For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Captain TeagueQuote
JumpingKentFlash
It was part of the RS69TRAX yes. I think there was all of it. I saw The Sun Is Shining and Brown Sugar, and a slew of other tracks from Altamont. It sounded like the well known bootleg of that show. I could be mistaking though.
I have not heard any of the RS69TRAX 'release' but surely ABKCO could not release an audience recording as part of a copyright extension?
Quote
bigmac7895
I also think the MR, SCB and Ruby Tuesday are from tour rehearsals in the Fall of 1969. You can tell they are trying to figure out the groove for Rambler and Stray Cat as to what it would become, but clearly after Hyde Park.
Quote
thkbeercan
1968: SFTD-from the Rock and Roll Circus, one of the early takes, not used in the video.
Quote
axl79
Here comes a re-upload of the first part.
I have re-tagged the files and removed some remaining "bleeps".
Some notes (tnx to thkbeercan and Gazza for the summary)
Ruby Tuesday-a complete, an early attempt at the song with Brian Jones on piano. (He also played piano, and recorder, in the final version.) (1966)
Love In Vain -one of the earliest attempts at the song, similar to the Robert Johnson arrangement (1969)
Sister Morphine-the same early version found on many bootlegs, but this is the complete take, 90 seconds longer (1969)
YCAGWYW-22 minutes of the London Bach Choir working on their vocals...lots of giggling and no complete performance of the song...interesting to listen to...once. (1969)
Wild Horses-the acoustic Muscle Shoals take from December 1969 but with strings added sometime in 1970.
Gimme Shelter that ABKCO made available isn't from 1969 as claimed but is (bizarrely) a 1978 tour rehearsal
[we.tl]
Quote
DandelionPowderman
Not Brian on piano.
Quote
JMARKOQuote
axl79
Link to some more tracks (upon JMARKOs request)
Sympathy, Stray Cat, Midnight Rambler, Honky Tonk Women (country rock), and Let It Bleed.
[we.tl]
Thanks for your time and work. Appreciated by many.
J
Quote
DandelionPowderman
Not Brian on piano.
Quote
axl79Quote
DandelionPowderman
Not Brian on piano.
According to Martin Elliot's Book
Ruby Tuesday was recorded between 16 nov - 6 Dec 1966 at Olympic Sound Studios.
"The piano accompaniment by Brian Jones and keyboards by Jack Nitzsche...."
"The song was written almost exclusively by Keith and Brian and is said to be about a well-known groupie.."
Quote
His MajestyQuote
axl79
Here comes a re-upload of the first part.
I have re-tagged the files and removed some remaining "bleeps".
Some notes (tnx to thkbeercan and Gazza for the summary)
Ruby Tuesday-a complete, an early attempt at the song with Brian Jones on piano. (He also played piano, and recorder, in the final version.) (1966)
Love In Vain -one of the earliest attempts at the song, similar to the Robert Johnson arrangement (1969)
Sister Morphine-the same early version found on many bootlegs, but this is the complete take, 90 seconds longer (1969)
YCAGWYW-22 minutes of the London Bach Choir working on their vocals...lots of giggling and no complete performance of the song...interesting to listen to...once. (1969)
Wild Horses-the acoustic Muscle Shoals take from December 1969 but with strings added sometime in 1970.
Gimme Shelter that ABKCO made available isn't from 1969 as claimed but is (bizarrely) a 1978 tour rehearsal
[we.tl]
RT is not from 1966 nor does it feature Brian playing piano.
Quote
funkydrummerQuote
His MajestyQuote
axl79
Here comes a re-upload of the first part.
I have re-tagged the files and removed some remaining "bleeps".
Some notes (tnx to thkbeercan and Gazza for the summary)
Ruby Tuesday-a complete, an early attempt at the song with Brian Jones on piano. (He also played piano, and recorder, in the final version.) (1966)
Love In Vain -one of the earliest attempts at the song, similar to the Robert Johnson arrangement (1969)
Sister Morphine-the same early version found on many bootlegs, but this is the complete take, 90 seconds longer (1969)
YCAGWYW-22 minutes of the London Bach Choir working on their vocals...lots of giggling and no complete performance of the song...interesting to listen to...once. (1969)
Wild Horses-the acoustic Muscle Shoals take from December 1969 but with strings added sometime in 1970.
