Quote
DandelionPowderman
So why isn't GS from Mobile 72 mentioned in this thread?

Perhaps because of its dubious sound quality.
Anyway, so many great Shelters from those 72 and 73 tours. But here you have it:

Quote
kleermaker

Quote
DandelionPowderman
So why isn't GS from Mobile 72 mentioned in this thread?

Perhaps because of its dubious sound quality.
Anyway, so many great Shelters from those 72 and 73 tours. But here you have it:

I have it, but thanks The solo is pretty good, though

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
LuxuryStones

Quote
DandelionPowderman
Lucky Keith who found utmost match!

Mick Taylor (guitar) - true - for a while
Mick Jagger (song writing) - for a while, Mick was the lucky one
Brian Jones (arrangement) - For a while, a brilliant guitar partner
Charlie Watts (rythm) - true
Ron Wood (mate) - for a while, his best guitar PARTNER

Are we talking about talent/skill here, or personal taste?

OK. Keith was nothing but lucky, SF isn't better than IORR, Brian couldn't play, Charlie is good tonight and the Stones didn't have a revival with SG and TY.

I get it

Just wanted to show how it looks if you say controversial things, purely based on taste like Mark did.

At least, I had some facts thrown in there somewhere

I didn't say Keith was lucky, or Brian couldn't play, nor did I say controversial things- I shouldn't have quoted. Just an objective question about the playing relationship between Keith and the rest of the guitar staff.

Can't You Hear Me Knocking...The Rolling stones No 1.






The Rolling Stones-Gimme Shelter Altamont





The Rolling Stones Gimme shelter Brussels







Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2014-04-14 20:21 by runaway.

Quote
LuxuryStones

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
LuxuryStones

Quote
DandelionPowderman
Lucky Keith who found utmost match!

Mick Taylor (guitar) - true - for a while
Mick Jagger (song writing) - for a while, Mick was the lucky one
Brian Jones (arrangement) - For a while, a brilliant guitar partner
Charlie Watts (rythm) - true
Ron Wood (mate) - for a while, his best guitar PARTNER

Are we talking about talent/skill here, or personal taste?

OK. Keith was nothing but lucky, SF isn't better than IORR, Brian couldn't play, Charlie is good tonight and the Stones didn't have a revival with SG and TY.

I get it

Just wanted to show how it looks if you say controversial things, purely based on taste like Mark did.

At least, I had some facts thrown in there somewhere

I didn't say Keith was lucky, or Brian couldn't play, nor did I say controversial things- I shouldn't have quoted. Just an objective question about the playing relationship between Keith and the rest of the guitar staff.

I know

But Mark said Keith was lucky on all accounts, hence I wanted to give him a little reversed tongue in cheek-reply. That obviously rubbed off a bit in my reply to you as well, sorry

If you read my more serious reply above, I said all three guitarists were a perfect match for Keith, for different reasons. And, yes, that is according to my own aquired taste.

Ineffable Dandelion, would you reserve your wet licks for more valuable targets?




Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014-04-17 09:41 by MarkSchneider.

Everyone is valuable here, Mark

One of my favourite Taylor performances is You Gotta Move. The sound he gets out of each note on that track is worth more than many of his fast solos combined, imo.

Sheer beauty

Quote
DandelionPowderman
One of my favourite Taylor performances is You Gotta Move. The sound he gets out of each note on that track is worth more than many of his fast solos combined, imo.

Sheer beauty

This is absolutely brilliant. He is amazing!

Here is one more that really shows his brilliance. It is an alternate version of Shine a light that I like better than the released Exile version. Enjoy. This may be embedded nd will refer you to YOu TUbe to watch.