For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
proudmaryQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
EirikQuote
Erik_Snow
In fact we shouldn't comment about anything at all, or share our opinions on anything either.
Haha, yes we should. But you seem to to be quite offending sometimes when people disagree with you, Erik. At least you have too agree on that one
What an absurd thing to say.
I do not really know are you joking or serious?
Quote
Erik_SnowQuote
EirikQuote
Erik_Snow
In fact we shouldn't comment about anything at all, or share our opinions on anything either.
Haha, yes we should. But you seem to to be quite offending sometimes when people disagree with you, Erik. At least you have too agree on that one
What an absurd thing to say.
Quote
proudmary
Wow!!!
All that just because I said that I like Don't Be A Stranger
Quote
VocalionQuote
proudmary
Wow!!!
All that just because I said that I like Don't Be A Stranger
No, you know exactly why.
Quote
Rockman
I'm one of the few women in this men's club that dares to have an opinion and defend it.
.... You GO Mary ... You Tell 'em ... Don't always agree with your views
but I reckon you contribute strongly to the site ...
Quote
proudmaryQuote
VocalionQuote
proudmary
Wow!!!
All that just because I said that I like Don't Be A Stranger
No, you know exactly why.
Sure I know - because I'm not the fan of Richards' book and vice versa the fan of SuperHeavy - the crime is even more inexcusable in this forum. Besides, I'm one of the few women in this men's club that dares to have an opinion and defend it.
By the way, there is now another thread about other new song, and then again people doubt from which year is Mick's vocals. And for some people it seems important -I would never say to all .
What is so terrible in my post to start a personal attack on me? I've read how someone called Jagger- "Mick Jagger T.T.T"(the tiny todger) - and nobody said a word to him. but me - Lord have mercy
But I love to argue so I probably even like it.
Quote
djgab
Some girls is not available in France today ????
we have to wait one extra week ...
does anybody know the reason ?
Quote
VocalionQuote
djgab
Some girls is not available in France today ????
we have to wait one extra week ...
does anybody know the reason ?
Cause you allready have the best looking girls in the world.
Quote
dcbaQuote
VocalionQuote
djgab
Some girls is not available in France today ????
we have to wait one extra week ...
does anybody know the reason ?
Cause you allready have the best looking girls in the world.
Do we really? [www.google.fr]
Quote
Erik_Snow
Well that's a nonsense statement (proudmary's I mean). 2 people - or was it one - thought the 1977 vocals came from 2011; and several of us replied immediately that it wasn't the case. Did it have to take 200 "No that's not the case"-posts to satisfy proudmary?
Quote
Erik_SnowQuote
VocalionQuote
proudmaryQuote
Eirik
Nice songs. Rock'n Roll, Blues, Country. I like the b-side version of So Young from Love Is Strong better, though. I don't know why you guys think the vocals on Don't Be A Stranger are so horrible ????? But the cd is so loud. Again...
Don't Be A Stranger is great and there are lots of good words about the song on the board. But people who hate all modern Jagger-related obviously hate Don't Be A Stranger too.
The irony is the fact that they can hardly distinguish the difference between 77 and 2011 vocals, say, on I Love You Too Much when they thought it's 2011's Jagger it was awful, then it was turned out to be 77 - and ok.
Both songs are very good and I love how Mick sings no matter what year
Nobody in this thread claims any such things....
Well that's a nonsense statement (proudmary's I mean). 2 people - or was it one - thought the 1977 vocals came from 2011; and several of us replied immediately that it wasn't the case. Did it have to take 200 "No that's not the case"-posts to satisfy proudmary?
Quote
DandelionPowderman
I was one of those two people, but I never said the vocals I thought were from 2011 were awful. I love the track! After 40 spins, I still do.
Quote
Erik_SnowQuote
DandelionPowderman
I was one of those two people, but I never said the vocals I thought were from 2011 were awful. I love the track! After 40 spins, I still do.
Yeah it doesn't matter when you thought the vocals were recorded; the important thing is whether one likes the song and singing or not. Don't think many people "decides" to dislike a song or singing style depending on when it was recorded. That's like saying that other people have no taste of their own.
ANyway; please let's not start a discussion similiar to the previous one.....glad you like the song.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
It was just a reply to proudmary, who put words in my mouth. I never said I didn't like Love You Too Much, I love it. In fact, it's one of the better on the album. So are many of the songs with new Jagger vocals.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
It was just a reply to proudmary, who put words in my mouth. I never said I didn't like Love You Too Much, I love it. In fact, it's one of the better on the album. So are many of the songs with new Jagger vocals.
Quote
proudmaryQuote
DandelionPowderman
It was just a reply to proudmary, who put words in my mouth. I never said I didn't like Love You Too Much, I love it. In fact, it's one of the better on the album. So are many of the songs with new Jagger vocals.
Do you like to argue with me and try to provoke me just for the fun of that?
I do not understand how "many people" means "DandelionPowderman, it is a bit self-centered of you, do not you think?
Still, I'm glad you like Love You Too Much. I like it too although not as much as Do You Think I Really Care
To Vocalion
I think you have to change the title of this thread from SG reviews to ProudMary's views reviews. Maybe I should in this case post my frontal nude photo for you guys to comment on my appearance too .
Quote
electricmud
I for myself appriciate the analyses of the bonus disc, I really do. What is old, what is new.. I know these Some Girls outtakes since the beginning 1980`s like many people on this board here. You all remember? I don`t know how much money I spent in bootlegs released every year to get Some Girls outtakes in better soundquality/ longer versions/new tracks/ different vocals and on and on..
A lot of fun to buy this bootleg stuff and a lot of money!! (remember the prices for LP or 2LP bootlegs). So in the end this one here is e real bargain. And for this "little" money (compared to what many people payed to the bootleggers) you get a record you can really listen to! Great soundquality, great songs and for me it works as a new album.
Jagger said an interesting thing about the EXILE-release: they didn`t want to release just a bunch of outtakes but an album you can listen to like a new album, just music. It worked with Exile very well (at least with the running order of the 2cd-set) and it works with the Some Girls bonus disc! If I just take the music as it is, don`t analyse whats old or new, I really enjoy this one.
Great! Heavy rotation!
Hope you can enjoy the music and have fun!
Tom
Quote
Vocalion
Claudine
fast version, you can listen to it at Ron Woods Radio Show
So Young
New version, vocals are a blend of 1977 - 1994 - 2011 IMO
Do You Really Think I Really Care
2011 upfront vocals and a very small Ian Stwart solo thing.
When You're Gone
2011 vocals blown thru an old mic at the beginning (or some sort of effect)
No Spare Parts
You can listen to it on IORR
Don't Be A Stranger
New HORRIBLE 2011 vocals (Sexy Eyes / Lucky in Love bootleg titles)
We Had It All
Not the same vocals as from the well know boot version, GREAT GREAT GREAT!
Tallahassee Lassie
Some Nice Jagger vocals, quite RAW, it's from RCA 1978, Very nice!
I Love You Too Much
You can listen to it on IORR
Keep Up Blues
NEVER HEARD BEFORE version of Some People Tell me. Vocals + harmonica are 2011
The "That's It" at the very end is still there, but different.
You Win Again
2011 Vocals, back-up vocals are nice (Mick and MAYBE far far away some old once
from Keith)
Petrol Blues
Original Vocals! Piano error not present anymore. Cut after 1:36
Vocals are not so bad as on Exile, Jaggers 2011 Vocals work a bit better on
this Some Girls Bonus Disc.