Tell Me :
Talk
Why nothing post-1997?
.....
Olly.
Only one studio record in last 18 years!
so... tie you up but no SFTD?... 2 songs from exile (a double album) and 4 from tattoo you?
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-11 07:22 by Turner68.
HA HA! That's hilarious.
Horrible song. Awful bad song.
'Memory Motel' would give Richards' vocals some added exposure I suppose.
I don't care much for any of the 4 'new' songs on Forty Licks, but 'Keys to Your Love' does feature a nice solo.
.....
Olly.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-13 23:42 by Olly.
Of the 4 new songs on FORTY LICKS Don't Stop is decent and I've always liked Keith's number. But really, Don't Stop would've been enough.
Keys To Your Love I deleted and refuse to listen to it's so bad. And the other one. Just horrendous. How they thought those were good enough... they could've put at least 2 other songs on the damn thing, like Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker) and maybe One Hit (To The Body) or She Was Hot or Hot Stuff or All Down The Line or Bitch.
actually --- this has been the basis for rolling stones' releases for the past 40 years.
at some point, they will have released more greatest hits albums than they have released albums.
there are at least 14 greatest hits compilation albums:
- big hits
- through the past darkly
- milestones (uk, decca)
- hot rocks
- more hot rocks
- made in the shade
- rolled gold (uk, decca)
- time waits for no one (uk)
- sucking in the 70s
- rewind
- singles collection
- jump back
- 40 licks
- GRR
Excellent point Turner..perhaps a best of the "best of" would be appropriate at this point.
But in this day and age where everyone can make their own playlists it seems almost pointless to me to be releasing these compilation records without something new on the table.
My most played Stones playlist is my countrified one which includes all my favorite country flavored Stones tunes from Beggar's Banquet through Some Girls with a few extra gems thrown in like 100 Years Ago, Let It Loose, etc.
well put :-)
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-15 02:22 by Turner68.
i think in your excellent post is also the inspiration for the title of the new greatest hits album...
STONES SANS
LOFL!!!!
I know there will never be a compilation everyone agrees on. But, I think the 2CD GRRR! does a fair job of accomplishing the task.
Well, if ya need me to chime in, sure, why not?
Instead of 80-90% singles/hits, the Rolling Stones ultimate compilation I'd like to see would be geared towards a long-playing experience, not a collection of stand-alone hits. For the 1963-'67 period, sure, include the singles and 3-4 lesser known cuts but then have lots of non-singles from the album era 1968 onward. It should be thick with stuff like Jigsaw Puzzle, Monkey Man, CYHMK, Rocks Off, Let It Loose, Winter, etc and maybe have just 10-12 singles/hits from JJF to the current day. No need for WH, Angie, Miss You, Fool to Cry, SMU, YGMR and it would be even more impressive of a collection for it; knowing that this 50 song suite didn't even include some of their best known songs.
Outside of live and rarity compilations, it's really the only remaining catalogue-pusher and legacy-expanding type of compilation they could use. Otherwise, as Turner68 noted, they're going to have more greatest hits type releases than studio ones soon!
I categorically disagree, owing mainly to the underrepresentation of tracks featuring Richards lead vocals, which I highlighted earlier in this discussion.
.....
Olly.
is anyone else irritated by rhetorical questions?
You forgot at least One Hit To The Body, Highwire, Doom And Gloom and Love Is Strong and of course Flip The Switch and Undercover Of The Night. And Feel On Baby... and... and... and...
I am going to work on a personal compilation that completely avoids warhorses and hits, this will be interesting indeed - deep cuts only.
Talk about your favorite band.
For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
buttons67
()
Date: July 11, 2015 02:44
imagine the stones are putting together a compilation album of thier work from the start to the present day and they want you to pick 50 songs that highlight all the abilities and success of the band in every era and one which best represents the bands history and all its versatility and variety.
and its going to be released as a superdeluxe package comprising of dvd, vinyl and cd with all the trimmings, photos, interviews etc.
my 50 would be.
1.she said yeah
2.off the hook
3.its all over now
4.the last time
5.satisfaction
6.paint it black
7.19th nervous breakdown
8.cool calm collected
9.back street girl
10.ruby tuesday
11.we love you
12.shes a rainbow
13.citadel
14jj flash
15.jigsaw puzzle
16.no expectetions
17.child of the moon
18.gimme shelter
19.midnight rambler
20.honky tonk woman
21.brown sugar
22.wild horses
23.moonlight mile
24.let it loose
25.loving cup
26.silver train
27.time waits for no one
28.fingerprint file
29.crazy mama
30.memory motel
31.shattered
32.far away eyes
33.some girls
34.shes so cold
35.start me up
36.slave
37.little t and a
38.worried about you
39.she was hot
40. tie you up.
41. continental drift
42.almost hear you sigh
43.highwire
44.love is strong
45.like a rolling stone
46.infamy
47.rough justice
48.laugh i nearly died.
49. plundered my soul
50. doom and gloom
and its going to be released as a superdeluxe package comprising of dvd, vinyl and cd with all the trimmings, photos, interviews etc.
my 50 would be.
