For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
LeonidPQuote
treaclefingersQuote
LeonidPQuote
treaclefingersQuote
LeonidPQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
treaclefingersQuote
LeonidPQuote
treaclefingersQuote
LeonidPQuote
treaclefingersQuote
NICOS
Too Much Blood is the only highlight on this album
Seriously? I mean if you like Too Much Blood, how is it that you don't like Undercover of the Night, or Pretty Beat Up or Tie You Up?
I can get not liking the album, but to like that song and not the rest is perplexing to me.
You just listed your top stones albums above, and put Tattoo You and Undercover above albums like Sticky and Exile ... and you question where this guy is coming from??? (although I do have to agree with one thing, as Too Much Blood is the only bad song on this album).
You need to reread my post, that isn't at all what I said...
Actually its exactly what you said:
"You've got your big four, Tattoo You, Some Girls, Between The Buttons, Aftermath, Black and Blue, Undercover."
Although I guess if I didn't scan over it too quickly I would have seen that you listed more than 4 and possibly figured it out.
Dear lord, you've reread it and you still don't know what 'your big four' means? I'm hereby revoking your fan club membership and placing you on citizen's arrest.
You'll be detained for questioning...oh you're in real trouble now my friend.
LeonidP, how is "your big four, Tattoo You, Some Girls, Between The Buttons, Aftermath, Black and Blue, Undercover" confused for not including Beggars, LIB, SF and EOMS?
He did not say "your big four" meaning Tattoo You, Some Girls, Between The Buttons, Aftermath, Black and Blue, Undercover" because, in case you can't count that, that's SIX albums. Nor did he list those 6 albums before the Big Four.
You must've eaten a funny cookie.
ummm... like I said, I scanned and did not count. Nonetheless it would have been his miscount, not mine, as it was his list.
Don't make your denseness my issue please. It would have been my 'miscount', had I miscounted anything...but I didn't, you did. Why you're trying to justify your miscalculation is mystifying. Let it go dude.
How would it be my miscount? It was your post.
Look...proving I'm dense over & over stopped being fun for me days ago.
Okay, I'll stop, proving you wrong was enough, no need for me to rub it in!
Quote
71Tele
The first album by the Rolling Stones where the majority of songs are sub-standard, plain and simple. Unfortunately it wasn't the last.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
My only other reference at the time was Tattoo You, and when I got Undercover I wasn't disappointed. I loved them equally.
This might have to do with the phase I was in, though, in the beginning of my Stones-exploration
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
My only other reference at the time was Tattoo You, and when I got Undercover I wasn't disappointed. I loved them equally.
This might have to do with the phase I was in, though, in the beginning of my Stones-exploration
Quote
DoxaQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
My only other reference at the time was Tattoo You, and when I got Undercover I wasn't disappointed. I loved them equally.
This might have to do with the phase I was in, though, in the beginning of my Stones-exploration
I belong to the same group of fans as Dandie, and while I did recognize that UNDERCOVER was different (especially compared to TATTOO YOU), it could be that for us 'newbies' who were more used to the sounds of the day (or didn't know any better...), that the Stones sounded like that was rather natural. But I guess for the older fans the new sounds they tried there didn't sound so convincing. Generally I have noticed that the lovers of UNDERCOVER are us newbies then (hooked by it, TATTOO YOU or at least not before SOME GIRLS), and also both the older and younger fan generations seem to more critical towards it. Anyway, our generation is still rather big generation of fans, so we have quite a lot of volume, for example, here at IORR...
I might sound critical now but at the time it was a big album for me.. my first 'new' Rolling Stones studio album... It sounded marvellous!
- Doxa
Quote
Redhotcarpet
And to me it sounded shit. I belong to the fan generation that discovered dad's records and played them to pieces. That's why I hardly recognized the band in Undercover, it sounded too different. And that I think is the key. Miss you sounds like the Stones and it's a great song. Undercover sounds like anything by anyone. I dont think its horrible but it's pointless and hollow.
Quote
nick
Make no mistake, the mass of US rock radio stations going Top 40 prevented this album going to #1. Savor that last Atlantic LP, it still holds truer to the Stones sound than that poppy 80's sound on that Dirty Work.
Quote
DoxaQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
My only other reference at the time was Tattoo You, and when I got Undercover I wasn't disappointed. I loved them equally.
This might have to do with the phase I was in, though, in the beginning of my Stones-exploration
I belong to the same group of fans as Dandie, and while I did recognize that UNDERCOVER was different (especially compared to TATTOO YOU), it could be that for us 'newbies' who were more used to the sounds of the day (or didn't know any better...), that the Stones sounded like that was rather natural. But I guess for the older fans the new sounds they tried there didn't sound so convincing. Generally I have noticed that the lovers of UNDERCOVER are us newbies then (hooked by it, TATTOO YOU or at least not before SOME GIRLS), and also both the older and younger fan generations seem to more critical towards it. Anyway, our generation is still rather big generation of fans, so we have quite a lot of volume, for example, here at IORR...
I might sound critical now but at the time it was a big album for me.. my first 'new' Rolling Stones studio album... It sounded marvellous!
- Doxa
Quote
WitnessQuote
DoxaQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
My only other reference at the time was Tattoo You, and when I got Undercover I wasn't disappointed. I loved them equally.
