For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Taylor1. But doesn’t Taylor overdub some lead lines toward the end of the song?Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
micawber
I LUV the truly great rhythm work on Star Star. Keith shines on that.
Taylor plays the rhythm guitar. Keith plays lead.
Quote
bitusa2012
All this talk of Star Star....I’ll be right royally pi55ed off if ‘pu55y clean‘ is SABOTAGED the way the last remasters were. At the prices we’ve all paid for the deluxe BOXES, they’d better be clean BOXES, as in, unmuddled like they were in those last sacrilegious remasters.
Quote
Father Ted
If they ever tour again, they should replace IORR with StarFacker
Quote
Taylor1
They should try to play IORR in the tempo of the studio version,especially since Jagger is obsessed for 30 years with recreating the studio versions live.They have never played IORR live like the studio version,except on the IORR sailor video, Which I think used the studio song backing track.Maybe it sounds too much like Bang the Gong
Quote
Taylor1
They should try to play IORR in the tempo of the studio version,especially since Jagger is obsessed for 30 years with recreating the studio versions live.They have never played IORR live like the studio version,except on the IORR sailor video, Which I think used the studio song backing track.Maybe it sounds too much like Bang the Gong
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
Taylor1
They should try to play IORR in the tempo of the studio version,especially since Jagger is obsessed for 30 years with recreating the studio versions live.They have never played IORR live like the studio version,except on the IORR sailor video, Which I think used the studio song backing track.Maybe it sounds too much like Bang the Gong
That was a new recording of IORR used for the video.
Quote
hockenheim95Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
Taylor1
They should try to play IORR in the tempo of the studio version,especially since Jagger is obsessed for 30 years with recreating the studio versions live.They have never played IORR live like the studio version,except on the IORR sailor video, Which I think used the studio song backing track.Maybe it sounds too much like Bang the Gong
That was a new recording of IORR used for the video.
Album and video versions are completely different songs for me. They've got nothing in Common but the Lyrics. I would love an official release of that Version.
This is old SHM-SACD release from 2014. It has nothing to do with current reissue.Quote
exilestones
Goats Head Soup [SHM-SACD] [Limited Release]
Catalog No. UIGY-9581
JAN/ISBN 4988005857330
Product Type SACD SHM
Super Audio CD (SACD) disc is not compatible with regular CD player or drive. This disc format is compatible only with SACD player.
[Special Priced 100 SHM-SACD Reissues] Uses the 2011 DSD master based on UK original analog tape. Originally released in 1973.
Reissue features the high-fidelity SHM-SACD format (fully compatible with standard SACD player, but it does not play on
standard CD players).
In this series, the following albums are from the band: "Big Hits (High Tide And Green Grass)," "Their Satanic Majesties Request,"
"Beggars Banquet," "Through The Past. Darkly (Big Hits Vol.2),""Let It Bleed," "STICKY FINGERS," "Exile On Main St.," "Goats Head Soup,"
"It's Only Rock 'n Roll," "Black And Blue," "Love You Live," "Some Girls," "Emotional Rescure," "Tattoo You,"
"Still Life (American Concert 1981)," "Undercover," and "Dirty Work."
Please note that this special priced reissue does not feature the cardboard mini LP sleeve previously featured. Instead, it comes housed in a jewel case.
Comes with a description and lyrics.
[www.cdjapan.co.jp]
Quote
Chris Fountain
....save me
It's so bad that pic wouldn't even make the album cover of Exile on Main Street.
Quote
Doxa
But they have very rarely played those any longer, not even when Chuck died.
- Doxa
Quote
DoxaQuote
Father Ted
If they ever tour again, they should replace IORR with StarFacker
I don't know what it is but I think they always play better Chuck Berry originals than their own pastishes of those. Especially with "Little Queenie" they just can do no wrong. But they have very rarely played those any longer, not even when Chuck died.
Like listening to BLUE & LONESOME - is it like that that stuff is so strongly build in their DNA that it just comes so naturally out of them. Being inspired but still with a certain humble and respecting attitude.