Gimme Shelter that ABKCO made available isn't from 1969 as claimed but is (bizarrely) a 1978 tour rehearsal
[we.tl]
RT is not from 1966 nor does it feature Brian playing piano.
OK - I am still waiting for evidence. Not just opinion. It is not clearly Nicky on piano - and as many have pointed out there is no reason for this not to be from 1966 - the absolute most probable scenario, because it doesn't fit any other likely scenario. "JLG says they did a version" - I am also a huge Godard fan and I have never read this. Ockham's razor here. Anyway, the sad thing is, the Stones archives will always sadly be in such disarray that this will be a likely source of contention for the foreseeable future. Except to me. It is an earlier take from 1966. It sounds fuller and in better fidelity because as Mick commented on BTB tracks - they overdubbed and bounced those so much they sounded like crap - one can compare to the backing tracks that emerged on Black Box that sound so much better even without the vocal ODs and compression. Anyway - I am gonna leave this one now,
Quote
His MajestyQuote
axl79Quote
DandelionPowderman
Not Brian on piano.
According to Martin Elliot's Book
Ruby Tuesday was recorded between 16 nov - 6 Dec 1966 at Olympic Sound Studios.
"The piano accompaniment by Brian Jones and keyboards by Jack Nitzsche...."
"The song was written almost exclusively by Keith and Brian and is said to be about a well-known groupie.."
Focus on this new recording. It is Nicky playing piano. Most definitely not Brian Jones.
Quote
JordyLicks96Quote
funkydrummerQuote
His MajestyQuote
axl79
Here comes a re-upload of the first part.
I have re-tagged the files and removed some remaining "bleeps".
Some notes (tnx to thkbeercan and Gazza for the summary)
Ruby Tuesday-a complete, an early attempt at the song with Brian Jones on piano. (He also played piano, and recorder, in the final version.) (1966)
Love In Vain -one of the earliest attempts at the song, similar to the Robert Johnson arrangement (1969)
Sister Morphine-the same early version found on many bootlegs, but this is the complete take, 90 seconds longer (1969)
YCAGWYW-22 minutes of the London Bach Choir working on their vocals...lots of giggling and no complete performance of the song...interesting to listen to...once. (1969)
Wild Horses-the acoustic Muscle Shoals take from December 1969 but with strings added sometime in 1970.
Gimme Shelter that ABKCO made available isn't from 1969 as claimed but is (bizarrely) a 1978 tour rehearsal
[we.tl]
RT is not from 1966 nor does it feature Brian playing piano.
OK - I am still waiting for evidence. Not just opinion. It is not clearly Nicky on piano - and as many have pointed out there is no reason for this not to be from 1966 - the absolute most probable scenario, because it doesn't fit any other likely scenario. "JLG says they did a version" - I am also a huge Godard fan and I have never read this. Ockham's razor here. Anyway, the sad thing is, the Stones archives will always sadly be in such disarray that this will be a likely source of contention for the foreseeable future. Except to me. It is an earlier take from 1966. It sounds fuller and in better fidelity because as Mick commented on BTB tracks - they overdubbed and bounced those so much they sounded like crap - one can compare to the backing tracks that emerged on Black Box that sound so much better even without the vocal ODs and compression. Anyway - I am gonna leave this one now,
I just want to understand the people throwing out there that it's Nicky on piano. Why are people so bent on this not being from 1966? Within seconds they apparently know it's Nicky and from 1969.
Quote
funkydrummerQuote
JordyLicks96Quote
funkydrummerQuote
His MajestyQuote
axl79
Here comes a re-upload of the first part.
I have re-tagged the files and removed some remaining "bleeps".
Some notes (tnx to thkbeercan and Gazza for the summary)
Ruby Tuesday-a complete, an early attempt at the song with Brian Jones on piano. (He also played piano, and recorder, in the final version.) (1966)
Love In Vain -one of the earliest attempts at the song, similar to the Robert Johnson arrangement (1969)
Sister Morphine-the same early version found on many bootlegs, but this is the complete take, 90 seconds longer (1969)
YCAGWYW-22 minutes of the London Bach Choir working on their vocals...lots of giggling and no complete performance of the song...interesting to listen to...once. (1969)
Wild Horses-the acoustic Muscle Shoals take from December 1969 but with strings added sometime in 1970.