This might have to do with the phase I was in, though, in the beginning of my Stones-exploration
I belong to the same group of fans as Dandie, and while I did recognize that UNDERCOVER was different (especially compared to TATTOO YOU), it could be that for us 'newbies' who were more used to the sounds of the day (or didn't know any better...), that the Stones sounded like that was rather natural. But I guess for the older fans the new sounds they tried there didn't sound so convincing. Generally I have noticed that the lovers of UNDERCOVER are us newbies then (hooked by it, TATTOO YOU or at least not before SOME GIRLS), and also both the older and younger fan generations seem to more critical towards it. Anyway, our generation is still rather big generation of fans, so we have quite a lot of volume, for example, here at IORR...
I might sound critical now but at the time it was a big album for me.. my first 'new' Rolling Stones studio album... It sounded marvellous!
- Doxa
In all haste during work:
I am representative of almost none, probably, as always. I belong to the group of fans that started to be hooked during the band's R&B period.
I am one that put UNDERCOVER so high that I - not always, not even most times, but sometimes - during some listenings rank it higher than EXILE ON MAIN STREET.
And I consider three out of four of the following studio albums, starting with SOME GIRLS, as the band's fourth peak (two peaks during Brian Jones' years). But I dislike what they made out of TATTOO YOU more than most. Let the studio version, put up against the most adequate early outtake of "Hang Fire", be one aspect of what I dislike about that album.
The edit: Three words had fallen out, but are entered with this: "out of four"
Quote
WitnessQuote
DoxaQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
My only other reference at the time was Tattoo You, and when I got Undercover I wasn't disappointed. I loved them equally.
This might have to do with the phase I was in, though, in the beginning of my Stones-exploration
I belong to the same group of fans as Dandie, and while I did recognize that UNDERCOVER was different (especially compared to TATTOO YOU), it could be that for us 'newbies' who were more used to the sounds of the day (or didn't know any better...), that the Stones sounded like that was rather natural. But I guess for the older fans the new sounds they tried there didn't sound so convincing. Generally I have noticed that the lovers of UNDERCOVER are us newbies then (hooked by it, TATTOO YOU or at least not before SOME GIRLS), and also both the older and younger fan generations seem to more critical towards it. Anyway, our generation is still rather big generation of fans, so we have quite a lot of volume, for example, here at IORR...
I might sound critical now but at the time it was a big album for me.. my first 'new' Rolling Stones studio album... It sounded marvellous!
- Doxa
In all haste during work:
I am representative of almost none, probably, as always. I belong to the group of fans that started to be hooked during the band's R&B period.
I am one that put UNDERCOVER so high that I - not always, not even most times, but sometimes - during some listenings rank it higher than EXILE ON MAIN STREET.
And I consider three out of four of the following studio albums, starting with SOME GIRLS, as the band's fourth peak (two peaks during Brian Jones' years). But I dislike what they made out of TATTOO YOU more than most. Let the studio version, put up against the most adequate early outtake of "Hang Fire", be one aspect of what I dislike about that album.
The edit: Three words had fallen out, but are entered with this: "out of four"
Quote
Witness
Yes, that is what I am saying.
I do like Dance, I am fond of "Indian Girl", and I am delighted by the songs with more or less negative feelings on the B-side of the album (the vinyl version). The reggae infused songs also give me joy. There are a couple of greater songs on SOME GIRLS, but all in all I as often as not choose EMOTIONAL RESCUE before SOME GIRLS.
In fact, I don't find the album uneven either. But varied I think it is.
Quote
DoxaQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
treaclefingersQuote
DandelionPowderman
<She was hot was a great song but thats it really>
That's hilarious!
If there is a great song on the album, it sure is the title track - although I like SWH very much as well.
With this album it seems fans are very divided.
While you'll get a few people waving the flag on Dirty Work, they are very few. For Undercover you have a very large number of lovers and haters. I don't know if whether you did a poll you'd find it 50/50 but it seems close to that.
I wonder why that is?
The SG-generation seem to like Undercover as well...
Funny though that seems the first time that a lot of fans didn't show up in droves to buy the album. I wonder if the explanation is as simple as the lead single, which was huge in the past 3 albums, just wasn't as commercial?
While I love the album and especially Undercover of the Night, I'll admit I was surprised when I first heard it. Very different from what we'd heard before.
My only other reference at the time was Tattoo You, and when I got Undercover I wasn't disappointed. I loved them equally.
This might have to do with the phase I was in, though, in the beginning of my Stones-exploration
I belong to the same group of fans as Dandie, and while I did recognize that UNDERCOVER was different (especially compared to TATTOO YOU), it could be that for us 'newbies' who were more used to the sounds of the day (or didn't know any better...), that the Stones sounded like that was rather natural. But I guess for the older fans the new sounds they tried there didn't sound so convincing. Generally I have noticed that the lovers of UNDERCOVER are us newbies then (hooked by it, TATTOO YOU or at least not before SOME GIRLS), and also both the older and younger fan generations seem to more critical towards it. Anyway, our generation is still rather big generation of fans, so we have quite a lot of volume, for example, here at IORR...
I might sound critical now but at the time it was a big album for me.. my first 'new' Rolling Stones studio album... It sounded marvellous!
- Doxa
Quote
DandelionPowderman
<I am guessing that fans would have initially thought this album was average...with one or 2 decent songs.>
Not for me, I liked the whole album at the time. And I thought Undercover Of The Night, She Was Hot and Pretty Beat Up were fantastic. I still do.