Surely there has been some cool versions both of "Starbucker" and "Only R&R", especially during classical 1973/75/76/78 tours, but I have always felt that they haven't ever been able to treat those gems right live - or to find a road version working great enough. Especially Jagger has had difficulties to know how to deliver them. For example, I always find his ways of singing/shouting the choruses a bit flat. Those parts that I always have found so capturing in the studio originals (when SCREAMING THE POINT!!). In one thread someone posted a rather recent version of "Star Star" - which wasn't any strong version in any sense of the word - but even there Jagger just couldn't stay in a key during the chorus. Not a big thing, but for some reason that always hurts my ear...
- Doxa
Quote
TravelinManQuote
Taylor1. But doesn’t Taylor overdub some lead lines toward the end of the song?Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
micawber
I LUV the truly great rhythm work on Star Star. Keith shines on that.
Taylor plays the rhythm guitar. Keith plays lead.
I don’t think he overdubs anything, it sounds like he just throws some tasty low register licks in.
Quote
Father TedQuote
DoxaQuote
Father Ted
If they ever tour again, they should replace IORR with StarFacker
I don't know what it is but I think they always play better Chuck Berry originals than their own pastishes of those. Especially with "Little Queenie" they just can do no wrong. But they have very rarely played those any longer, not even when Chuck died.
Like listening to BLUE & LONESOME - is it like that that stuff is so strongly build in their DNA that it just comes so naturally out of them. Being inspired but still with a certain humble and respecting attitude.
Surely there has been some cool versions both of "Starbucker" and "Only R&R", especially during classical 1973/75/76/78 tours, but I have always felt that they haven't ever been able to treat those gems right live - or to find a road version working great enough. Especially Jagger has had difficulties to know how to deliver them. For example, I always find his ways of singing/shouting the choruses a bit flat. Those parts that I always have found so capturing in the studio originals (when SCREAMING THE POINT!!). In one thread someone posted a rather recent version of "Star Star" - which wasn't any strong version in any sense of the word - but even there Jagger just couldn't stay in a key during the chorus. Not a big thing, but for some reason that always hurts my ear...
- Doxa
The live IORR has always been a horrid pseudo-Berry number and a reinstated Starbucker would probably end up the same, but I'm tired of hearing IORR. It's a shame that the road version of IORR never even tried to replicate the studio intro. Maybe you're right and they should just ditch both of them and try Bye Bye Johnny instead.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
TravelinManQuote
Taylor1. But doesn’t Taylor overdub some lead lines toward the end of the song?Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
micawber
I LUV the truly great rhythm work on Star Star. Keith shines on that.
Taylor plays the rhythm guitar. Keith plays lead.
I don’t think he overdubs anything, it sounds like he just throws some tasty low register licks in.
Where in the song is that? I can't remember any lead lines from Taylor at all.
Quote
TIRED
Some of the lyrics in UNDER MY THUMB were also changed during the No-Filter tour,
Quote
TIRED
Not sure this has been discussed in this forum already...
There was a Stones release of STAR STAR some years ago in which the part "keep your pussy clean" was overdubbed in such a way that the words could hardly be heard.
Can we expect the same mutilation in the new GHS release?
What's the general opinion on such alterations of past Stones songs?
Some of the lyrics in UNDER MY THUMB were also changed during the No-Filter tour, I wonder what/who led to that regrettable decision.
Bending to political correctness somehow contradicts the freedom the Stones always stood for.
Quote
TravelinManQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
TravelinManQuote
Taylor1. But doesn’t Taylor overdub some lead lines toward the end of the song?Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
micawber
I LUV the truly great rhythm work on Star Star. Keith shines on that.
Taylor plays the rhythm guitar. Keith plays lead.
I don’t think he overdubs anything, it sounds like he just throws some tasty low register licks in.
Where in the song is that? I can't remember any lead lines from Taylor at all.
In the outro. I'm probably thinking of the live version, actually. I don't think I've listed to the studio version in a while.
Quote
thkbeercan
Does anyone know the dimensions of the deluxe box set?