it is obvious i have sounded like a besserwisser but that was not my aim.!

I was just bringing up some topic, that I was in understanding with, as most of the topics i feel a little confused, maybe language problem and all that..!

what i felt was interesting is that I have no idea if stones use "ninth" in that case, most surely not: But as you CrisM, I play in band, and have used this chord and feel it feels right.

best
Dýri (footballnickname Richter...)

richter informed me:

Rank outsider
"there is more to the stones than keith, so what he does or doesnt not play does not tell everything on chord structures of stones songs,
ronnie playes chords, keybord plays chords, even the horns can play cord notes, the backupsigners can sing in chords. so it is the overall chordical sound that we are discussing"

Ya, I undersatnd that ricter, but, the reason people are having such a difficult time figuring out what the "chords" are in this song is because the guitar parts are layered on top one another as to make this more difficult to hear. And THAT is mainly caused by what Keith does/doesn't play. People are 'hearing' the overall chrodal sounds which are actually made up of several differnt parts. (see my other post).

And there's no way it's D-minor. duh.


I ain't stupid, I'm just guitarded.

mathijs, kohen and stickyfinger " I've always thought the D's are major, not
> 7th. " boys that is a incredible statement, are you allright? it is not a "one and not the other" case !
it can be both, ie major seventh it is as simple as that..

am I not worth furter comments boys ? I dont believe you are the arrogant type of people that just ingnore the topic cause you are wrong...

mathijs : you have been so eager to inform us on the stones music, as well as the tecnical aspect of the stones instruments, through the time : you have nothn to say ?


----------------------------------------

I feel sometimes sad how the topics fade out, cause we just answer from the our side, instead of kind of lead the topic forward, ie drawing the sentences out of the other people, by asking questions etc. like experienced tv program people do.. we are not very much interested in the other people, just ourselves.. ???

whatchja think?
-------------------------------------

Dýri

richter Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> >
> am I not worth furter comments boys ? I dont
> believe you are the arrogant type of people that
> just ingnore the topic cause you are wrong...
>
> mathijs : you have been so eager to inform us on
> the stones music, as well as the tecnical aspect
> of the stones instruments, through the time : you
> have nothn to say ?
>
>
> ----------------------------------------
>
> I feel sometimes sad how the topics fade out,
> cause we just answer from the our side, instead of
> kind of lead the topic forward, ie drawing the
> sentences out of the other people, by asking
> questions etc. like experienced tv program people
> do.. we are not very much interested in the other
> people, just ourselves.. ???
>
> whatchja think?
> -------------------------------------
>
> Dýri
>
>
>
>


If we're wrong, we're wrong richter...what can I say?

Rolling Stones Tribute

Play Rolling Stones

Mathijs, did you take WNY Stones's woman or something? He pretty much blast anything you say.

I'm just waiting on a friend.

Im sorry, if i put you in some uncomfortable sitiation my RS friends..
best wishes

Dýri


ps was watching yoko ono live on icelandic tv just now,
she is here in reykjavik. the plan is to raise a "column of peace" 30 m high, on an small island just outside Reykjavik, she is the designer (artist) of that column.
on that colum will be written all kind of pieceslogans from of her and john lennon.

richter Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> mathijs : you have been so eager to inform us on
> the stones music, as well as the tecnical aspect
> of the stones instruments, through the time : you
> have nothn to say ?

Well, I don't know what your trying to say. The D, G, and A's are all major, the B is major too although Wood likes to make it a 7th once in a while (especially on the '89 tour). I don't fully understand where your trying to get with the A9's and all.

Mathijs

Elmo Lewis Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Mathijs, did you take WNY Stones's woman or
> something? He pretty much blast anything you say.

I truly don't know what he has on me.

Mathijs

i wrote before mathijs :


"
Em D G D Em .......
Em D G D A9 B7


it is the A9 i am talking about
an A major chord with an B note added
also showed in my diagram "

------------------------------

richter Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> it is the A9 i am talking about
> an A major chord with an B note added

What the risk of being chastised, as said before, what's in that diagram is an Asus2, an A9 looks like this:

- - X - - -
- X - - - -
- - - X - -
- X - - - -
- - - - - -
- - - - - -

all my notes are included in your diagram koen...right ?
i realise you show other notes as well like the g note 7th, but as we know sometimes guitarcords can be that complex that you have to omit some notes for practical purpose

best
d

Yes, beautiful, well done. But what do you mean? The Stones play an Amajor, and of course, you can play any lick or expend th Amajor chord as long as it is in the major key. The A9 you show indeed is an Asus2, not an A9. An Asus2 would give it a Spanish flavour, and I can imagine it would fit the '89 version with the gut stringed electro-acoustic. But on the original version, it's an Amajor.

Mathijs

instead of playin a stragiht A major chord I omit the c# note and play the B note (9nth) instead.

that is all A ninth instead of straight A

best

richter Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> > instead of playin a stragiht A major chord I
> omit the c# note and play the B note (9nth)
> instead.

In that case would call it an Aadd9, see eg: [www.8notes.com]

all the notes in what you call Aadd9 are includ in A9, so it sounds the same in my ears, Koen, just a question of broadness.. !