Quote
slewan

what did you expect? A critical edition meeting the philological state of the art?
It's just another hits collection plus a bonus CD being released at the beginning of a tour and ment to rip of fans

Meh.
We're talking less money than a t-shirt here, sign me up a couple versions of this.
The live cuts alone are worth it, and looking forward to the few alternate versions. The live tracks capture what The Rolling Stones do best, still, and are the reason they pack stadiums and are very much a relevant force. Fortunate to have been in attendance for a couple of them and from first (and some second ) listen they are fantastic! Going to buy cd's today, and looking forward to a red vinyl version from the shows.

Quote
Irix

Quote
BowieStone

It also has the date of Wild Horses wrong. It's all very messy. Nobody checked or read what was printed. Principality Stadium with no city added to it, "Shine A Light Live at Arena, Amsterdam" but "Under My Thumb Live at London Stadium".

What's wrong with it? This list should be correct: [iorr.org] ?

The name of that arena is the Amsterdam Arena or even better: Johan Cruijff Arena.
“Live at arena” makes no sense.

Just listen live tracks.
Well...
Floating, nothing transcendent.
And I can't stand Chuck playing anymore, sorry...

Mick is great.

***
I'm just a Bad Boy Boogie



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-04-19 16:17 by powerage78.

Quote
slewan

Quote
BowieStone

Quote
Matt1984

I really hope the physical release hasn’t made the mistake of saying this song was performed at the Arena.

It has. It also has the date of Wild Horses wrong. It's all very messy. Nobody checked or read what was printed. Principality Stadium with no city added to it, "Shine A Light Live at Arena, Amsterdam" but "Under My Thumb Live at London Stadium".


The booklet is packed with mistakes. Especially in the who played what section.

what did you expect? A critical edition meeting the philological state of the art?
It's just another hits collection plus a bonus CD being released at the beginning of a tour and ment to rip of fans

What a load of BS.
What’s wrong with expecting correct info?

Just a millennial boy that found Jump Back and copied the design...

[www.debutart.com]

I don't understand why some of you waste your energy complaining about every single misspelling or mistake in the linear notes. Couldn't care less about that. If the performances and the mixes are good (and they are) then I am happy.

Great to hear official versions of Mr. D and Under My Thumb, both songs that I heard on many concerts during the No Filter tour and that bring back great memories from opening night in Hamburg until my last concert in Prague.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-04-19 16:26 by StonedRambler.

Quote
BowieStone

The name of that arena is the Amsterdam Arena or even better: Johan Cruijff Arena. “Live at arena” makes no sense.

The 'Amsterdam ArenA' (1996–2018) was renamed in Spring 2018 into 'Johan Cruijff ArenA' while the Stones played there on 30-Sep-2017 -- [nl.Wikipedia.org] .

Wow that Doom And Gloom version rocks quite hard!!

Was Doom And Gloom completely re-recorded in the February sessions? Sounds like it

Quote
Irix

Quote
BowieStone

The name of that arena is the Amsterdam Arena or even better: Johan Cruijff Arena. “Live at arena” makes no sense.

The 'Amsterdam ArenA' (1996–2018) was renamed in Spring 2018 into 'Johan Cruijff ArenA' while the Stones played there on 30-Sep-2017 -- [nl.Wikipedia.org] .

It was already called Johan Cruijff Arena at the time, only it was not official yet. That was constantly pushed back
That’s why I said: “the name of the arena is the Amsterdam Arena.”

What is the booklet like? Many photos?

Quote
BowieStone

Quote
slewan

Quote
BowieStone

Quote
Matt1984

I really hope the physical release hasn’t made the mistake of saying this song was performed at the Arena.

It has. It also has the date of Wild Horses wrong. It's all very messy. Nobody checked or read what was printed. Principality Stadium with no city added to it, "Shine A Light Live at Arena, Amsterdam" but "Under My Thumb Live at London Stadium".


The booklet is packed with mistakes. Especially in the who played what section.

what did you expect? A critical edition meeting the philological state of the art?
It's just another hits collection plus a bonus CD being released at the beginning of a tour and ment to rip of fans

What a load of BS.
What’s wrong with expecting correct info?

my point is just that they rushed this compilation out and didn't have (or took) time to cross-check everything. Of course they should have done it!

Honk, Honk, can anyone say how's the pictures in the booklet, anything interesting?

Quote
IrelandCalling4

What is the booklet like? Many photos?

Quote
frankotero

Honk, Honk, can anyone say how's the pictures in the booklet, anything interesting?

Unboxing - The Rolling Stones: Honk 3CD Deluxe (SHM-CD) - [www.YouTube.com] .

Another 3CD-Unboxing: [www.YouTube.com] .

Quote
slewan

Quote
BowieStone

Quote
slewan

Quote
BowieStone

Quote
Matt1984

I really hope the physical release hasn’t made the mistake of saying this song was performed at the Arena.

It has. It also has the date of Wild Horses wrong. It's all very messy. Nobody checked or read what was printed. Principality Stadium with no city added to it, "Shine A Light Live at Arena, Amsterdam" but "Under My Thumb Live at London Stadium".


The booklet is packed with mistakes. Especially in the who played what section.

what did you expect? A critical edition meeting the philological state of the art?
It's just another hits collection plus a bonus CD being released at the beginning of a tour and ment to rip of fans

What a load of BS.
What’s wrong with expecting correct info?

my point is just that they rushed this compilation out and didn't have (or took) time to cross-check everything. Of course they should have done it!

