For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
Quote
matxilQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
I think Talk Is Cheap, Main Offender and Crosseyed Heart are all tree very good, but all have their weak points. In that sense, Crosseyed Heart is the "best" since its only weak point is the Blues In The Morning cacaphony. Talk Is Cheap was a great surprise, and has a lot of great stuff to offer, but the production could have been better, and the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice (and again: the production doesn't help either, I could imagine live it could sound much steamier). Main Offender has the most weak songs (Yap Yap, Body Talks), but I love Wicked and Hate It When You Leave, and I've come to appreciate the odd Will But You Won't / Running Too Deep copy/paste sequence.
Quote
matxilQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
I think Talk Is Cheap, Main Offender and Crosseyed Heart are all tree very good, but all have their weak points. In that sense, Crosseyed Heart is the "best" since its only weak point is the Blues In The Morning cacaphony. Talk Is Cheap was a great surprise, and has a lot of great stuff to offer, but the production could have been better, and the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice (and again: the production doesn't help either, I could imagine live it could sound much steamier). Main Offender has the most weak songs (Yap Yap, Body Talks), but I love Wicked and Hate It When You Leave, and I've come to appreciate the odd Will But You Won't / Running Too Deep copy/paste sequence.
Quote
MaindefenderQuote
matxilQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
I think Talk Is Cheap, Main Offender and Crosseyed Heart are all tree very good, but all have their weak points. In that sense, Crosseyed Heart is the "best" since its only weak point is the Blues In The Morning cacaphony. Talk Is Cheap was a great surprise, and has a lot of great stuff to offer, but the production could have been better, and the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice (and again: the production doesn't help either, I could imagine live it could sound much steamier). Main Offender has the most weak songs (Yap Yap, Body Talks), but I love Wicked and Hate It When You Leave, and I've come to appreciate the odd Will But You Won't / Running Too Deep copy/paste sequence.
Weird I thought from first listen and still think Blues In The Morning is brilliant lyrically and musically. Let's face it so many of Keith's songs would be great Rolling Stones songs.
Quote
MaindefenderQuote
matxilQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
I think Talk Is Cheap, Main Offender and Crosseyed Heart are all tree very good, but all have their weak points. In that sense, Crosseyed Heart is the "best" since its only weak point is the Blues In The Morning cacaphony. Talk Is Cheap was a great surprise, and has a lot of great stuff to offer, but the production could have been better, and the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice (and again: the production doesn't help either, I could imagine live it could sound much steamier). Main Offender has the most weak songs (Yap Yap, Body Talks), but I love Wicked and Hate It When You Leave, and I've come to appreciate the odd Will But You Won't / Running Too Deep copy/paste sequence.
Weird I thought from first listen and still think Blues In The Morning is brilliant lyrically and musically. Let's face it so many of Keith's songs would be great Rolling Stones songs.
Quote
matxilQuote
MaindefenderQuote
matxilQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
I think Talk Is Cheap, Main Offender and Crosseyed Heart are all tree very good, but all have their weak points. In that sense, Crosseyed Heart is the "best" since its only weak point is the Blues In The Morning cacaphony. Talk Is Cheap was a great surprise, and has a lot of great stuff to offer, but the production could have been better, and the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice (and again: the production doesn't help either, I could imagine live it could sound much steamier). Main Offender has the most weak songs (Yap Yap, Body Talks), but I love Wicked and Hate It When You Leave, and I've come to appreciate the odd Will But You Won't / Running Too Deep copy/paste sequence.
Weird I thought from first listen and still think Blues In The Morning is brilliant lyrically and musically. Let's face it so many of Keith's songs would be great Rolling Stones songs.
I must be missing something. My girlfriend (not a huge Stones fan) likes that song also. I prefer to skip it, to me it just sounds like a very loud 12-bar boogie without anything special, just very loud and chaotic.
I am assuming that for you it's something like Black Limousine or Who's Driving Your Plane, (both of which I love), but for me it lacks control, clearity and direction. Never mind though, the rest of the album is great.
Quote
Spud
Blues in the Morning is just loud, exuberant Rock & Roll...
With plenty of Roll ... so what the f*** is wrong with that ?
Quote
liddas
Blues in the Morning is Tom Waits' Union Square part II!
C
Quote
Voodookitten76
Happy 2nd birthday Crosseyed Heart!!!! Two years on and this is still one of the albums that I listen to most.
Quote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
Goodnight Irene could easily have been skipped.
Quote
LeonidPQuote
Voodookitten76
Happy 2nd birthday Crosseyed Heart!!!! Two years on and this is still one of the albums that I listen to most.
Didn't realize it was 2 years already, but what a great album it is!Quote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
Certainly it is. And I love Talk is Cheap, but X-eyed Heart is superior.Quote
DandelionPowderman
Goodnight Irene could easily have been skipped.
