For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
GravityBoyQuote
kleermaker
Best Knocking (thus far):
This one is good quality.
Keith gives MT a nice kiss at the end.
He needed that, because this was far, far from the brilliance he came up with on the last rendition...
Taylor is very daring, and moves way out of his comfort zone - albeit without succeeding, imo.
Quote
sanQQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
GravityBoyQuote
kleermaker
Best Knocking (thus far):
This one is good quality.
Keith gives MT a nice kiss at the end.
He needed that, because this was far, far from the brilliance he came up with on the last rendition...
Taylor is very daring, and moves way out of his comfort zone - albeit without succeeding, imo.
Huh??? He succeeded greatly here. Playing outside the comfort zone is the best way and the way the most talented players play. If you want to hear the record, play it. I don't understand the logic in that comment.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
sanQQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
GravityBoyQuote
kleermaker
Best Knocking (thus far):
This one is good quality.
Keith gives MT a nice kiss at the end.
He needed that, because this was far, far from the brilliance he came up with on the last rendition...
Taylor is very daring, and moves way out of his comfort zone - albeit without succeeding, imo.
Huh??? He succeeded greatly here. Playing outside the comfort zone is the best way and the way the most talented players play. If you want to hear the record, play it. I don't understand the logic in that comment.
True, but he didn't succeed. Sometimes you move far astray...
Nothing pleases me more than doing something that's different from the record in a guitar solo, but it has to sound good for me to enjoy it.
The first CYHMK was fantastic. This one was average at best...
Quote
kleermaker
During the first Knocking Taylor caught the band (and us) by surprise, being totally in control, wrong-footing the band, especially Jagger (but except Charlie I guess). The second one showed us a somewhat subdued Taylor, but to me this last solo had some beautiful and lyrical moments. Maybe not so easy and fast to 'catch' as the first one.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
kleermaker
During the first Knocking Taylor caught the band (and us) by surprise, being totally in control, wrong-footing the band, especially Jagger (but except Charlie I guess). The second one showed us a somewhat subdued Taylor, but to me this last solo had some beautiful and lyrical moments. Maybe not so easy and fast to 'catch' as the first one.
Not at all. The band was backing him up, perhaps even better than on the second version. It's the other way around.
However, Taylor's performance was better the first time.
Jagger is Jagger. He'll stick to the maracas from now on
Quote
kleermakerQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
kleermaker
During the first Knocking Taylor caught the band (and us) by surprise, being totally in control, wrong-footing the band, especially Jagger (but except Charlie I guess). The second one showed us a somewhat subdued Taylor, but to me this last solo had some beautiful and lyrical moments. Maybe not so easy and fast to 'catch' as the first one.
Not at all. The band was backing him up, perhaps even better than on the second version. It's the other way around.
However, Taylor's performance was better the first time.
Jagger is Jagger. He'll stick to the maracas from now on
You're right as for the wrong-footing: that concerns only Jagger. Indeed almost no back up during the second one: only Taylor and Charlie. And Mick on maracas of course. I think I like the second version most. A matter of taste I guess.
Quote
sabata
MT's direct Sound
Quote
LorenzQuote
sabata
MT's direct Sound
Man, Taylor really @#$%& that one up. What a crappy way to destroy a primal, simple riff.
Quote
guitard
I have the full show in HD - will author to blu-ray soon.
Quote
guitard
I have the full show in HD - will author to blu-ray soon.
Other than brief battery/SD card changes - I've got the whole show (both 28th and 31st). I'm just waiting on flacvinyl to release his audio so I can sync them with the videos for blu-ray and DVD.Quote
Green Lady
Beautiful video, guitard. Main post updated.
Still missing Doom & Gloom, One More shot and Tumbling Dice. If Mick wants to know which song to leave out, he should note that HARDLY ANYONE EVER SEEMS TO FILM TUMBLING DICE. But as they've invested in that backdrop video for it, I expect we're stuck with it.
Quote
guitardOther than brief battery/SD card changes - I've got the whole show (both 28th and 31st). I'm just waiting on flacvinyl to release his audio so I can sync them with the videos for blu-ray and DVD.Quote
Green Lady
Beautiful video, guitard. Main post updated.
Still missing Doom & Gloom, One More shot and Tumbling Dice. If Mick wants to know which song to leave out, he should note that HARDLY ANYONE EVER SEEMS TO FILM TUMBLING DICE. But as they've invested in that backdrop video for it, I expect we're stuck with it.