For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
I guess the philosophy for some is when the truth hurts then an attack is in order.Quote
Jah PaulQuote
misterfrias
I'm surprised by this Grace Slick pile-on. Her comments regarding "aging rock stars" are far from obnoxious. In fact, I have read several comments by Mick Jagger in various publications from the sixties in which he states that he cannot imagine singing rock & roll after he reaches 30 years of age. A lot of other musicians from that time (i.e., the sixties) shared that same feeling. Anyone recall the line, "Hope I die before I get old"? I guess these aging rock stars get a pass now because they made their comments when they were young (i.e., before they realized that retirement would mean jumping off the gravy train).
That said, I never understood Jefferson Airplane's popularity. Much less the popularity of Jefferson Starship & Starship. A couple of JA songs are decent (WHITE RABBIT, SOMEBODY TO LOVE) but the rest -- ugh!
Anything that remotely offends "our boys" (whether it's real or imagined) always elicits a pile-on from some.
Quote
Jah PaulQuote
misterfrias
I'm surprised by this Grace Slick pile-on. Her comments regarding "aging rock stars" are far from obnoxious. In fact, I have read several comments by Mick Jagger in various publications from the sixties in which he states that he cannot imagine singing rock & roll after he reaches 30 years of age. A lot of other musicians from that time (i.e., the sixties) shared that same feeling. Anyone recall the line, "Hope I die before I get old"? I guess these aging rock stars get a pass now because they made their comments when they were young (i.e., before they realized that retirement would mean jumping off the gravy train).
That said, I never understood Jefferson Airplane's popularity. Much less the popularity of Jefferson Starship & Starship. A couple of JA songs are decent (WHITE RABBIT, SOMEBODY TO LOVE) but the rest -- ugh!
Anything that remotely offends "our boys" (whether it's real or imagined) always elicits a pile-on from some.
Quote
stoneheartedQuote
Jah PaulQuote
misterfrias
I'm surprised by this Grace Slick pile-on. Her comments regarding "aging rock stars" are far from obnoxious. In fact, I have read several comments by Mick Jagger in various publications from the sixties in which he states that he cannot imagine singing rock & roll after he reaches 30 years of age. A lot of other musicians from that time (i.e., the sixties) shared that same feeling. Anyone recall the line, "Hope I die before I get old"? I guess these aging rock stars get a pass now because they made their comments when they were young (i.e., before they realized that retirement would mean jumping off the gravy train).
That said, I never understood Jefferson Airplane's popularity. Much less the popularity of Jefferson Starship & Starship. A couple of JA songs are decent (WHITE RABBIT, SOMEBODY TO LOVE) but the rest -- ugh!
Anything that remotely offends "our boys" (whether it's real or imagined) always elicits a pile-on from some.
As one who might be considered guilty of the "pile-on" toward Grace Slick, I would like to clarify a bit on my comments posted above, which were not intended as negative toward Grace Slick, as I quite admire her work with the Jefferson Airplane/Jefferson Starship/Starship from the 60s through the 80s.
It is Grace herself who has made the most ageist comments toward such aging rockers as The Stones continuing on as they have. It is her ageist attitude that I have been addressing, rather than the fact of her ageing itself.
In other genres of music, female musicians and performers have carried on despite their age. In the folk genre, Mary Travers of Peter, Paul, and Mary continued on through old age as did Etta James in the blues genre, as well as Aretha Franklin in the soul genre, to say nothing of Loretta Lynn in the country genre. But there seems to be this unspoken rule that in rock music one should retire at an early age. Why is that? Is it because the term 'rock n roll' is actually a slang expression for the sex act and thus its music is only suitable to younger people? Why is rock n roll exclusively not allowed for older people, yet every other music genre has no problem with older artists?
The problem is Grace Slick's attitude toward this, not her age. As one of the ultimate rock n roll female voices she should still be out there, but she is apparently too self-conscious and insecure--too obsessive about the physical drawbacks of ageing--to continue on performing with her talents.
Quote
His MajestyQuote
Silver DaggerQuote
His Majesty
I really like her contributions to Marty's song Today from Surrealistic Pillow. Lovely recorder and harmony vocals.
Isn't that the song Pennebaker messed up at Monterey and showed Grace when Marty was singing the lead?
It is.
