For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Justin
Well that's great that Keith can play an acoustic guitar. But what good does that do the Stones? He plays electric on all but one or two songs in the set. They won't do an all stripped down acoustic tour. They're not going to write an unplugged country or blues album. So what's the point?
Keith's issues are twofold: 1) unable to stick to rhythm playing 2) he can't be bothered to actually learn all the non-warhorse songs. This is why he constantly noodles on stage. Both these issues most likely effected by this physical limitations. What has Keith done to help the situation to help the band and not hurt it??...nothing.
Fans fantasize about the scenario that Mick and Keith need to be locked in a room to write great songs....I'll say it again: we already got that: it's called A Bigger Bang. That's the best they could come up with, folks. Locking them in a kitchen, pantry or closet isn't going to make the songwriting any better. They're running on fumes and they know it doesn't take much to splice together a song. plop it on an album...and shove it out to the fans who will proceed to eat it up. At this point, fans don't even care what they write..they just want to HEAR them do something new. That really gives them the license to just not care.
Quote
MKjan
Some seem to ignore that Keith's brain surgery was a very serious matter, as were
the medications, as is arthritis, and the toll of all his hard living years, and his wifes cancer ordeal....yeah just jump all over him cause he isn't doing what you
want him to...... love the guy.
Quote
pgarofQuote
MKjan
Some seem to ignore that Keith's brain surgery was a very serious matter, as were
the medications, as is arthritis, and the toll of all his hard living years, and his wifes cancer ordeal....yeah just jump all over him cause he isn't doing what you
want him to...... love the guy.
Well said that man!
Quote
pgarofQuote
Justin
Well that's great that Keith can play an acoustic guitar. But what good does that do the Stones? He plays electric on all but one or two songs in the set. They won't do an all stripped down acoustic tour. They're not going to write an unplugged country or blues album. So what's the point?
Keith's issues are twofold: 1) unable to stick to rhythm playing 2) he can't be bothered to actually learn all the non-warhorse songs. This is why he constantly noodles on stage. Both these issues most likely effected by this physical limitations. What has Keith done to help the situation to help the band and not hurt it??...nothing.
Fans fantasize about the scenario that Mick and Keith need to be locked in a room to write great songs....I'll say it again: we already got that: it's called A Bigger Bang. That's the best they could come up with, folks. Locking them in a kitchen, pantry or closet isn't going to make the songwriting any better. They're running on fumes and they know it doesn't take much to splice together a song. plop it on an album...and shove it out to the fans who will proceed to eat it up. At this point, fans don't even care what they write..they just want to HEAR them do something new. That really gives them the license to just not care.
You don't really know it's just all guesswork with you, how do you know that Keith is not writing songs and playing his guitar every day at home? know one knows so why keep on knocking Keith, I just don't get some of you guys.
Quote
NaturalustQuote
GazzaQuote
NaturalustQuote
Gazza
There is absolutely no schedule conflict between SuperHeavy and what the Rolling Stones will or won't do.
You keep saying this Gazza. I have no idea what you are talking about. I want my stones NOW and yes they could be writing and recording a new record RIGHT NOW. How could you possibly say that SH is not a big distraction (at the least) possibly a road block (at the most) to getting our stones back together. I don't mind Mick trying to get his creative thing on whatever way he can, and I totally support collaboration and change but your contention here is baseless in my humble opinion. peace.
Are you serious?
SuperHeavy is all but done. The album is out, the interviews are nearly finished and there will be no concerts. There's hardly anything else to promote.
Its September 2011. Not June 2012. Jagger was releasing solo albums in November 2001 and November 2004. LATER than he has done this time. The Stones still managed to go on the road the following summer each time and also have new material released.
Who's to say they havent been writing? They dont write together anyway. They dont even need to record together. Most of the last record wasnt even made with the four of them in the same room at the same time. Mick has even said that he's been doing some songs with Charlie.
The biggest 'roadblock' to 'your' Stones working together is the fact that Jagger's principal co-writer has pretty much dried up creatively since 1997.