1.she said yeah
2.off the hook
3.its all over now
4.the last time
5.satisfaction
6.paint it black
7.19th nervous breakdown
8.cool calm collected
9.back street girl
10.ruby tuesday
11.we love you
12.shes a rainbow
13.citadel
14jj flash
15.jigsaw puzzle
16.no expectetions
17.child of the moon
18.gimme shelter
19.midnight rambler
20.honky tonk woman
21.brown sugar
22.wild horses
23.moonlight mile
24.let it loose
25.loving cup
26.silver train
27.time waits for no one
28.fingerprint file
29.crazy mama
30.memory motel
31.shattered
32.far away eyes
33.some girls
34.shes so cold
35.start me up
36.slave
37.little t and a
38.worried about you
39.she was hot
40. tie you up.
41. continental drift
42.almost hear you sigh
43.highwire
44.love is strong
45.like a rolling stone
46.infamy
47.rough justice
48.laugh i nearly died.
49. plundered my soul
50. doom and gloom
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Send It To me
()
Date: July 11, 2015 03:18
Needs to be 60
the 21 songs from hot rocks
22. The Last Time
23. Not Fade Away
24. Out of Time
25. She's A Rainbow
26. No Expectations
27. Salt of the Earth
28. Live With Me
29. Moonlight Mile
30. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
31. Rocks Off
32. Tumbling Dice
33. Happy
34. Sweet Virginia
35. Angie
36. Heartbreaker
37. Star Star
38. If You Can't Rock Me
39. IORR
40. Ain't Too Proud
41. Hand of Fate
42. Crazy Mamma
43. Memory Motel
44.-51. all of Some Girls except Lies & Imagination
52. She's So Cold
53. Start Me Up
54. Hang Fire
55. Worried About You
56. Undercover
57. One Hit
58. Mixed Emotions
59. Highwire
60. Out of Control
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-11 03:21 by Send It To me.
the 21 songs from hot rocks
22. The Last Time
23. Not Fade Away
24. Out of Time
25. She's A Rainbow
26. No Expectations
27. Salt of the Earth
28. Live With Me
29. Moonlight Mile
30. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
31. Rocks Off
32. Tumbling Dice
33. Happy
34. Sweet Virginia
35. Angie
36. Heartbreaker
37. Star Star
38. If You Can't Rock Me
39. IORR
40. Ain't Too Proud
41. Hand of Fate
42. Crazy Mamma
43. Memory Motel
44.-51. all of Some Girls except Lies & Imagination
52. She's So Cold
53. Start Me Up
54. Hang Fire
55. Worried About You
56. Undercover
57. One Hit
58. Mixed Emotions
59. Highwire
60. Out of Control
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-11 03:21 by Send It To me.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Olly
()
Date: July 11, 2015 03:34
Quote
Send It To me
Needs to be 60
the 21 songs from hot rocks
22. The Last Time
23. Not Fade Away
24. Out of Time
25. She's A Rainbow
26. No Expectations
27. Salt of the Earth
28. Live With Me
29. Moonlight Mile
30. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
31. Rocks Off
32. Tumbling Dice
33. Happy
34. Sweet Virginia
35. Angie
36. Heartbreaker
37. Star Star
38. If You Can't Rock Me
39. IORR
40. Ain't Too Proud
41. Hand of Fate
42. Crazy Mamma
43. Memory Motel
44.-51. all of Some Girls except Lies & Imagination
52. She's So Cold
53. Start Me Up
54. Hang Fire
55. Worried About You
56. Undercover
57. One Hit
58. Mixed Emotions
59. Highwire
60. Out of Control
Why nothing post-1997?
.....
Olly.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Send It To me
()
Date: July 11, 2015 04:24
Quote
OllyQuote
Send It To me
Needs to be 60
the 21 songs from hot rocks
22. The Last Time
23. Not Fade Away
24. Out of Time
25. She's A Rainbow
26. No Expectations
27. Salt of the Earth
28. Live With Me
29. Moonlight Mile
30. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
31. Rocks Off
32. Tumbling Dice
33. Happy
34. Sweet Virginia
35. Angie
36. Heartbreaker
37. Star Star
38. If You Can't Rock Me
39. IORR
40. Ain't Too Proud
41. Hand of Fate
42. Crazy Mamma
43. Memory Motel
44.-51. all of Some Girls except Lies & Imagination
52. She's So Cold
53. Start Me Up
54. Hang Fire
55. Worried About You
56. Undercover
57. One Hit
58. Mixed Emotions
59. Highwire
60. Out of Control
Why nothing post-1997?
Only one studio record in last 18 years!
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
GasLightStreet
()
Date: July 11, 2015 06:17
Take HOT ROCKS and throw in (except for repeats, of course) MADE IN THE SHADE, TIME WAITS FOR NO ONE, SUCKING IN THE SEVENTIES and REWIND and that says, perhaps, enough. If a lot is enough, that is. Although they have had some great songs post UNDERCOVER/REWIND, critically they don't matter.
But I would throw in a couple from STEEL WHEELS, VOODOO, BRIDGES and BANG for sure.
