For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
jcstone47
So you have my full attention. Of all the shows I've seen, it adds up to 99 different songs from their catalog. I just noticed this year that Heartbreaker was missing from my list. I have some deep track requests like Salt of the Earth, Jigsaw Puzzle and Memo from Turner. I wouldn't have guessed Heartbreaker would be so elusive.
Love 100 years ago. LOVE GHS.
Quote
TurnerP
Absolutely didn't miss voodoo lounge no - I see what you mean now. Yes it would have been everything to get a live memo from Turner. My name isn't Turner Purple for nothing. I pleaded it would be done this year but instead I got the excerpt from the movie, oh you know "you'd better come on, in my kitchen.." during midnight rambler which is side by side at the top of my list in songs along with memo. I couldn't agree more. There is 3 versions of Memo however, if you didn't know that already
Quote
jcstone47
Yes, of my 30+ shows, I never heard heartbreaker live. Nor have I heard any from my wish list… memo, jigsaw or salt. I wouldn’t mind and of them being my 100th live tune. After years of no filter, I wish the fan vote wasn’t my best bet to hear something different. My husband thinks I’m nuts traveling from continent to continent to hear the same setlist. Chasing a dream
Quote
TurnerP
You're suspecting overdubs? Guess that isn't a bad guess. Maybe whomever sent this to me didn't know what they had or something but the vocals weave in and out so oddly I hardly thought of that especially with what I was told. It almost sounds like a way younger mick is in it but I don't see how that could've been possible. I think I could try asking the source what their source is instead of your guy's opinion but something tells me they probably don't know much else either. Well it'd suck if they are fake dubs but it's still interesting nonetheless, even more so if they are real lol. Maybe I'm just weird
Quote
okenny
My guess is that the backing track is no different than a fully finished product, so it was processed from a state where only MJ's vocals could be extracted, like the "Let It Bleed" isolate track.
If there is no isolate track available for "Goats", then the vocals were processed and mixed with the official track using an effects processor that can extract only the vocal track. This trend is the same with "Heartbreaker" and "100 Years".