Brutal! It's such a great cover, Keith does a great job on vocals, it's one of the highlights for me.
Quote
barbabang
quote
matxil
I think Talk Is Cheap, Main Offender and Crosseyed Heart are all tree very good, but all have their weak points. In that sense, Crosseyed Heart is the "best" since its only weak point is the Blues In The Morning cacaphony. Talk Is Cheap was a great surprise, and has a lot of great stuff to offer, but the production could have been better, and the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice (and again: the production doesn't help either, I could imagine live it could sound much steamier). Main Offender has the most weak songs (Yap Yap, Body Talks), but I love Wicked and Hate It When You Leave, and I've come to appreciate the odd Will But You Won't / Running Too Deep copy/paste sequence.
1 : the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice???
How do mean clearly? It works great! Great opener of the record with all ingredients that work. You should have written : In my humble opinion there.
2. The production. The production could have been better? In what way? Great dynamics, all analogue, and thus the record can be played loud without getting 'ear fatigue'. It is a great production in the sound department (in my opinion)
The cd version was not so good as the longplayer version, but with Main Offender the cd version sounds VERY good (in my opinion)
Quote
matxilQuote
MaindefenderQuote
matxilQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
I think Talk Is Cheap, Main Offender and Crosseyed Heart are all tree very good, but all have their weak points. In that sense, Crosseyed Heart is the "best" since its only weak point is the Blues In The Morning cacaphony. Talk Is Cheap was a great surprise, and has a lot of great stuff to offer, but the production could have been better, and the funk effort of Big Enough clearly does not work for Keith's voice (and again: the production doesn't help either, I could imagine live it could sound much steamier). Main Offender has the most weak songs (Yap Yap, Body Talks), but I love Wicked and Hate It When You Leave, and I've come to appreciate the odd Will But You Won't / Running Too Deep copy/paste sequence.
Weird I thought from first listen and still think Blues In The Morning is brilliant lyrically and musically. Let's face it so many of Keith's songs would be great Rolling Stones songs.
I must be missing something. My girlfriend (not a huge Stones fan) likes that song also. I prefer to skip it, to me it just sounds like a very loud 12-bar boogie without anything special, just very loud and chaotic.
I am assuming that for you it's something like Black Limousine or Who's Driving Your Plane, (both of which I love), but for me it lacks control, clearity and direction. Never mind though, the rest of the album is great.
Quote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
For me, Crosseyed Heart had a greater impact and left a bigger impression on me.
Hard to be objective with this as it's only my opinion, but the two were released at different periods of my life and therefore have a different context which can sometimes influence one's opinion.
I certainly loved Talk is Cheap and it held the place as the best Stones related album since Tattoo You for a long time...until Crosseyed Heart came out.
That said, I think You Don't Move Me as an individual song is better than any individual song from Crosseyed Heart, but if comparing the albums as a whole, I lean towards Crosseyed Heart - for a variety of reasons.
I guess that's the point: it' s all subjective, just opinions. For me,there are, especially in the first half of CH great tunes but also few fillers in the second half. Talk is cheap: every song a Killer. Compare Blues in the morning with could have stood you up and you know what I mean.
Quote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
For me, Crosseyed Heart had a greater impact and left a bigger impression on me.
Hard to be objective with this as it's only my opinion, but the two were released at different periods of my life and therefore have a different context which can sometimes influence one's opinion.
I certainly loved Talk is Cheap and it held the place as the best Stones related album since Tattoo You for a long time...until Crosseyed Heart came out.
That said, I think You Don't Move Me as an individual song is better than any individual song from Crosseyed Heart, but if comparing the albums as a whole, I lean towards Crosseyed Heart - for a variety of reasons.
I guess that's the point: it' s all subjective, just opinions. For me,there are, especially in the first half of CH great tunes but also few fillers in the second half. Talk is cheap: every song a Killer. Compare Blues in the morning with could have stood you up and you know what I mean.
I can't see what you mean as I think Blues in the Morning is far superior to I Could Have Stood You Up.
While Blues in the Morning is a stomping barrel house romp through the history of the blues and early rock and roll (with great lyrics), I Could Have Stood You Up comes across as nothing more than a faux rockabilly tune.
Not a bad tune by any means as it's fun to listen to and fits well on the album, but it's more of a tongue-in-cheek novelty whereas Blues in the Morning seems to have more sincerity and is closer to the real deal imo.
Quote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
For me, Crosseyed Heart had a greater impact and left a bigger impression on me.
Hard to be objective with this as it's only my opinion, but the two were released at different periods of my life and therefore have a different context which can sometimes influence one's opinion.
I certainly loved Talk is Cheap and it held the place as the best Stones related album since Tattoo You for a long time...until Crosseyed Heart came out.
That said, I think You Don't Move Me as an individual song is better than any individual song from Crosseyed Heart, but if comparing the albums as a whole, I lean towards Crosseyed Heart - for a variety of reasons.