But I would throw in a couple from STEEL WHEELS, VOODOO, BRIDGES and BANG for sure.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Cristiano Radtke
()
Date: July 11, 2015 07:16
Quote
Send It To meQuote
OllyQuote
Send It To me
Needs to be 60
Why nothing post-1997?
Only one studio record in last 18 years!
What about "A Bigger Bang"?
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Turner68
()
Date: July 11, 2015 07:19
Quote
buttons67
imagine the stones are putting together a compilation album of thier work from the start to the present day and they want you to pick 50 songs that highlight all the abilities and success of the band in every era and one which best represents the bands history and all its versatility and variety.
and its going to be released as a superdeluxe package comprising of dvd, vinyl and cd with all the trimmings, photos, interviews etc.
my 50 would be.
1.she said yeah
2.off the hook
3.its all over now
4.the last time
5.satisfaction
6.paint it black
7.19th nervous breakdown
8.cool calm collected
9.back street girl
10.ruby tuesday
11.we love you
12.shes a rainbow
13.citadel
14jj flash
15.jigsaw puzzle
16.no expectetions
17.child of the moon
18.gimme shelter
19.midnight rambler
20.honky tonk woman
21.brown sugar
22.wild horses
23.moonlight mile
24.let it loose
25.loving cup
26.silver train
27.time waits for no one
28.fingerprint file
29.crazy mama
30.memory motel
31.shattered
32.far away eyes
33.some girls
34.shes so cold
35.start me up
36.slave
37.little t and a
38.worried about you
39.she was hot
40. tie you up.
41. continental drift
42.almost hear you sigh
43.highwire
44.love is strong
45.like a rolling stone
46.infamy
47.rough justice
48.laugh i nearly died.
49. plundered my soul
50. doom and gloom
so... tie you up but no SFTD?... 2 songs from exile (a double album) and 4 from tattoo you?
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-11 07:22 by Turner68.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
RaiseTheKnife
()
Date: July 11, 2015 14:42
I would not buy another best of if there was not any rare live recordings on it. But I would buy something like this:
DISC 1
1. Tell Me
2. Route 66 (LA '73)
3. She Said Yeah
4. Mercy Mercy
5. Satisfaction (New Zealand '66)
6. What To Do
7. Flight 505
8. 19th Nervous Breakdown
9. Mother Little Helper (Virginia Beach '66)
10. She Smiled Sweetly
11. Let's Spend The Night Together (Paris '67)
12. Paint It Black (Paris '67)
13. Out Of Time
14. Honky Tonk Women (London '76)
15. Sympathy For The Devil
16. Salt Of The Earth
17. Jumping Jack Flash (Palm Beach '69)
18 Live With Me
19. Love In Vain
20. Can't You Hear Me Knocking (Brighton '71)
21. Wild Horses
22. Brown Sugar (Rotterdam '73)
23. Loving Cup
24. All Down The Line (Frankfurt '76)
25. Coming Down Again
DISC TWO
1. 100 Years Ago (Vienna '73)
2. Silver Train (Vienna '73)
3. Time Waits For No One
4. If You Can't Rock Me (Cleveland '02)
5. Hand Of Fate
6. Memory Hotel (Live '98 without Dave Matthews)
7. Lies
8. Miss You
9. Start Me Up (Gothenburg '07)
10. Slave (2002 Rehearsals)
11. Dance Pt. 2
12. She Was Hot (Extended cut)
13. One Hit
14. Mixed Emotions
15. Slipping Away
16. Moon Is Up (Shepards Bush '99)
17. Out Of Tears
18. Flip The Switch
19. Saint Of Me (Amsterdam '98)
20. Rough Justice
21. It Won't Take Long
22. Back Of My Hand (Boston '05)
23. Doom And Gloom
24. Keys To Your Love
25. Don't Stop (Bangalore '03)
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-11 15:02 by RaiseTheKnife.
DISC 1
1. Tell Me
2. Route 66 (LA '73)
3. She Said Yeah
4. Mercy Mercy
5. Satisfaction (New Zealand '66)
6. What To Do
7. Flight 505
8. 19th Nervous Breakdown
9. Mother Little Helper (Virginia Beach '66)
10. She Smiled Sweetly
11. Let's Spend The Night Together (Paris '67)
12. Paint It Black (Paris '67)
13. Out Of Time
14. Honky Tonk Women (London '76)
15. Sympathy For The Devil
16. Salt Of The Earth
17. Jumping Jack Flash (Palm Beach '69)
18 Live With Me
19. Love In Vain
20. Can't You Hear Me Knocking (Brighton '71)
21. Wild Horses
22. Brown Sugar (Rotterdam '73)
23. Loving Cup
24. All Down The Line (Frankfurt '76)
25. Coming Down Again
DISC TWO
1. 100 Years Ago (Vienna '73)
2. Silver Train (Vienna '73)
3. Time Waits For No One
4. If You Can't Rock Me (Cleveland '02)
5. Hand Of Fate
6. Memory Hotel (Live '98 without Dave Matthews)
7. Lies
8. Miss You
9. Start Me Up (Gothenburg '07)
10. Slave (2002 Rehearsals)
11. Dance Pt. 2
12. She Was Hot (Extended cut)
13. One Hit
14. Mixed Emotions
15. Slipping Away
16. Moon Is Up (Shepards Bush '99)
17. Out Of Tears
18. Flip The Switch
19. Saint Of Me (Amsterdam '98)
20. Rough Justice
21. It Won't Take Long
22. Back Of My Hand (Boston '05)
23. Doom And Gloom
24. Keys To Your Love
25. Don't Stop (Bangalore '03)
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-11 15:02 by RaiseTheKnife.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Olly
()
Date: July 12, 2015 21:09
One of the problems I have with the GRRR! compilations is the underrepresentation of tracks featuring Richards lead vocals.