Well, since I generally trust your insights and comments I am happy to hear your reply at least the part about SH being all but done (and on the eve of the CD release no less). I am just as seriously bummed out that you think Keith is not a force of creation anymore. To that I will counter that he probably does the same great new riffs with a few croaks and squeals as he's always done, but Mick Jagger has lost the ability (or motivation) to interpret the song out of the spark and take it and run. This was the process for most ALL the good Stones tunes (per Keith) were written. Its not fair to Keith to hold him out there with these song sparks, alone and naked without Jagger to grab the ball and run toward the goal line. I get the feeling it was a communion of those two spirits which made the magic. I don't see Mick willing to even try this approach anymore. I'm quite sure Keith would do his part. Maybe what they need is a common foe to get them into the same kitchen again and do what they do best...together. peace.
Quote
Gazza
I'd argue that the compromise Keith accepted in 1989 when he and Mick patched up their differences and brought the Stones back from the brink was that the balance of power in the band shifted to Mick irreversibly. It was either his way or the highway
Quote
71Tele
So many threads, so many opinions, based on so little information...
Quote
Naturalust
Hey brother Gazza, we are about as far away in opinion here as the distance in the BIG pond that separates us physically. (California- Irish Republic)
Quote
Naturalust
If this was the case, where is the affirmation of such from Keith? He is outspoken, speaks his mind, pulls few punches and from what I've heard him say, its just the opposite.
Quote
Naturalust
Mick forgot who the Rolling Stone's were. Ask Bill it's Keiths band, a two-guitar affair , with a blues singer up front.
Quote
Naturalust
Your contention about the balance of power having to be one or the other is probabaly astute though. Just like with our wives, the honeymoon always melds into a power stuggle and the outcome of that determines if the pairing will continue, no matter how many vows were spoken in the beginning. Contempt is the beginning of a rot that destroys the very foundations of relationships, God know's there's been enough of that between Mick and Keith. peace.
Quote
MKjan
Some seem to ignore that Keith's brain surgery was a very serious matter, as were
the medications, as is arthritis, and the toll of all his hard living years, and his wifes cancer ordeal....yeah just jump all over him cause he isn't doing what you
want him to...... love the guy.
What we do.Quote
71Tele
So many threads, so many opinions, based on so little information...
Quote
pgarof
You don't really know it's just all guesswork with you, how do you know that Keith is not writing songs and playing his guitar every day at home? know one knows so why keep on knocking Keith, I just don't get some of you guys.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
Mick is probably laughing his head off as we speak
Quote
pgarof
it's just all guesswork
Quote
Rolling Hansie
Mick Jagger did not say the Rolling Stones won't tour next year in celebration of the band's 50th anniversary
Quote
sweetcharmedlife
Mick Jagger did not say the Rolling Stones won't tour next year in celebration of the band's 50th anniversary
Bears repeating.
Quote
Naturalust
if you could hear Keith for 15 minutes with just his acoustic guitar, in 2011 you would not be of the opinion that he brings nothing to the table. I have heard him in just such an intimate setting and he is still just friggin amazing. Knarled fingers and all. And I am a guitar player for many years. I assure you, He still has IT. That's why I pray that MJ is healed from his affleunza and LVS and comes back to the kitchen with the motivation to "do what it takes". I'm all for locking them in a room for days until they work out their differences and start the intimate songwriting again. I know Keith loves Mick dearly, I'm not sure about how Mick feels. peace.
Quote
sweetcharmedlifeWhat we do.Quote
71Tele
So many threads, so many opinions, based on so little information...
Quote
jamesjagger
Believe me guys there will be a new album AND a tour and we will hear 4 new songs 3,5 written by mick, 0.5 written by Keith) and 12 blus cover songs.
Quote
MKjan
Some seem to ignore that Keith's brain surgery was a very serious matter, as were
the medications, as is arthritis, and the toll of all his hard living years, and his wifes cancer ordeal....yeah just jump all over him cause he isn't doing what you
want him to...... love the guy.
FINGERSQuote
shortfatfanny
STICKY
Quote
Pecman
this book has already been written
Quote
Naturalust
Contempt is the beginning of a rot that destroys the very foundations of relationships, God know's there's been enough of that between Mick and Keith. peace.