For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Bärs
There is something in the smoothness and timing which isn't exactly like Keith.
Quote
Bärs
There is something in the smoothness and timing which isn't exactly like Keith.
Quote
71Tele
Still have the original vinyl with the Jagger/Richards/Taylor credit on it. Anyone know why Taylor's name was later removed?
For those who think it can't be anyone but Richards on open G rhythm, listen to Stop Breaking Down or Sway (both Jagger), or Leather Jacket or Broken Man from Taylor's first post-Stones album.
Quote
jpasc95
yes they probably didn't find how to make this song more elaborate
but it's a good one though
I like the guitar's sound, to me it's Keith's one..
Quote
AmsterdamnedQuote
71Tele
Still have the original vinyl with the Jagger/Richards/Taylor credit on it. Anyone know why Taylor's name was later removed?
For those who think it can't be anyone but Richards on open G rhythm, listen to Stop Breaking Down or Sway (both Jagger), or Leather Jacket or Broken Man from Taylor's first post-Stones album.
I agree with you,Bars and Redhotcarpet that it's probably not Richards. Too heavy handed to play like this. Not 100% shure though.
Likely Jagger or Taylor
The song doesn't go anywhere imo,so in the end the guitar player doesn't save it either.
Quote
jpasc95
this is your opinion, no problem
maybe you're right
there is an example, we know that guitars on Sway are played by Taylor and Jagger, so...
Quote
Amsterdamned
Several people,, me included think it might be Jagger or Taylor.
with the exception of MR "Know it all", the most annoying person Ive never met , who attended the recording sessions.
Quote
Erik_Snow
To me - the guitar on "I'm Going Down" is extremely Keith-ish, in every way
It's only the "fake intro" (available on bootleg) that sounds different than Keith.....Keith doesn't stumble like that, usually
Apart from that, the guitar has the Keith style every step of the way, IMO
Quote
Mathijs
I always thought that the false-start intro is not how it was played, but a studio play-back. It sounds like the tape is rolled back or so. The false start and the actual start sound very much like identical copies.
Quote
benon again
Briliant track with great atmosphere.Extra bass and saxophone with trade mark riff.One of my favourities.
Quote
Amsterdamned
Take it easy on your insults......Mathijs have incredible knowledge beyond most of us on this board, especially when it comes to guitar-parts of recorded RS songs <Eric Snow>
That's no insult. It's quite annoying and rude when someone puts opinions Aplomb, and wiping others people remarks under the carpet.
One cannot know for sure this is Richards. I think and listen for myself, especially when it comes to Taylor Richards discussions.
Respect other peoples opinions,that's all I wanna say,unless the truth is crystal clear
Quote
His Majesty
Quote
Amsterdamned
Taylor & Jagger are great rythm players too in a more subtle way, and able to copy or come close to Keith.