'Happy' is the sole selection on the 40 and 50 track GRRR! compilations. The 80 track version also features 'You Got The Silver'.
What a shame.
Any career-spanning compilation should include more songs sung by Richards as they have played an increasingly important part in the band's sound since the late 1960s, and the numbers sung by Richards, especially on releases in the 1980s and 1990s, offer great quality and diversity.
A 50+ track compilation should make room for 'Happy', 'Before They Make Me Run' and at least one of the following:
.....
Olly.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-13 23:23 by Olly.
'Happy' is the sole selection on the 40 and 50 track GRRR! compilations. The 80 track version also features 'You Got The Silver'.
What a shame.
Any career-spanning compilation should include more songs sung by Richards as they have played an increasingly important part in the band's sound since the late 1960s, and the numbers sung by Richards, especially on releases in the 1980s and 1990s, offer great quality and diversity.
A 50+ track compilation should make room for 'Happy', 'Before They Make Me Run' and at least one of the following:
- [*] 'Little T & A'
[*] 'The Worst'
[*] 'Thief in the Night'
.....
Olly.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-13 23:23 by Olly.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
GasLightStreet
()
Date: July 13, 2015 15:19
Quote
RaiseTheKnife
Memory Hotel (Live '98 without Dave Matthews)
HA HA! That's hilarious.
Quote
RaiseTheKnife
Keys To Your Love
Horrible song. Awful bad song.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Olly
()
Date: July 13, 2015 23:28
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
RaiseTheKnife
Memory Hotel (Live '98 without Dave Matthews)
HA HA! That's hilarious.Quote
RaiseTheKnife
Keys To Your Love
Horrible song. Awful bad song.
'Memory Motel' would give Richards' vocals some added exposure I suppose.
I don't care much for any of the 4 'new' songs on Forty Licks, but 'Keys to Your Love' does feature a nice solo.
.....
Olly.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-13 23:42 by Olly.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
StonesHood
()
Date: July 13, 2015 23:35
51. Luxury
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
GasLightStreet
()
Date: July 14, 2015 20:21
Quote
Olly
I don't care much for any of the 4 'new' songs on Forty Licks, but 'Keys to Your Love' does feature a nice solo.
Of the 4 new songs on FORTY LICKS Don't Stop is decent and I've always liked Keith's number. But really, Don't Stop would've been enough.
Keys To Your Love I deleted and refuse to listen to it's so bad. And the other one. Just horrendous. How they thought those were good enough... they could've put at least 2 other songs on the damn thing, like Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker) and maybe One Hit (To The Body) or She Was Hot or Hot Stuff or All Down The Line or Bitch.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Turner68
()
Date: July 14, 2015 22:37
Quote
MattClifford
You people make it far too easy for Mick. You all probably happily purchased GRRR and now you are daydreaming: "Man, if there was another one just like it."
actually --- this has been the basis for rolling stones' releases for the past 40 years.
at some point, they will have released more greatest hits albums than they have released albums.
there are at least 14 greatest hits compilation albums:
- big hits
- through the past darkly
- milestones (uk, decca)
- hot rocks
- more hot rocks
- made in the shade
- rolled gold (uk, decca)
- time waits for no one (uk)
- sucking in the 70s
- rewind
- singles collection
- jump back
- 40 licks
- GRR
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Naturalust
()
Date: July 15, 2015 01:50
Quote
Turner68Quote
MattClifford
You people make it far too easy for Mick. You all probably happily purchased GRRR and now you are daydreaming: "Man, if there was another one just like it."
actually --- this has been the basis for rolling stones' releases for the past 40 years.
at some point, they will have released more greatest hits albums than they have released albums.
there are at least 14 greatest hits compilation albums:
- big hits
- through the past darkly
- milestones (uk, decca)
- hot rocks
- more hot rocks
- made in the shade
- rolled gold (uk, decca)
- time waits for no one (uk)
- sucking in the 70s
- rewind
- singles collection
- jump back
- 40 licks
- GRR
Excellent point Turner..perhaps a best of the "best of" would be appropriate at this point.
But in this day and age where everyone can make their own playlists it seems almost pointless to me to be releasing these compilation records without something new on the table.
My most played Stones playlist is my countrified one which includes all my favorite country flavored Stones tunes from Beggar's Banquet through Some Girls with a few extra gems thrown in like 100 Years Ago, Let It Loose, etc.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
umakmehrd
()
Date: July 15, 2015 02:14
No Winter ????
