For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
palerider22Quote
gotdablouseQuote
DandelionPowderman
Not too good, imo. Keith starts it way too slow, and Taylor is not doing a good solo...
Not as good as in LA but better than in CHI/3 I'd say, he was maybe a tad loud though, they really can't seem to get his sound right! Not sure if he was on the Rythm or Treble position this time, LA/2 was Rythm and it sounded better, so...
Thank you for the clip...but DO NOT be fooled by it. IN NO WAY does it capture the sound in the arena last night. It does not even come close! I can't believe how bad it is compared to what I heard in the upper balcony. Myself and the others who were there can attest to fact it sounded AMAZING! Everyone was grooving to it at the back of the arena, mostly standing. If you're going to Montreal, Philly or Boston this is not what it's going to sound like....
Quote
treaclefingers
Oh dear, well the Globe and Mail has said it so it has to be true.
I was there, CYHMK started off slow but really gelled after a couple of minutes, no fault of MT. Rambler was the pinnacle of the show.
I've mentioned some failures last night, Rocks Off, SFTD....had nothing to do with MT.
Both were suffered because of MJ and KR...I'm not even bashing the show because it was great, but those were the low moments.
As I mentioned, JJF, IORR, Satisfaction, Brown Sugah, were all rote, love if they'd just revolve those out...but the audience did love those songs.
Quote
Montrealsuperfan
Just got up and read all these posts.
This may sound arrogant, but criticzing the show through videos and you tube is like watching a sex tape and then telling the participants that they didn't enjoy it. I would rather be doing it, then watching the tape.
Quote
His MajestyQuote
Montrealsuperfan
Just got up and read all these posts.
This may sound arrogant, but criticzing the show through videos and you tube is like watching a sex tape and then telling the participants that they didn't enjoy it. I would rather be doing it, then watching the tape.
Considering the vast world of stones bootlegs, are people's good or bad listening experiences of them not valid because they weren't there?
What about the guy who had a crap time stuck behind a pillar at a concert? Or the people who hear the music seconds after the musicians have played it? Their live show viewpoint is more valid than the muso who devours every recording from a tour?
Quote
His MajestyQuote
Montrealsuperfan
Just got up and read all these posts.
This may sound arrogant, but criticzing the show through videos and you tube is like watching a sex tape and then telling the participants that they didn't enjoy it. I would rather be doing it, then watching the tape.
Considering the vast world of stones bootlegs, are people's good or bad listening experiences of them not valid because they weren't there?
What about the guy who had a crap time stuck behind a pillar at a concert? Or the people who hear the music seconds after the musicians have played it? Their live show viewpoint is more valid than the muso who devours every recording from a tour?
Quote
andrewtQuote
palerider22Quote
gotdablouseQuote
DandelionPowderman
Not too good, imo. Keith starts it way too slow, and Taylor is not doing a good solo...
Not as good as in LA but better than in CHI/3 I'd say, he was maybe a tad loud though, they really can't seem to get his sound right! Not sure if he was on the Rythm or Treble position this time, LA/2 was Rythm and it sounded better, so...
Thank you for the clip...but DO NOT be fooled by it. IN NO WAY does it capture the sound in the arena last night. It does not even come close! I can't believe how bad it is compared to what I heard in the upper balcony. Myself and the others who were there can attest to fact it sounded AMAZING! Everyone was grooving to it at the back of the arena, mostly standing. If you're going to Montreal, Philly or Boston this is not what it's going to sound like....
This is true. An off-note is still an off-note but the guitar tone is way meatier at the show, and the volume of course is essential. At the show you are actually feeling the music. No substitute for that. The crowd went bananas when the jam started, just the release of knowing the moment of glory has come electrified the place. During the jam, it felt like rock concerts used to feel back in the day, the vibe of stoners getting their synapses tickled, chicks dancing to the latin groove, people tossing a beach ball through the crowd, like the first day of summer vacation. I, of course, have a similar attitude to most about doing something to freshen up the warhorses (different placement in the set, rotation, less goddamn Chuck, less scripted arrangements etc.) but objectively I can say Paint It Black does not do much for the crowd or the diehards and should probably get dropped. If they went straight in Gimme Shelter after IORR the crowd would really get going. Emotional Rescue --the novelty is wearing off...fast. Again, the set could flow better at that point.
Doom & Gloom totally works in concert but One More Shot is pointless. Also, the "obscure" numbers can really work if the band just nailed the performance of them.
Warhorses you can get away with some lacklustre work because everyone knows and loves the song and is singing along. With the other tunes, you really need to sell it on stage. Worried About You wowed the crowd because Mick knocked it out of the park. Rocks Off or songs like it could as well if they were played with fire, conviction, and a modicum of efficiency.
