lets say paint it black is plaied in e minor :
what do you feel is the next but last chord of the chorus ( not just the alphabet sign ...)

com'on !
where are'u all, guitar guys !

I don't really understand the question. The last chord of the chorus is a B. What do you mean by "not just the alphabet sign"?

JuanTCB Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I don't really understand the question. The last
> chord of the chorus is a B. What do you mean by
> "not just the alphabet sign"?


ditto

???what are you askin'??? and why chord teaser?

*scratching head*

the next but last , ie the one before that B7...
ok it is an A, but be more specific !!!

dont give up u guitarbastards. !!!

ok ill help u with it
it is A9


- - - - - -
- - - - - -
- X - - - -
- X - - - -
- - - - - -
- - - - - -


check it out, it makes a difference i am sure you will notice.!

richter, you are god! Let us dirty little rats know more about your incredible genius, and especially about what exactly you are smoking!
Thanks in advance.

In my humble opinion i am a genius.
I should be in the stones....

Richter mein Freund, was meinst du? Bist du besoffen? Das geht über meinen Verstand!

do you have those dreams where you are playing in / w/ the stones and everything is working??..............is not that the best!!!!

To Crism :
richter is not my real name, just a nickname i have in in a certain circle, and i am not german, but icelandic

the topic :
you dont understand me ..?
the cord sequence of the chorus of paint it black :

Em D7 G D7 Em .......
Em D7 G D7 A9 B7

it is the A9 i am talking about
an A major chord with an B note added
also showed in my diagram

enjoy!!

Always thought it was Esus4:

- - - - - -
- - - - - -
- X - - - -
- X - - - -
- X - - - -
- - - - - -

But the A9 sounds indeed much better. Although I think it's called Asus2, because an A9 should have the 3rd (C#) and 7th (G) notes.

Always the same story with incredible genius... LOL

agree koen 3rd and 7th should be there as a part of A 9th

just wanted to have the diagram simple for my pupils !
(ok miccawber ...)

I've always thought the D's are major, not 7th.

Mathijs

Mathijs Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I've always thought the D's are major, not 7th.
>
> Mathijs


...me too..........

Rolling Stones Tribute

Play Rolling Stones

Stikkyfinger Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Mathijs Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > I've always thought the D's are major, not
> 7th.
> >
> > Mathijs
>
>
> ...me too..........


me three

you are right my dears !

so, and the intro goes like this.....put the capo on the 2nd fret. btw it's not my achievement. so i don't deserve any credits!!!

---------------2----------3---------------5--------3-------------------------------------------2--------------------------2----------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------5--------5-----4------5------------------2----4---5----------------5----4-------2-----4----
----------------------------------------------------------4------4-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------2----------2-----------2------------2-----------2------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mathijs Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I've always thought the D's are major, not 7th.
>
> Mathijs


Well dude . AGAIN your wrong. Did you see my reply to you for the rough justice topic.

Well, it's not a matter whether I "think" the D's are major -they ARE major, and not 7th.

But what do you know about it anyway. What do you KNOW anyway?

Mathijs

I just looovez this cute catfight between Mathjis and WNY Stones.

The fight is between him and me, not between me and him. Apperently he has something to loose or to proof, as he keeps a close eye on whatever I write, and atacks it without even properly reading it. He (or she for that matter) is part of these psychotic American fans worshipping anything concerning the Stones, whom normally plague other message boards.

Well, I couldn't care less.

Mathijs

D7 doesn't even come close to the right sound... I always thought it was D-minor.

Sounds like D Major to me too, in fact Keith isn't even playing the whole E-minor chord during the chorus. Best I can hear at this point is that he's playing two notes from the E minor (E and G 3rd and forth strings) right before a suspended and then Major D using only two strings from that whole chord (1st and 2nd). He does the same thing over the G using the sixth and 4th strings. It's trademark Keith in it's early form. In fact I'm not so sure that that's ALL he plays (the suspended then Major D on 1st and 3rd strings) with one guitar, the 'whole' chords are played underneath that with another. But I think it's the way I described. Anybody that can hang with this, wow,.....LOL I guess I'm just 'guitarded' (thanks Roy).

I ain't stupid, I'm just guitarded.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2006-02-19 23:18 by RankOutsider.

"D7 doesn't even come close to the right sound... I always thought it was D-minor. " come on rutger you must have some musical ear, of course it is not a D minor, that must be a print mistake on your behalf. it is major cord ( dur, not moll ) but what we are discussing is weather it is a seventh or not, ie d major with a c note added.
I for one wound say it does not matter, this part of the song is in G, having the D7th in the "chord faminly" but in my mind this is a small issue,

Rank outsider
there is more to the stones than keith, so what he does or doesnt not play does not tell everything on chord structures of stones songs,
ronnie playes chords, keybord plays chords, even the horns can play cord notes, the backupsigners can sing in chords. so it is the overall chordical sound that we are discussing

but the start of the discussion was the A 9nt, which i would like to hear your comment on, not on less important side matters!
best

ok it is obvious u are not up to some positive discussions. just when u see the opp to critizise someth that is not by the holy stones book, u jump on it,
( and then u critizise others for being negative...!)

learned musicians have to get support from books,
natual musicians can trust their ears

big words, but have to be told...

best

Dýri

said in the spur of the mmnt
sorry , not fair.

Richter, thanks for the guitar lesson but I have been playing for 30 years and know my way around the fret board and have made ample use of the A9 chord where it suits the song. The point of my response (Sorry that I thought you were German but with a nom de plume like Richter it was the first thing that occured to me!) was to ask what your point was. From waht I cna see now it seesm that you wanted to introduce us to the A9 chord.