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Turner68
()
Date: July 15, 2015 02:22
Quote
NaturalustQuote
Turner68Quote
MattClifford
You people make it far too easy for Mick. You all probably happily purchased GRRR and now you are daydreaming: "Man, if there was another one just like it."
actually --- this has been the basis for rolling stones' releases for the past 40 years.
at some point, they will have released more greatest hits albums than they have released albums.
there are at least 14 greatest hits compilation albums:
- big hits
- through the past darkly
- milestones (uk, decca)
- hot rocks
- more hot rocks
- made in the shade
- rolled gold (uk, decca)
- time waits for no one (uk)
- sucking in the 70s
- rewind
- singles collection
- jump back
- 40 licks
- GRR
Excellent point Turner..perhaps a best of the "best of" would be appropriate at this point.
But in this day and age where everyone can make their own playlists it seems almost pointless to me to be releasing these compilation records without something new on the table.
My most played Stones playlist is my countrified one which includes all my favorite country flavored Stones tunes from Beggar's Banquet through Some Girls with a few extra gems thrown in like 100 Years Ago, Let It Loose, etc.
well put :-)
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-15 02:22 by Turner68.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
GasLightStreet
()
Date: July 15, 2015 02:35
Disc 2 or sides 3 & 4 of HOT ROCKS sans YCAGWYW and Midnight Rambler
MADE IN THE SHADE sans Angie, Brown Sugar and Wild Horses
TIME WAITS FOR NO ONE sans Angie, If You Can't Rock Me/Get Off My Cloud, Bitch
SUCKING IN THE SEVENTIES sans Mannish Boy, Whip and the three BLACK AND BLUE tracks
REWIND sans Angie, Beast Of Burden
That's perfection right there.
MADE IN THE SHADE sans Angie, Brown Sugar and Wild Horses
TIME WAITS FOR NO ONE sans Angie, If You Can't Rock Me/Get Off My Cloud, Bitch
SUCKING IN THE SEVENTIES sans Mannish Boy, Whip and the three BLACK AND BLUE tracks
REWIND sans Angie, Beast Of Burden
That's perfection right there.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Turner68
()
Date: July 15, 2015 02:51
Quote
GasLightStreet
Disc 2 or sides 3 & 4 of HOT ROCKS sans YCAGWYW and Midnight Rambler
MADE IN THE SHADE sans Angie, Brown Sugar and Wild Horses
TIME WAITS FOR NO ONE sans Angie, If You Can't Rock Me/Get Off My Cloud, Bitch
SUCKING IN THE SEVENTIES sans Mannish Boy, Whip and the three BLACK AND BLUE tracks
REWIND sans Angie, Beast Of Burden
That's perfection right there.
i think in your excellent post is also the inspiration for the title of the new greatest hits album...
STONES SANS
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
GasLightStreet
()
Date: July 15, 2015 02:58
Quote
Turner68Quote
GasLightStreet
Disc 2 or sides 3 & 4 of HOT ROCKS sans YCAGWYW and Midnight Rambler
MADE IN THE SHADE sans Angie, Brown Sugar and Wild Horses
TIME WAITS FOR NO ONE sans Angie, If You Can't Rock Me/Get Off My Cloud, Bitch
SUCKING IN THE SEVENTIES sans Mannish Boy, Whip and the three BLACK AND BLUE tracks
REWIND sans Angie, Beast Of Burden
That's perfection right there.
i think in your excellent post is also the inspiration for the title of the new greatest hits album...
STONES SANS
LOFL!!!!
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
tonyc
()
Date: July 15, 2015 03:56
Quote
MattClifford
You people make it far too easy for Mick. You all probably happily purchased GRRR and now you are daydreaming: "Man, if there was another one just like it."
I know there will never be a compilation everyone agrees on. But, I think the 2CD GRRR! does a fair job of accomplishing the task.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
winter
()
Date: July 15, 2015 09:01
Quote
umakmehrd
No Winter ????
Well, if ya need me to chime in, sure, why not?
Instead of 80-90% singles/hits, the Rolling Stones ultimate compilation I'd like to see would be geared towards a long-playing experience, not a collection of stand-alone hits. For the 1963-'67 period, sure, include the singles and 3-4 lesser known cuts but then have lots of non-singles from the album era 1968 onward. It should be thick with stuff like Jigsaw Puzzle, Monkey Man, CYHMK, Rocks Off, Let It Loose, Winter, etc and maybe have just 10-12 singles/hits from JJF to the current day. No need for WH, Angie, Miss You, Fool to Cry, SMU, YGMR and it would be even more impressive of a collection for it; knowing that this 50 song suite didn't even include some of their best known songs.
Outside of live and rarity compilations, it's really the only remaining catalogue-pusher and legacy-expanding type of compilation they could use. Otherwise, as Turner68 noted, they're going to have more greatest hits type releases than studio ones soon!
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Olly
()
Date: July 20, 2015 20:56
Quote
tonyc
I know there will never be a compilation everyone agrees on. But, I think the 2CD GRRR! does a fair job of accomplishing the task.
