For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Bad, bad idea. For Lucinda , I mean. I say this completely from own experience.
Quote
billwebsterQuote
Palace Revolution 2000
Bad, bad idea. For Lucinda , I mean. I say this completely from own experience.
I agree. There is nothing wrong with the original. And for the Stones, they haven't felt the urge to re-record studio versions of their ABKCO catalogue hits for financial or licensing reasons in the past, so why should they do it now that ABKCO and their own label Promopub B. V. share the same distributor with Universal?
Quote
LeonidP
I wish they would remake Dirty Work, improve it by making it all silent so that I can listen all the way through.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
billwebsterQuote
Palace Revolution 2000
Bad, bad idea. For Lucinda , I mean. I say this completely from own experience.
I agree. There is nothing wrong with the original. And for the Stones, they haven't felt the urge to re-record studio versions of their ABKCO catalogue hits for financial or licensing reasons in the past, so why should they do it now that ABKCO and their own label Promopub B. V. share the same distributor with Universal?
They recorded live versions of some of them in the studio for Stripped.
That worked. I'm not sure about new studio takes of old tracks, though.
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
billwebsterQuote
Palace Revolution 2000
Bad, bad idea. For Lucinda , I mean. I say this completely from own experience.
I agree. There is nothing wrong with the original. And for the Stones, they haven't felt the urge to re-record studio versions of their ABKCO catalogue hits for financial or licensing reasons in the past, so why should they do it now that ABKCO and their own label Promopub B. V. share the same distributor with Universal?
They recorded live versions of some of them in the studio for Stripped.
That worked. I'm not sure about new studio takes of old tracks, though.
They also re-recorded Beast Of Burden, Angie, The Worst and Memory Motel at Toshiba. So it wasn't all ABKCO Music songs.
Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Bad, bad idea. For Lucinda , I mean. I say this completely from own experience.
Quote
RoughJusticeOnYa
Concerning these 'Stripped' recording sessions: I quite liked what they did with/ to "The Spider and The Fly", f.i.
That really worked!
"Angie": not so much...
"Wild Horses": brilliant.
"Beast of Burden": redundant.
Quote
GasLightStreet
Honest I Do and Spider And The Fly were supreme. It's too bad Honest I Do wasn't included on STRIPPED.
And the LARS B-sides - those should've been on STRIPPED! They could've left off Wild Horses, Angie and I'm Free in place of Black Limo, All Down The Line and Honest I Do.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
GasLightStreet
Honest I Do and Spider And The Fly were supreme. It's too bad Honest I Do wasn't included on STRIPPED.
And the LARS B-sides - those should've been on STRIPPED! They could've left off Wild Horses, Angie and I'm Free in place of Black Limo, All Down The Line and Honest I Do.
Agreed, except for Wild Horses. That one's perhaps the best of the lot!
Quote
matxil
Ridiculous idea. And of course they'll never do it, it would be the musical, artistic and commercial equivalent of committing suicide.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
[Stripped extra] Honest I Do was excellent.
..
Quote
LeonidPQuote
DandelionPowderman
[Stripped extra] Honest I Do was excellent.
..
Agree, but I still prefer the original (meaning their original cover).
Quote
dennycranium
I think we would be surprised with an album like this.
INXS did their own tribute album with guest vocalists and I, for the most part, enjoyed it.
Keith has always compared new studio tracks as "babies" and then they "grow up" when they take them out on tour and perform them live.
I'm not sure I'd want a redo of a complete album but would enjoy a "warhorses" redo.
A few tracks I'd like to see how they've "grown up?"
1.Jumping Jack Flash- the original version was recorded before Keith discovered open G tuning.
2. 19th Nervous Breakdown- just like the song.
3. Start Me Up- my favorite Stones riff!
4. Gimme Shelter
5. Street Fighting Man
6. Wild Horses
7. Going To A Go Go or Just My Imagination.
8. Some Girls- as Mick has experienced more relationships since this song was recorded, he could alter or add a few new verses.
9. Worried About You
10. Emotional Rescue- Darryl Jones bass playing would add a whole other level to this song.
11. Miss You- same reason as Emotional Rescue-Darryl
I'd even love to hear a redo album entitled "Open G."
For myself,the open G chord is like heroin to my ears.
I would welcome an album like this!
Quote
Rip This
Dirty Work...that record is so bad they should burn it take it out of circulation and try it again....terrible....the worst. Undercover and Bridges would be 2nd, and third choices.
Quote
HairballQuote
LeonidPQuote
DandelionPowderman
[Stripped extra] Honest I Do was excellent.
..
Agree, but I still prefer the original (meaning their original cover).
And how would you rate the original cover to the superior Jimmy Reed original?
Johnny Winter did a nice version as well in 1978 - one that I prefer over the Stones' version.
Agree.Quote
Rockman
None or 'em .... prefer the Glimmers ta tell us what they think of a 2017 world ....
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
RoughJusticeOnYa
Concerning these 'Stripped' recording sessions: I quite liked what they did with/ to "The Spider and The Fly", f.i.
That really worked!
"Angie": not so much...
"Wild Horses": brilliant.
"Beast of Burden": redundant.
Spot on!
Angie was a real live take, though. That BOB-version rightfully remained an outtake, imo.
Love In Vain was pretty good as well. Honest I Do was excellent.
Memory Motel and LSTNT were so so..