Gimme Shelter that ABKCO made available isn't from 1969 as claimed but is (bizarrely) a 1978 tour rehearsal
[we.tl]
RT is not from 1966 nor does it feature Brian playing piano.
OK - I am still waiting for evidence. Not just opinion. It is not clearly Nicky on piano - and as many have pointed out there is no reason for this not to be from 1966 - the absolute most probable scenario, because it doesn't fit any other likely scenario. "JLG says they did a version" - I am also a huge Godard fan and I have never read this. Ockham's razor here. Anyway, the sad thing is, the Stones archives will always sadly be in such disarray that this will be a likely source of contention for the foreseeable future. Except to me. It is an earlier take from 1966. It sounds fuller and in better fidelity because as Mick commented on BTB tracks - they overdubbed and bounced those so much they sounded like crap - one can compare to the backing tracks that emerged on Black Box that sound so much better even without the vocal ODs and compression. Anyway - I am gonna leave this one now,
I just want to understand the people throwing out there that it's Nicky on piano. Why are people so bent on this not being from 1966? Within seconds they apparently know it's Nicky and from 1969.
JordyLicks - I think everything you have posted is on the money. I don't know either. I guess because "it sounds a bit like Nicky" - but I am not convinced either way. Until that time - a session from 66 is most probable. Definitely sounds like intonation and lyric choices from 66-67 era to me.
Quote
His Majesty
1969 is the starting point. No one has yet proven it isn't from 1969.
Quote
dcbaQuote
His Majesty
1969 is the starting point. No one has yet proven it isn't from 1969.
ABKCO have tried to sell us a 1969 "shelter" that was recorded 9 years later... It took the most perspicacious IORR members (not me btw...) about 10 minutes to find the correct attribution for this track.
Quote
His MajestyQuote
dcbaQuote
His Majesty
1969 is the starting point. No one has yet proven it isn't from 1969.
ABKCO have tried to sell us a 1969 "shelter" that was recorded 9 years later... It took the most perspicacious IORR members (not me btw...) about 10 minutes to find the correct attribution for this track.
Yes, but I am talking about this new Ruby Tuesday.
Quote
His Majesty
1969 is the starting point. No one has yet proven it isn't from 1969.
I have musically been studying Brian for about 30 years. It is absolutely not him playing piano on this RT.
The piano has various signatures that Nicky often played. Similar with Charlie in relation to 1968/69.
Quote
axl79
Here comes a re-upload of the first part.
I have re-tagged the files and removed some remaining "bleeps".
Some notes (tnx to thkbeercan and Gazza for the summary)
Ruby Tuesday-a complete, an early attempt at the song with Brian Jones on piano. (He also played piano, and recorder, in the final version.) (1966)
Love In Vain -one of the earliest attempts at the song, similar to the Robert Johnson arrangement (1969)
Sister Morphine-the same early version found on many bootlegs, but this is the complete take, 90 seconds longer (1969)
YCAGWYW-22 minutes of the London Bach Choir working on their vocals...lots of giggling and no complete performance of the song...interesting to listen to...once. (1969)
Wild Horses-the acoustic Muscle Shoals take from December 1969 but with strings added sometime in 1970.
Gimme Shelter that ABKCO made available isn't from 1969 as claimed but is (bizarrely) a 1978 tour rehearsal
[we.tl]
Quote
axl79
axl79
Link to some more tracks (upon JMARKOs request)
Sympathy, Stray Cat, Midnight Rambler, Honky Tonk Women (country rock), and Let It Bleed.
[we.tl]
Quote
NikkeiQuote
His Majesty
1969 is the starting point. No one has yet proven it isn't from 1969.
I have musically been studying Brian for about 30 years. It is absolutely not him playing piano on this RT.
The piano has various signatures that Nicky often played. Similar with Charlie in relation to 1968/69.
That's being dogmatic, but I guess it can happen if you study the same thing over and over for 30 years. When you hear The Who's "Lets See Action" for the first time, that would be an instance where you can tell it's Nicky in a split second. How about you focus on the drums and Micks pronunciation instead.
Quote
JordyLicks96
Why has ABKCO included this, calling it an early 1969 version? Why are recordings form 1966, 1968 and 1970 identified as being from 1969?