Quote
andrewt
Question for those at the show: Is that the first time they did the fake ending on Satisfaction? That caught me off guard (in a good way) And was that a bit of "Everybody Needs Somebody To Love" thrown in at the very end?
Quote
Montrealsuperfan
Just got up and read all these posts.
This may sound arrogant, but criticzing the show through videos and you tube is like watching a sex tape and then telling the participants that they didn't enjoy it. I would rather be doing it, then watching the tape.
A few other show comments that have come back to me;
Sympathy was great and watching Keith come out on the cat walk in the bright red shirt is something I will never forget. The solo was great.
Start me up was surprsingly good
I never got into Miss You, although the creowd loved it
Bobby Keys is an amazing player
I have nothing against Chuck L, but it seems the keyboard sound was much more prominent then in the past (perhaps at the expense of the guitars)
There you have it- I am just a fan who has never played a note of music in my life and I loved every minute of the show.
I am in the pit Sunday, which should provide an interesting perspective.
Quote
treaclefingers
Keith was barely ok, and the great second solo I swear was Ronnie...Keith was trapsing about sometime hands off the guitar and I was watching Ronnie and I think he carried it.
Quote
pinkfloydthebarber
one memorable moment also was when mick mentioned their first single - chuck berry's 'come on' was about to be 50 years old - the anniversary of its release apparently - so he starts to sing a few bars... and i'm thinking -'they're gonna play come on! no way! awesome!!' - but then mick says 'but keith cant remember the intro' and laughs, and then adds 'and Charlie isn't into that one tonight anyway,' and then he laughs, and so did I.
A++++
Quote
stewedandkeefed
I was at last night's show. Initially got section 312 in $85 ticket lottery but got upgraded to section 110 before lights out. The sound was amazing. The best I have heard at a Stones show. I enjoyed the show a lot. This was my fifteenth show and the the first time I heard them play Get Off Of My Cloud, Worried About You, Emotional Rescue, D & G. OMS and CYHMK. I was there cos Mick Taylor was there and I found his solos were great and went over well. I would reiterate what someone else has said that the videos do not do justice to how it sounded in the room. For a bunch of seventy year olds they were pretty amazing and I felt they used Taylor about the right amount. A sober Ron Wood is a force to be reckoned with and his contributions were noticeable.This was probably the best of the post Bill Wyman shows I have seen
Quote
MunichhiltonQuote
stewedandkeefed
I was at last night's show. Initially got section 312 in $85 ticket lottery but got upgraded to section 110 before lights out. The sound was amazing. The best I have heard at a Stones show. I enjoyed the show a lot. This was my fifteenth show and the the first time I heard them play Get Off Of My Cloud, Worried About You, Emotional Rescue, D & G. OMS and CYHMK. I was there cos Mick Taylor was there and I found his solos were great and went over well. I would reiterate what someone else has said that the videos do not do justice to how it sounded in the room. For a bunch of seventy year olds they were pretty amazing and I felt they used Taylor about the right amount. A sober Ron Wood is a force to be reckoned with and his contributions were noticeable.This was probably the best of the post Bill Wyman shows I have seen
It does look like all of you there last night lucked into the best or second best gig so far...
Quote
Tonyz
Hilarious... I went with my dad this time. Causal fan. He was upset that they didn't play MORE hits ala Angie and Street Fighting Man. Didn't appreciate Midnight Rambler and CYHMK. I just had to laugh.
I tell ya, these guys can't win.
Quote
KatieGirl
Had a blast at the Toronto show, even the songs I don't really like, (SMU, ER) didn't bother me. Crowd from my vantage point (lower bowl) was totally in to it, certainly seemed like a sell out from where I was sitting. Lots of parents with their children of various ages. Who would have thought that 50 years on the Stones would be family entertainment! This is the music of my life. I can remember being 13 or 14 years old and my older brother bringing home December's Children on vinyl. I've been a fan since then. Haven't been to many concerts,, am not a musician, but they have been with me all my life. I know this sounds really stupid but I actually started to tear up when they walked out on stage! Great vibe at the show from both band and audience. It's totally different being there and watching it on youtube My only other Stones concert to compare it to was about 40 years ago, and while I know I went, that's all I can remember!!There, I've bared my soul, everyone can make fun of me. I don't care. I loved the show, even the songs I never liked all that much (and there are more than just two, a few of the warhorses actually!)