While I would ordinarily agree that level of professionalism is expected, historically speaking, Stones albums have always had misprints, incorrect song titles, etc on them dating all the way back to their first album.

That “oh, well” attitude is part of the reason we love them so much, is it not?

Thank you lrix, very cool.

Cool photos on the 3 CD deluxe; 2 CD deluxe just the booklet I guess. Overall nice packaging though.

Of course I will get the 3CD version tomorrow when the stores are open here in Germany, not today though.

I have n idea when i will get mine, cause i ordered it through the RS online store.
Blue And Lonesome came 2-3 weeks after the release date, i hope ill get mine next week.

Terrible version of Get Off Of My Cloud on it: I prefer the San Diego version.

Yesterday I looked in "M" Mueller and Media Markt where I live but no luck. Sometimes they put them out in a case like this, but no luck this time.

I wonder when I'll get mine. I ordered from the online store. Hope it's soon!

Quote
Karlos123

Quote
makustone
I'm listening to HONK on Spotify and I notice that Doom And Gloom and Ride 'Em On Down are different versions of the original ones! Especially in Ride 'Em On Down Mick sings it differently and harmonica solo is different! For these things I love the Stones more than my life! Did anyone notice something different in other songs on the album?

You‘re right - noticed differences in Doom and Gloom as well. Intonation in the second verse is different (garbage dump, end up drunk). I like this version! Even more aggressive!

And Charlie is playing as well, not the Band-In-A-Box kind of thing they used on GRRR!

Quote
frankotero
Yesterday I looked in "M" Mueller and Media Markt where I live but no luck. Sometimes they put them out in a case like this, but no luck this time.

In Portugal it was in some stores at April 17

Quote
MacLaurens

Quote
Karlos123

Quote
makustone
I'm listening to HONK on Spotify and I notice that Doom And Gloom and Ride 'Em On Down are different versions of the original ones! Especially in Ride 'Em On Down Mick sings it differently and harmonica solo is different! For these things I love the Stones more than my life! Did anyone notice something different in other songs on the album?

You‘re right - noticed differences in Doom and Gloom as well. Intonation in the second verse is different (garbage dump, end up drunk). I like this version! Even more aggressive!

And Charlie is playing as well, not the Band-In-A-Box kind of thing they used on GRRR!

Are you shure this isn't the normal Grrr Version? I haven't heard Honk now but the Grrr Version was different to the YouTube/single Version. I Just can't believe we have a third version now

HONK review:
There is something for everybody here.
I have already carved out my 3 keepers for my particular taste,
if you have other favorite flavors of the RS,
that is here too


I may have more than 3, thank you Rolling Stones !



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-04-19 22:55 by 35love.

Photo book did not airbrush out Bill . . . ha ha.

Anybody else having problems with Mac and CD player unable to read/display song titles on disc 2 and 3? Have not seen this problem before on a non-bootleg. Mac iTunes also thinks disc 1 is Japanese single disc version.

I'm in the US in case that makes a difference.

HBK

Quote
hockenheim95

Quote
MacLaurens

Quote
Karlos123

Quote
makustone
I'm listening to HONK on Spotify and I notice that Doom And Gloom and Ride 'Em On Down are different versions of the original ones! Especially in Ride 'Em On Down Mick sings it differently and harmonica solo is different! For these things I love the Stones more than my life! Did anyone notice something different in other songs on the album?

You‘re right - noticed differences in Doom and Gloom as well. Intonation in the second verse is different (garbage dump, end up drunk). I like this version! Even more aggressive!

And Charlie is playing as well, not the Band-In-A-Box kind of thing they used on GRRR!

Are you shure this isn't the normal Grrr Version? I haven't heard Honk now but the Grrr Version was different to the YouTube/single Version. I Just can't believe we have a third version now

I listened to both versions on Spotify:

Doom and Gloom is the GRRR! version. The other version used for the music video and lyric video is the Jeff Bahasker remix, which has a different lead vocal and the music I'm not too sure is different as well and Ride 'Em On Down is the EXACT version from BLUE & LONESOME. So unless you can post exactly what you're hearing, than they're both the same on HONK.

Quote
JordyLicks96

Quote
hockenheim95

Quote
MacLaurens

Quote
Karlos123

Quote
makustone
I'm listening to HONK on Spotify and I notice that Doom And Gloom and Ride 'Em On Down are different versions of the original ones! Especially in Ride 'Em On Down Mick sings it differently and harmonica solo is different! For these things I love the Stones more than my life! Did anyone notice something different in other songs on the album?

You‘re right - noticed differences in Doom and Gloom as well. Intonation in the second verse is different (garbage dump, end up drunk). I like this version! Even more aggressive!

And Charlie is playing as well, not the Band-In-A-Box kind of thing they used on GRRR!

Are you shure this isn't the normal Grrr Version? I haven't heard Honk now but the Grrr Version was different to the YouTube/single Version. I Just can't believe we have a third version now

I listened to both versions on Spotify:

Doom and Gloom is the GRRR! version. The other version used for the music video and lyric video is the Jeff Bahasker remix, which has a different lead vocal and the music I'm not too sure is different as well and Ride 'Em On Down is the EXACT version from BLUE & LONESOME. So unless you can post exactly what you're hearing, than they're both the same on HONK.

You may be right there about DaG. I also tried to find differences with REOD but couldn't find any. It is the same version.