I guess that's the point: it' s all subjective, just opinions. For me,there are, especially in the first half of CH great tunes but also few fillers in the second half. Talk is cheap: every song a Killer. Compare Blues in the morning with could have stood you up and you know what I mean.
I can't see what you mean as I think Blues in the Morning is far superior to I Could Have Stood You Up.
While Blues in the Morning is a stomping barrel house romp through the history of the blues and early rock and roll (with great lyrics), I Could Have Stood You Up comes across as nothing more than a faux rockabilly tune.
Not a bad tune by any means as it's fun to listen to and fits well on the album, but it's more of a tongue-in-cheek novelty whereas Blues in the Morning seems to have more sincerity and is closer to the real deal imo.
Hmmm: could have stood you up is s fine classic rockabilly, blues in the morning rather a jamsession with noddling guitar where the voice should be and a later overdubbed vocalpart. No masterpiece, I'm sorry
Quote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
For me, Crosseyed Heart had a greater impact and left a bigger impression on me.
Hard to be objective with this as it's only my opinion, but the two were released at different periods of my life and therefore have a different context which can sometimes influence one's opinion.
I certainly loved Talk is Cheap and it held the place as the best Stones related album since Tattoo You for a long time...until Crosseyed Heart came out.
That said, I think You Don't Move Me as an individual song is better than any individual song from Crosseyed Heart, but if comparing the albums as a whole, I lean towards Crosseyed Heart - for a variety of reasons.
I guess that's the point: it' s all subjective, just opinions. For me,there are, especially in the first half of CH great tunes but also few fillers in the second half. Talk is cheap: every song a Killer. Compare Blues in the morning with could have stood you up and you know what I mean.
I can't see what you mean as I think Blues in the Morning is far superior to I Could Have Stood You Up.
While Blues in the Morning is a stomping barrel house romp through the history of the blues and early rock and roll (with great lyrics), I Could Have Stood You Up comes across as nothing more than a faux rockabilly tune.
Not a bad tune by any means as it's fun to listen to and fits well on the album, but it's more of a tongue-in-cheek novelty whereas Blues in the Morning seems to have more sincerity and is closer to the real deal imo.
Hmmm: could have stood you up is s fine classic rockabilly, blues in the morning rather a jamsession with noddling guitar where the voice should be and a later overdubbed vocalpart. No masterpiece, I'm sorry
No apologies necessary - we all have different tastes and opinions.
Quote
Voodookitten76
I'm surprised by the Stood You Up comments. I love that track! It's a great '50s nostalgia song, so catchy.
Quote
LeonidPQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
HairballQuote
deardoctorQuote
Hairball
The entire album is a winner and provided some great listening for months after release - I still consider it a masterpiece, and hearing it now is just as satisfying. The soundtrack for the late summer and Fall of 2015, and easily the best Stones related album since Tattoo You. If the Stones as a band can ever get it together for a new album, they have their work cut out for them if they want to come close to the overall quality of Crosseyed Heart. Doubtful they can imo considering the soap opera that's taken place so far, not to mention all the other Stones albums since Tattoo You which have always felt unnatural and forced resulting in something mediocre at best.
Come on, does crosseyed heart really beat Talk is cheap? Certainly not.
For me, Crosseyed Heart had a greater impact and left a bigger impression on me.
Hard to be objective with this as it's only my opinion, but the two were released at different periods of my life and therefore have a different context which can sometimes influence one's opinion.
I certainly loved Talk is Cheap and it held the place as the best Stones related album since Tattoo You for a long time...until Crosseyed Heart came out.
That said, I think You Don't Move Me as an individual song is better than any individual song from Crosseyed Heart, but if comparing the albums as a whole, I lean towards Crosseyed Heart - for a variety of reasons.
I guess that's the point: it' s all subjective, just opinions. For me,there are, especially in the first half of CH great tunes but also few fillers in the second half. Talk is cheap: every song a Killer. Compare Blues in the morning with could have stood you up and you know what I mean.
I can't see what you mean as I think Blues in the Morning is far superior to I Could Have Stood You Up.
While Blues in the Morning is a stomping barrel house romp through the history of the blues and early rock and roll (with great lyrics), I Could Have Stood You Up comes across as nothing more than a faux rockabilly tune.
Not a bad tune by any means as it's fun to listen to and fits well on the album, but it's more of a tongue-in-cheek novelty whereas Blues in the Morning seems to have more sincerity and is closer to the real deal imo.
Hmmm: could have stood you up is s fine classic rockabilly, blues in the morning rather a jamsession with noddling guitar where the voice should be and a later overdubbed vocalpart. No masterpiece, I'm sorry
No apologies necessary - we all have different tastes and opinions.
Yes, but his is wrong. Blues In The Morning blows away Stood You Up by a country mile. And if those solos are just 'noodling' than it's not possible to play a solo without it being 'noodling'.