Quote
kleermakerQuote
MunichhiltonQuote
stewedandkeefed
I was at last night's show. Initially got section 312 in $85 ticket lottery but got upgraded to section 110 before lights out. The sound was amazing. The best I have heard at a Stones show. I enjoyed the show a lot. This was my fifteenth show and the the first time I heard them play Get Off Of My Cloud, Worried About You, Emotional Rescue, D & G. OMS and CYHMK. I was there cos Mick Taylor was there and I found his solos were great and went over well. I would reiterate what someone else has said that the videos do not do justice to how it sounded in the room. For a bunch of seventy year olds they were pretty amazing and I felt they used Taylor about the right amount. A sober Ron Wood is a force to be reckoned with and his contributions were noticeable.This was probably the best of the post Bill Wyman shows I have seen
It does look like all of you there last night lucked into the best or second best gig so far...
best show ever
Quote
MunichhiltonQuote
kleermakerQuote
MunichhiltonQuote
stewedandkeefed
I was at last night's show. Initially got section 312 in $85 ticket lottery but got upgraded to section 110 before lights out. The sound was amazing. The best I have heard at a Stones show. I enjoyed the show a lot. This was my fifteenth show and the the first time I heard them play Get Off Of My Cloud, Worried About You, Emotional Rescue, D & G. OMS and CYHMK. I was there cos Mick Taylor was there and I found his solos were great and went over well. I would reiterate what someone else has said that the videos do not do justice to how it sounded in the room. For a bunch of seventy year olds they were pretty amazing and I felt they used Taylor about the right amount. A sober Ron Wood is a force to be reckoned with and his contributions were noticeable.This was probably the best of the post Bill Wyman shows I have seen
It does look like all of you there last night lucked into the best or second best gig so far...
best show ever
best tour ever
Quote
DoomandGloomI liked last night's version and Taylor stretches out in a good way. Very old style, reminiscent of Jerry Garcia and Duane Allman at times... This ain't no juke box, his tone is fine in the videos and must have been huge for those attending.Quote
palerider22Too much over-analysis....The Globe guy is stretching for something to write. Like a couple of posters have already said....both CYMYK and MR sounded '#*$$*$# insane live... And I was in the 300's. They both hit 10 of 10 on the applause meter...Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
StonesCatQuote
paulm
Based on the posts, I don't even need to watch the vids to reach my conclusion...last night was pivotal for MT, and if the consensus is less than glowing, and he's still having trouble "gelling" or even playing in the beat, I'm turning 180 to say the band is better overall without him.
We all know that time changes things, and while MT certainly evolved musically over the years, he is inconsistent with the Stones; and, it would be a tall (but certainly not impossible) order to expect him to be consistent.
We had CYHMK in L.A., and that was such a good high, I'm all set with MT and the Stones at this point. It's just mudding up the sound.
Every review from fans that actually go to the shows always say Knocking and/or Rambler are great, and highlights from the shows. Then one or two of the same people analyze his solos from afar to the nth degree on here, and suddenly it was "pivotal" last night for him? Whaaa? That's some good comedy. You really wanna analyze each of the three's playing to that level?
Let's hear it from The Globe And Mail - Toronto, then:
"Can’t You Here Me Knocking : Former lead guitarist Mick Taylor, brought back in small nightly doses for this tour, stretched out like Carlos Santana on the sprawling Latin-grooved jam that makes up the song’s second part. He fumbled initially, and never did match the finesse of the recorded version from 1971’s Sticky Fingers . It was as if Taylor was trying to fit in all the notes he missed over the years, having left the band in 1974".
[www.theglobeandmail.com]
Quote
StonesTodQuote
MunichhiltonQuote
kleermakerQuote
MunichhiltonQuote
stewedandkeefed
I was at last night's show. Initially got section 312 in $85 ticket lottery but got upgraded to section 110 before lights out. The sound was amazing. The best I have heard at a Stones show. I enjoyed the show a lot. This was my fifteenth show and the the first time I heard them play Get Off Of My Cloud, Worried About You, Emotional Rescue, D & G. OMS and CYHMK. I was there cos Mick Taylor was there and I found his solos were great and went over well. I would reiterate what someone else has said that the videos do not do justice to how it sounded in the room. For a bunch of seventy year olds they were pretty amazing and I felt they used Taylor about the right amount. A sober Ron Wood is a force to be reckoned with and his contributions were noticeable.This was probably the best of the post Bill Wyman shows I have seen
It does look like all of you there last night lucked into the best or second best gig so far...
best show ever
best tour ever
best tour thread ever
Quote
rebelrebel
Fair enough I'm not but it sounded nice to me and I'm praying they'll do both songs in Hyde Park.