand others feel safer when they allow others to make their decisions and form their opinions.
Hopefully you truly think it's a great track rather than just following the herd.
By the way, HMS hasn't been as active lately...maybe he's caved in to the attacks on his opinions and retreated?
Quote
DandelionPowderman
Some sparring and stinging comments doesn't mean that one dislikes you or your views, Riffie. You shouldn't take it so hard
Quote
stone4ever
Even today i noticed myself not wanting to upset people who love Mick and his solo albums, so i find myself thinking Wandering Spirit is not so bad .
Quote
HairballQuote
stone4ever
Even today i noticed myself not wanting to upset people who love Mick and his solo albums, so i find myself thinking Wandering Spirit is not so bad .
Stay strong stone4ever - it was just a passing sensation...you're not fully brainwashed yet!!!
Resist the temptation of singing to the choir, and sing your own tune...even if it's completely out of key.
Quote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Quote
LongBeachArena72Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Oh, ok. I guess a lot of 'casual' fans do refer to the band as 'Mick Jagger,' after all. I for one am rooting for WWIV. I need something to distract me from these North Korean ICBM's that keep buzzing our rooftops in LA.
Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Oh, ok. I guess a lot of 'casual' fans do refer to the band as 'Mick Jagger,' after all. I for one am rooting for WWIV. I need something to distract me from these North Korean ICBM's that keep buzzing our rooftops in LA.
Jeez no wonder you're drinking Patriotic Beer, sounds scary
Quote
LongBeachArena72Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Oh, ok. I guess a lot of 'casual' fans do refer to the band as 'Mick Jagger,' after all. I for one am rooting for WWIV. I need something to distract me from these North Korean ICBM's that keep buzzing our rooftops in LA.
Quote
35loveQuote
LongBeachArena72Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Oh, ok. I guess a lot of 'casual' fans do refer to the band as 'Mick Jagger,' after all. I for one am rooting for WWIV. I need something to distract me from these North Korean ICBM's that keep buzzing our rooftops in LA.
*if I were poetic, I'd try to explain the F. It attitude/ tomorrow's uncertain/ who cares feel to the place but for these tethers, I mean kids... or is that 50?
Quote
stone4everQuote
35loveQuote
LongBeachArena72Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Oh, ok. I guess a lot of 'casual' fans do refer to the band as 'Mick Jagger,' after all. I for one am rooting for WWIV. I need something to distract me from these North Korean ICBM's that keep buzzing our rooftops in LA.
*if I were poetic, I'd try to explain the F. It attitude/ tomorrow's uncertain/ who cares feel to the place but for these tethers, I mean kids... or is that 50?
Not entirely sure what you are saying, you wish you was poetic so you could explain the fvck it attitude because tomorrows uncertain, but who cares anyway because you are tied to children and you are about 50. Is that right
Quote
35loveQuote
stone4everQuote
35loveQuote
LongBeachArena72Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Oh, ok. I guess a lot of 'casual' fans do refer to the band as 'Mick Jagger,' after all. I for one am rooting for WWIV. I need something to distract me from these North Korean ICBM's that keep buzzing our rooftops in LA.
*if I were poetic, I'd try to explain the F. It attitude/ tomorrow's uncertain/ who cares feel to the place but for these tethers, I mean kids... or is that 50?
Not entirely sure what you are saying, you wish you was poetic so you could explain the fvck it attitude because tomorrows uncertain, but who cares anyway because you are tied to children and you are about 50. Is that right
*Oh dear, this thread makes me woozy and too talkative. No, my life is good, I'm grateful, but there is a wandering spirit within. How's that?
Topic: IORR clues look today like new Jagger solo, doesn't it?
Truthfully, I want some new music and I'll buy and want what Mick gives, if it goes that way, and I can't control my music repeat selection based on who it comes from--
Quote
stone4everQuote
35loveQuote
stone4everQuote
35loveQuote
LongBeachArena72Quote
stone4everQuote
LongBeachArena72
I was off drinking way too much patriotic beer the last cpl of days and so missed the 'news': is it actually possible that we'll have a new 'Mick Jagger solo work' to dissect before there is another Stones opus to eviscerate? Color my mind boggled ...
LB i think that was fake news, no Jagger album that i know of. The video the girl was involved with might have been a Stones one unless we are in for WWIV.
I don't understand the secrecy of it all, perhaps there's method in their madness.
Oh, ok. I guess a lot of 'casual' fans do refer to the band as 'Mick Jagger,' after all. I for one am rooting for WWIV. I need something to distract me from these North Korean ICBM's that keep buzzing our rooftops in LA.
*if I were poetic, I'd try to explain the F. It attitude/ tomorrow's uncertain/ who cares feel to the place but for these tethers, I mean kids... or is that 50?
Not entirely sure what you are saying, you wish you was poetic so you could explain the fvck it attitude because tomorrows uncertain, but who cares anyway because you are tied to children and you are about 50. Is that right
*Oh dear, this thread makes me woozy and too talkative. No, my life is good, I'm grateful, but there is a wandering spirit within. How's that?
Topic: IORR clues look today like new Jagger solo, doesn't it?
Truthfully, I want some new music and I'll buy and want what Mick gives, if it goes that way, and I can't control my music repeat selection based on who it comes from--
Yep that will do nicely, very poetic .
I'd settle for a Mick solo album as it happens, anything, its been ten years.
I wonder what happened to these 40 demo's, perhaps Mick's got a double album coming.
Quote
stone4ever
...
I have studied this place over the years and its very telling, say for instance the album Dirty Work, apart from me and HMS everyone hates it even though there are tracks on it that they really like. Its so funny they don't want to be seen like the odd one out, its really not that bad an album, it stands up to all the crap that was released at the time it was released...
Quote
Rocky Dijon
It's not actually "fake news" when the person posting it says they're just speculating aloud and not teasing any insider secrets.
Here's what Mick had to say in March 2015 courtesy of [timeisonourside.com]
Mick: I don't know. It would be very nice and I've got a lot of new songs and songs I've written over the last couple of years. I've done really good demos for all of them, which I would love to record. So, let's hope so... I haven't (thought about making a solo album). I'd love to record a Stones album. If that doesn't happen, then yes. That's a truthful answer. I've got songs that would be great for the Stones, and I've got songs that wouldn't be perfect for the Stones...I've been writing this week. I've written a lot of new songs lately, but we haven't recorded them yet. (They're about)just life in general, different subjects, personal things, social things.
Quote
stone4ever
I have studied this place over the years and its very telling, say for instance the album Dirty Work, apart from me and HMS everyone hates it even though there are tracks on it that they really like. Its so funny they don't want to be seen like the odd one out, its really not that bad an album, it stands up to all the crap that was released at the time it was released.
Dirty Work is just an example, Emotional Rescue is another, Its crap but because key members on here say its great everyone agrees.
The other thing i notice is how posters will completely turn 180 degrees on an opinion if a fellow poster they respect happens to disagree.
Even today i noticed myself not wanting to upset people who love Mick and his solo albums, so i find myself thinking Wandering Spirit is not so bad after all lol. It happens.
The thing i notice most of all is how someone you really like, and know to get along with will eventually dislike you if you disagree with their taste in music lol. People take it personal, we are still just primitive monkeys underneath the surface.