I categorically disagree, owing mainly to the underrepresentation of tracks featuring Richards lead vocals, which I highlighted earlier in this discussion.
.....
Olly.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
kowalski
()
Date: February 15, 2016 03:40
If it was ever released on CD, would you buy this one : [online.bmg.com]
Solid selection of songs of modern Stones era IMO.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016-02-15 03:41 by kowalski.
Solid selection of songs of modern Stones era IMO.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016-02-15 03:41 by kowalski.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
treaclefingers
()
Date: February 15, 2016 05:56
Quote
OllyQuote
Send It To me
Needs to be 60
the 21 songs from hot rocks
22. The Last Time
23. Not Fade Away
24. Out of Time
25. She's A Rainbow
26. No Expectations
27. Salt of the Earth
28. Live With Me
29. Moonlight Mile
30. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
31. Rocks Off
32. Tumbling Dice
33. Happy
34. Sweet Virginia
35. Angie
36. Heartbreaker
37. Star Star
38. If You Can't Rock Me
39. IORR
40. Ain't Too Proud
41. Hand of Fate
42. Crazy Mamma
43. Memory Motel
44.-51. all of Some Girls except Lies & Imagination
52. She's So Cold
53. Start Me Up
54. Hang Fire
55. Worried About You
56. Undercover
57. One Hit
58. Mixed Emotions
59. Highwire
60. Out of Control
Why nothing post-1997?
is anyone else irritated by rhetorical questions?
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
jackflash1129
()
