For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
Quote
MathijsQuote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
On the Rotterdam Rehearsals Keith plays the same rhythm track, not for note, while Taylor is trying out various nice licks over it.
Mathijs
Quote
TheflyingDutchmanQuote
MathijsQuote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
On the Rotterdam Rehearsals Keith plays the same rhythm track, not for note, while Taylor is trying out various nice licks over it.
Mathijs
Yep. Maybe Keith tried to play (Taylor's?) rhythm part from the studio and then switched to the rhytm part we can hear on the '73 live versions. That's quite different and more heavy stuff.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
TheflyingDutchmanQuote
MathijsQuote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
On the Rotterdam Rehearsals Keith plays the same rhythm track, not for note, while Taylor is trying out various nice licks over it.
Mathijs
Yep. Maybe Keith tried to play (Taylor's?) rhythm part from the studio and then switched to the rhytm part we can hear on the '73 live versions. That's quite different and more heavy stuff.All I can add is that good old Bård mentioned that Keith himself said he only played bas on the studio track. But that's years ago, the track talk on which I just looked.
It's pretty similar. The main difference is how the G is played. On GHS it's played in the 10th position. Live it's (from what I can hear) played in the third position).
However, Keith played the Em/Em7-stuff very similar to the album version - to the point that he screws up the rhythm at the very same place (like on the album - compare the first and second verse line).
If I was forced to put money on this, I'd say the studio version is Taylor, though
Quote
Rockman
JB -HiFi .... walk in tamorrow and grab one ...
Quote
OpenG
Sorry to change the subject - On Coming Down Again who is the female singing backup vocals with Keith,Mick and MT.
Quote
jbwelda
That original parcel may still show up on your doorstep and it will be free!
jb
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
TheflyingDutchmanQuote
MathijsQuote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
On the Rotterdam Rehearsals Keith plays the same rhythm track, not for note, while Taylor is trying out various nice licks over it.
Mathijs
Yep. Maybe Keith tried to play (Taylor's?) rhythm part from the studio and then switched to the rhytm part we can hear on the '73 live versions. That's quite different and more heavy stuff.
It's pretty similar. The main difference is how the G is played. On GHS it's played in the 10th position. Live it's (from what I can hear) played in the third position).
However, Keith played the Em/Em7-stuff very similar to the album version - to the point that he screws up the rhythm at the very same place (like on the album - compare the first and second verse line).
If I was forced to put money on this, I'd say the studio version is Taylor, though
Quote
MathijsQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
TheflyingDutchmanQuote
MathijsQuote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
On the Rotterdam Rehearsals Keith plays the same rhythm track, not for note, while Taylor is trying out various nice licks over it.
Mathijs
Yep. Maybe Keith tried to play (Taylor's?) rhythm part from the studio and then switched to the rhytm part we can hear on the '73 live versions. That's quite different and more heavy stuff.
It's pretty similar. The main difference is how the G is played. On GHS it's played in the 10th position. Live it's (from what I can hear) played in the third position).
However, Keith played the Em/Em7-stuff very similar to the album version - to the point that he screws up the rhythm at the very same place (like on the album - compare the first and second verse line).
If I was forced to put money on this, I'd say the studio version is Taylor, though
I think it is Richards, as the part is really similar to the rehearsals and the live versions, and it's fairly similar to Keith's part of Time Waits. Also, I don't know of any other Taylor part that's quite similar.
Mathijs
Quote
MathijsQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
TheflyingDutchmanQuote
MathijsQuote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
On the Rotterdam Rehearsals Keith plays the same rhythm track, not for note, while Taylor is trying out various nice licks over it.
Mathijs
Yep. Maybe Keith tried to play (Taylor's?) rhythm part from the studio and then switched to the rhytm part we can hear on the '73 live versions. That's quite different and more heavy stuff.
It's pretty similar. The main difference is how the G is played. On GHS it's played in the 10th position. Live it's (from what I can hear) played in the third position).
However, Keith played the Em/Em7-stuff very similar to the album version - to the point that he screws up the rhythm at the very same place (like on the album - compare the first and second verse line).
If I was forced to put money on this, I'd say the studio version is Taylor, though
I think it is Richards, as the part is really similar to the rehearsals and the live versions, and it's fairly similar to Keith's part of Time Waits. Also, I don't know of any other Taylor part that's quite similar.
Mathijs
Quote
TravelinManQuote
MathijsQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
TheflyingDutchmanQuote
MathijsQuote
TheflyingDutchman
Both Keith and Taylor could have played rhythm guitar on the studio version. On the live version (London'73)you can hear Taylor and Richards playing the same powerchords. (in the beginning).On the studio version the rhythm guitar is not as aggressive as Keith's rhythm guitar on the live version.So a good chance it's Taylor in the studio playing the rhythm part as well. Take what you like.
On the Rotterdam Rehearsals Keith plays the same rhythm track, not for note, while Taylor is trying out various nice licks over it.
Mathijs
Yep. Maybe Keith tried to play (Taylor's?) rhythm part from the studio and then switched to the rhytm part we can hear on the '73 live versions. That's quite different and more heavy stuff.
It's pretty similar. The main difference is how the G is played. On GHS it's played in the 10th position. Live it's (from what I can hear) played in the third position).
However, Keith played the Em/Em7-stuff very similar to the album version - to the point that he screws up the rhythm at the very same place (like on the album - compare the first and second verse line).
If I was forced to put money on this, I'd say the studio version is Taylor, though
I think it is Richards, as the part is really similar to the rehearsals and the live versions, and it's fairly similar to Keith's part of Time Waits. Also, I don't know of any other Taylor part that's quite similar.
Mathijs
I’m thinking that guitar is Richards as well. I think the quote that is associated with Heartbreaker is incorrect, and Richards meant to say 100 Years ago. That makes so much more sense with Taylor on wah and Richards on Bass.
Also, I hear an acoustic in the new mix (1st chorus) as well as some buried Taylor guitar in the outro. One note in particular has operatic vibrato (3:02-3:03).
Quote
Mathijs
I think it is Richards, as the part is really similar to the rehearsals and the live versions, and it's fairly similar to Keith's part of Time Waits. Also, I don't know of any other Taylor part that's quite similar.
Mathijs
Quote
jbwelda
Terrible guitar players like Jeff Beck?
sheesh. Unbelievable.
jb
Quote
SighuntQuote
bitusa2012
I like it. But the video? Now, I’m a red blooded male. But that’s crass from a band pushing into their 80s. Do they really think in 2020, that’s appropriate?
I remember many of us squirmed with Keith’s “Bare your breasts And let me feel at home” line, at his age, from This Place is Empty in 2005. 15 years later we get this tawdry video...
After the refreshing Living in a ghost Town video, this one is dreadful.
But I like the song.
For me, it is not that I'm a prude, I just think that the video is pointless. Here you are the Rolling Stones who are showcasing (arguably) one of their better outtake/rarities for the world to hear for the first time, and you match it up with a T & A video coming from guys in their 70's...C'mon!
Here is the link for San Jose DVD+2CDQuote
Whale
One more question.
I wanted to buy the japanese CD to have the two extra songs.
There was a german webshop I believe where you can do that.
Can somebody point me to the right item?
Same question for the San Jose CD.
Thanks!