For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Silver Dagger
Thinking of Brian today - the greatest of all the Rolling Stones.
Quote
BamaStone
Always wish he would've pulled it together, still been around. I had envisioned if he had, him and Lennon would've worked in a group together somewhere down the road..
Quote
DiamondDog7
No Jones, No Stones ! As simple as that. R.I.P. Brian.
Quote
dmay
What's a p*sser is that his date of death coincides with my birth date.
Quote
LongBeachArena72
To this day, I have musician friends who tell me in all seriousness that they wrote off the band once Brian left; that after his departure they became a monochromatic rock boogie band and were infinitely less interesting.
Quote
24FPSQuote
LongBeachArena72
To this day, I have musician friends who tell me in all seriousness that they wrote off the band once Brian left; that after his departure they became a monochromatic rock boogie band and were infinitely less interesting.
Yes, they lost that ethereal touch with Brian, but moved into other areas that were just as interesting. Is somebody going to argue that Let It Bleed through Exile weren't 'interesting'? They were definitely not monochromatic up through Start Me Up, and even Steel Wheels has many different styles. It wasn't until the retro Voodoo Lounge that they began to fall backward in the studio, from which they've never really recovered. But come on, after Brian they created some cool stuff for the 20 years. Taylor and Wood are great on slide, although never with the feel Brian had. Bill picked up the emotional weight on bass, but he took the last vestige of Stones sensitivity with him.
Quote
HairballQuote
24FPSQuote
LongBeachArena72
To this day, I have musician friends who tell me in all seriousness that they wrote off the band once Brian left; that after his departure they became a monochromatic rock boogie band and were infinitely less interesting.
Yes, they lost that ethereal touch with Brian, but moved into other areas that were just as interesting. Is somebody going to argue that Let It Bleed through Exile weren't 'interesting'? They were definitely not monochromatic up through Start Me Up, and even Steel Wheels has many different styles. It wasn't until the retro Voodoo Lounge that they began to fall backward in the studio, from which they've never really recovered. But come on, after Brian they created some cool stuff for the 20 years. Taylor and Wood are great on slide, although never with the feel Brian had. Bill picked up the emotional weight on bass, but he took the last vestige of Stones sensitivity with him.
It could have to do with the age of certain fans, and when they first became fans of the Stones (there's another recent thread about this).
Similar reactions to Fleetwood Mac - never the same after Peter Green left. The Bob Welch years were the best (a rare phenomenon lol). They are the best (or they are the worst) with Stevie and Lyndsey, etc., etc., etc.
Same with the Eagles - many different lineups, and the current one about to happen is causing major debates.
Same with Yardbirds - never the same after Clapton left. Or better with Jeff Beck, etc.
I imagine if I was a fan in the very early years and was devoted to Brian and his unique input, I might have had a hard time accepting a replacement. On the other hand, I might have - actually I probably would have - embraced the "new" kid on the block and the skills he brought.
Quote
LongBeachArena72
To this day, I have musician friends who tell me in all seriousness that they wrote off the band once Brian left; that after his departure they became a monochromatic rock boogie band and were infinitely less interesting.
Quote
24FPSQuote
HairballQuote
24FPSQuote
LongBeachArena72
To this day, I have musician friends who tell me in all seriousness that they wrote off the band once Brian left; that after his departure they became a monochromatic rock boogie band and were infinitely less interesting.
Yes, they lost that ethereal touch with Brian, but moved into other areas that were just as interesting. Is somebody going to argue that Let It Bleed through Exile weren't 'interesting'? They were definitely not monochromatic up through Start Me Up, and even Steel Wheels has many different styles. It wasn't until the retro Voodoo Lounge that they began to fall backward in the studio, from which they've never really recovered. But come on, after Brian they created some cool stuff for the 20 years. Taylor and Wood are great on slide, although never with the feel Brian had. Bill picked up the emotional weight on bass, but he took the last vestige of Stones sensitivity with him.
It could have to do with the age of certain fans, and when they first became fans of the Stones (there's another recent thread about this).
Similar reactions to Fleetwood Mac - never the same after Peter Green left. The Bob Welch years were the best (a rare phenomenon lol). They are the best (or they are the worst) with Stevie and Lyndsey, etc., etc., etc.
Same with the Eagles - many different lineups, and the current one about to happen is causing major debates.
Same with Yardbirds - never the same after Clapton left. Or better with Jeff Beck, etc.
I imagine if I was a fan in the very early years and was devoted to Brian and his unique input, I might have had a hard time accepting a replacement. On the other hand, I might have - actually I probably would have - embraced the "new" kid on the block and the skills he brought.
I was barely aware of who Brian was. Even when he died the announcer (in the U.S.) played Satisfaction, which wasn't something Brian stood out on. All I knew of him was he had blond hair and wore a surfer's cross. It wasn't until 1972 and Dalton's book of past essays and photos that I began to understand his contribution. And it took even longer, I think it was Big Hits and Fazed Cookies that really informed me. He was gone just as the Stones' fame was getting ready to kick into the stratosphere.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
It was in the stratosphere by Satisfaction already. That's what allowed them to experiment- and that's when Brian shone.
Quote
LongBeachArena72Quote
DandelionPowderman
It was in the stratosphere by Satisfaction already. That's what allowed them to experiment- and that's when Brian shone.
Interesting. Is there evidence that they'd wanted to 'experiment' before "Satisfaction" but decided not to because they weren't commercially successful enough?