Date: February 15, 2016 07:04
I'd do 150 songs
1. I wanna be loved
2. Mona
3. Not fade away
4. Time is on my side
5. It's all over now
6. Good times bad times
7. Heart of stone
8. Little red rooster
9. She said yeah
10. Mercy mercy
11. The last time
12. The spider and the fly
13. Play with fire
14. I'm free
15. Satisfaction
16. As tears go by
17. Get off of my cloud
18. Under my thumb
19. Paint it black
20. Long long while
21. Mothers little helper
22. Out of time
23. Lady Jane
24. Backstreet girl
25. Ride on baby
26. Yesterdays papers
27. Connection
28. She smiled sweetly
29. Lets spend the night together
30. Ruby Tuesday
31. We love you
32. Dandelion
33. 2000 man
34. She's a rainbow
35. 2000 light years from home
36. Chip of the moon
37. Jumpin Jack flash
38. Sympathy for the devil
39. No expectations
40. Dear Doctor
41. Jigsaw Puzzle
42. Street fighting man
43. Stray cat blues
44. Factory girl
45. Salt of the earth
46. I dont know why
47. Honky tonk woman
48. Memo from turner
49. Gimme Shelter
50. Live with me
51. Let it bleed
52. Monkey man
53. You got the silver
54. You can't always get what you want
55. Love in vain live
56. Midnight rambler live
57. Brown Sugar
58. Sway
59. Wild horses
60. Can't you hear me knocking
61. Bitch
62. I got the blues
63. Dead flowers
64. Sister morphine
65. Moonlight mile
66. Rocks off
67. Rip this joint
68. Tumbling dice
69. Sweet Virginia
70. Loving cup
71. Happy
72. Let it loose
73. All down the Lin
74. Shine a light
75. 100 years ago
76. Coming down again
77. Winter
78. Angie
79. Heartbreaker
80. Star star
81. If you cant rock me
82. It's only rock and roll
83. Time waits for no one
84. Dance little sister
85. Through the lonely nights
86. Hot stuff
87. Hand of fate
88. Memory motel
89. Fool to cry
90. Miss you
91. Some girls
92. Far away eyes
93. Respectable
94. Before they make me run
95. Beast of burden
96. Shattered
97. Emotional rescue
98. Dance
99. She's so Col
100. All about you
101. Start me up
102. Hang fire
103. Little T&A
104. Worried about you
105. Tops
106. No use jn crying
107. Waiting on a friend
108. Undercover of the night
109. Wanna hold you
110. Too much blood
111. One hit to the body
112. Sad sad sad
113. Mixed emotions
114. Rock and a hard place
115. Cant be seen
116. Slipping away
117. Almost hear you sigh
118. High wire
119. Love is strong
120. You got me rocking
121. Sparks will fly
122. The worst
123. Blinded by rainbows
124. I go wild
125. Jump on top of me baby
126. Anybody seen my baby
127. Flip the switch
128. Out of control
129. Saint of me
130. You don't have to mean it
131. Thief in the night
132. How can I stop
133. Dont stop
134. Rough Justice
135. Let me down slow
136. Rain fall down
137. Back of my hand
138. Oh no not you again
139. Plundered my soul
140. Dancing in the light
141. I'm not signifying
142. Following the river
143. Do you think I really care?
144. When you're gone
145. Tallahassee lassie
146. So young
147. We had it all
148. No spare parts
149. One more shot
150. Doom and gloom
1. I wanna be loved
2. Mona
3. Not fade away
4. Time is on my side
5. It's all over now
6. Good times bad times
7. Heart of stone
8. Little red rooster
9. She said yeah
10. Mercy mercy
11. The last time
12. The spider and the fly
13. Play with fire
14. I'm free
15. Satisfaction
16. As tears go by
17. Get off of my cloud
18. Under my thumb
19. Paint it black
20. Long long while
21. Mothers little helper
22. Out of time
23. Lady Jane
24. Backstreet girl
25. Ride on baby
26. Yesterdays papers
27. Connection
28. She smiled sweetly
29. Lets spend the night together
30. Ruby Tuesday
31. We love you
32. Dandelion
33. 2000 man
34. She's a rainbow
35. 2000 light years from home
36. Chip of the moon
37. Jumpin Jack flash
38. Sympathy for the devil
39. No expectations
40. Dear Doctor
41. Jigsaw Puzzle
42. Street fighting man
43. Stray cat blues
44. Factory girl
45. Salt of the earth
46. I dont know why
47. Honky tonk woman
48. Memo from turner
49. Gimme Shelter
50. Live with me
51. Let it bleed
52. Monkey man
53. You got the silver
54. You can't always get what you want
55. Love in vain live
56. Midnight rambler live
57. Brown Sugar
58. Sway
59. Wild horses
60. Can't you hear me knocking
61. Bitch
62. I got the blues
63. Dead flowers
64. Sister morphine
65. Moonlight mile
66. Rocks off
67. Rip this joint
68. Tumbling dice
69. Sweet Virginia
70. Loving cup
71. Happy
72. Let it loose
73. All down the Lin
74. Shine a light
75. 100 years ago
76. Coming down again
77. Winter
78. Angie
79. Heartbreaker
80. Star star
81. If you cant rock me
82. It's only rock and roll
83. Time waits for no one
84. Dance little sister
85. Through the lonely nights
86. Hot stuff
87. Hand of fate
88. Memory motel
89. Fool to cry
90. Miss you
91. Some girls
92. Far away eyes
93. Respectable
94. Before they make me run
95. Beast of burden
96. Shattered
97. Emotional rescue
98. Dance
99. She's so Col
100. All about you
101. Start me up
102. Hang fire
103. Little T&A
104. Worried about you
105. Tops
106. No use jn crying
107. Waiting on a friend
108. Undercover of the night
109. Wanna hold you
110. Too much blood
111. One hit to the body
112. Sad sad sad
113. Mixed emotions
114. Rock and a hard place
115. Cant be seen
116. Slipping away
117. Almost hear you sigh
118. High wire
119. Love is strong
120. You got me rocking
121. Sparks will fly
122. The worst
123. Blinded by rainbows
124. I go wild
125. Jump on top of me baby
126. Anybody seen my baby
127. Flip the switch
128. Out of control
129. Saint of me
130. You don't have to mean it
131. Thief in the night
132. How can I stop
133. Dont stop
134. Rough Justice
135. Let me down slow
136. Rain fall down
137. Back of my hand
138. Oh no not you again
139. Plundered my soul
140. Dancing in the light
141. I'm not signifying
142. Following the river
143. Do you think I really care?
144. When you're gone
145. Tallahassee lassie
146. So young
147. We had it all
148. No spare parts
149. One more shot
150. Doom and gloom
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
HopeYouGuessMyName
()
Date: February 15, 2016 07:29
TILL THE NEXT GOODBYE?
FINGERPRINT FILE?
TOO TOUGH?
IT MUST BE HELL?
....
What the heck.....let's face it....we will need 200 songs!
FINGERPRINT FILE?
TOO TOUGH?
IT MUST BE HELL?
....
What the heck.....let's face it....we will need 200 songs!
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
Turner68
()
Date: February 15, 2016 11:07
Only 12 songs are needed
Little Red Rooster
Paint it Black
Satisfaction
Jumping Jack Flash
Honky Tonk Women
Gimme Shelter
Carol (live, Ya-Ya's)
Rambler (live, Ya-Ya's)
Brown Sugar
Happy
Miss You
Start Me up
What more is there to say?
Little Red Rooster
Paint it Black
Satisfaction
Jumping Jack Flash
Honky Tonk Women
Gimme Shelter
Carol (live, Ya-Ya's)
Rambler (live, Ya-Ya's)
Brown Sugar
Happy
Miss You
Start Me up
What more is there to say?
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
HMS
()
Date: February 15, 2016 12:37
Quote
Turner68
Only 12 songs are needed
Little Red Rooster
Paint it Black
Satisfaction
Jumping Jack Flash
Honky Tonk Women
Gimme Shelter
Carol (live, Ya-Ya's)
Rambler (live, Ya-Ya's)
Brown Sugar
Happy
Miss You
Start Me up
What more is there to say?
You forgot at least One Hit To The Body, Highwire, Doom And Gloom and Love Is Strong and of course Flip The Switch and Undercover Of The Night. And Feel On Baby... and... and... and...
I am going to work on a personal compilation that completely avoids warhorses and hits, this will be interesting indeed - deep cuts only.
Re: the stones ultimate compilation album
Posted by:
DandelionPowderman
()
Date: February 15, 2016 12:50
1. Come On
2. I Wanna Be Your Man
3. I Just Can't Be Satisfied
4. It's All Over Now
5. The Last Time
6. Satisfaction
7. Get Off Of My Cloud
8. Under My Thumb
9. Paint It, Black
10. Going Home
11. Have You Seen Your Mother Standing In The Shadow
12. 19th Nervous Breakdown
13. Back Street Girl
14. Let's Spend The Night Together
15. She Smiled Sweetly
16. Connection
17. All Sold Out
18. Citadel
19. She's A Rainbow
20. 2000 Light Years From Home
21. Child Of The Moon
22. We Love You
23. Dandelion
24. Sympathy For The Devil
25. Stray Cat Blues
26. Parachute Woman
27. No Expectations
28. Street Fighting Man
29. Salt Of The Earth
30. Gimmie Shelter
31. Midnight Rambler
32. Love In Vain
33. Monkey Man
34. You Can't Always Get What You Want
35. Little Queenie (live)
36. Brown Sugar
37. Wild Horses
38. Bitch
39. Rocks Off
40. Let It Loose
41. All Down The Line
42. Angie
43. 100 Years Ago
44. If You Really Want To Be My Friend
45. Fingerprint File
46. It's Only Rock'n'Roll
47. Hot Stuff
48. Memory Motel
49. Fool To Cry
50. Miss You
51. Beast Of Burden
52. Shattered
53. Far Away Eyes
54. Dance (Pt. 1)
55. Down In The Holw
56. Emotional Rescue
57. She's So Cold
58. Start Me Up
59. Worried About You
60. Little T + A
61. Waiting On A Friend
62. Undercover (Of The Night)
63. She Was Hot
64. Too Much Blood
65. Tie You Up (The Pain Of Love)
66. One Hit (To The Body)
67. Harlem Shuffle
68. Dirty Work
69. Sad Sad Sad
70. Mixed Emotions
71. Terrifying
72. Almost Hear You Sigh
73. Love Is Strong
74. You Got Me Rocking
75. Anybody Seen My Baby
76. Saint Of Me
77. How Can I Stop
78. Don't Stop
79. Rough Justice
80. Let Me Down Slow
81. Doom And Gloom
82. One More Shot
83. When The Whip Comes Down (live 1978)
84. Mannish Boy (live 1977)
2. I Wanna Be Your Man
3. I Just Can't Be Satisfied
4. It's All Over Now
5. The Last Time
6. Satisfaction
7. Get Off Of My Cloud
8. Under My Thumb
9. Paint It, Black
10. Going Home
11. Have You Seen Your Mother Standing In The Shadow
12. 19th Nervous Breakdown
13. Back Street Girl
14. Let's Spend The Night Together
15. She Smiled Sweetly
16. Connection
17. All Sold Out
18. Citadel
19. She's A Rainbow
20. 2000 Light Years From Home
21. Child Of The Moon
22. We Love You
23. Dandelion
24. Sympathy For The Devil
25. Stray Cat Blues
26. Parachute Woman
27. No Expectations
28. Street Fighting Man
29. Salt Of The Earth
30. Gimmie Shelter
31. Midnight Rambler
32. Love In Vain
33. Monkey Man
34. You Can't Always Get What You Want
35. Little Queenie (live)
36. Brown Sugar
37. Wild Horses
38. Bitch
39. Rocks Off
40. Let It Loose
41. All Down The Line
42. Angie
43. 100 Years Ago
44. If You Really Want To Be My Friend
45. Fingerprint File
46. It's Only Rock'n'Roll
47. Hot Stuff
48. Memory Motel
49. Fool To Cry
50. Miss You
51. Beast Of Burden
52. Shattered
53. Far Away Eyes
54. Dance (Pt. 1)
55. Down In The Holw
56. Emotional Rescue
57. She's So Cold
58. Start Me Up
59. Worried About You
60. Little T + A
61. Waiting On A Friend
62. Undercover (Of The Night)
63. She Was Hot
64. Too Much Blood
65. Tie You Up (The Pain Of Love)
66. One Hit (To The Body)
67. Harlem Shuffle
68. Dirty Work
69. Sad Sad Sad
70. Mixed Emotions
71. Terrifying
72. Almost Hear You Sigh
73. Love Is Strong
74. You Got Me Rocking
75. Anybody Seen My Baby
76. Saint Of Me
77. How Can I Stop
78. Don't Stop
79. Rough Justice
80. Let Me Down Slow
81. Doom And Gloom
82. One More Shot
83. When The Whip Comes Down (live 1978)
84. Mannish Boy (live 1977)
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Online Users
bauk77 , charlystone , chris girard , crawdaddy , Heart for Stones , imthemastah , keefmick , mako1964 , ohmercy61 , PaintMonkeyManBlack , perkmo , Peterh , Rambler62 , riccardo99 , RnT , snarf2014 , Stoney1962 , superglen , teleblaster , TW2019
Guests:
2275
Record Number of Users:
206
on June 1, 2022 23:50
Record Number of Guests:
9627
on January 2, 2024 23:10