Beautiful version though, ace use of the rare Baldwin electric harpsichord on that. Grace also played it on Two Heads from After Bathing At Baxters.
Quote
Dan
"it's silly to perform a song that has no relevance to the present or expresses feelings you no longer have"
Seems to me like music means more to her than just a paycheck. I can see why that pisses some people off, at least on this board.
Quote
Jah PaulQuote
stoneheartedQuote
Jah PaulQuote
misterfrias
I'm surprised by this Grace Slick pile-on. Her comments regarding "aging rock stars" are far from obnoxious. In fact, I have read several comments by Mick Jagger in various publications from the sixties in which he states that he cannot imagine singing rock & roll after he reaches 30 years of age. A lot of other musicians from that time (i.e., the sixties) shared that same feeling. Anyone recall the line, "Hope I die before I get old"? I guess these aging rock stars get a pass now because they made their comments when they were young (i.e., before they realized that retirement would mean jumping off the gravy train).
That said, I never understood Jefferson Airplane's popularity. Much less the popularity of Jefferson Starship & Starship. A couple of JA songs are decent (WHITE RABBIT, SOMEBODY TO LOVE) but the rest -- ugh!
Anything that remotely offends "our boys" (whether it's real or imagined) always elicits a pile-on from some.
As one who might be considered guilty of the "pile-on" toward Grace Slick, I would like to clarify a bit on my comments posted above, which were not intended as negative toward Grace Slick, as I quite admire her work with the Jefferson Airplane/Jefferson Starship/Starship from the 60s through the 80s.
It is Grace herself who has made the most ageist comments toward such aging rockers as The Stones continuing on as they have. It is her ageist attitude that I have been addressing, rather than the fact of her ageing itself.
In other genres of music, female musicians and performers have carried on despite their age. In the folk genre, Mary Travers of Peter, Paul, and Mary continued on through old age as did Etta James in the blues genre, as well as Aretha Franklin in the soul genre, to say nothing of Loretta Lynn in the country genre. But there seems to be this unspoken rule that in rock music one should retire at an early age. Why is that? Is it because the term 'rock n roll' is actually a slang expression for the sex act and thus its music is only suitable to younger people? Why is rock n roll exclusively not allowed for older people, yet every other music genre has no problem with older artists?
The problem is Grace Slick's attitude toward this, not her age. As one of the ultimate rock n roll female voices she should still be out there, but she is apparently too self-conscious and insecure--too obsessive about the physical drawbacks of ageing--to continue on performing with her talents.
It's pretty much just her opinion, not some complex sociological statement. With all the old rockers going on well into their 60s and beyond, I think we can safely say the old "rules" you speak of regarding age and rock n roll don't really exist anymore, and Grace's long-standing opinion is really no threat to any band or artist. I first heard her make those comments probably 15 years ago, maybe longer, and I don't recall her singling out anyone by name...except herself!
And that was kind of the point of my comment...she didn't even mention the Stones, yet some folks immediately run to their defense as if it was some horrible personal attack. After all these years and all the jokes about their age, I think the Stones can handle it...and most of their fans can, too.
As for Grace possibly being too self-conscious and insecure to continue, hey, it's her life...she did the rock n roll thing for 25 years and decided to retire - and has stuck to her word. She doesn't owe anyone anything.
Quote
blivet
I read a more recent interview with her someplace where she was asked about a Jefferson Airplane reunion, and she said it's just not possible, that she has health issues which prevent her from being on her feet for more than a few minutes at a time.
Quote
tattersQuote
Dan
"it's silly to perform a song that has no relevance to the present or expresses feelings you no longer have"
Seems to me like music means more to her than just a paycheck. I can see why that pisses some people off, at least on this board.
It would piss me off if I went to see someone like, oh, for instance, James Taylor, and someone called out for "Fire And Rain" and he said, "I'm sorry, but I don't do that one anyone. I'm no longer a junkie, you see, so I can't relate."
Quote
Jah Paul
Found this from a 2007 interview...
antiMUSIC: I know you've said that all rock stars over 50 should retire but do you not feel periods of just wanting to get behind the mike at least and record?
Grace: But there's only two forms, one of them's rap and it's not even old enough to have anyone that's old, and the other is rock and roll. And they are young people's things. Now you can do classical music or rhythm and blues till you're 150, but not rock and roll and rap. It pains me to see old people leaping around trying to act like their 25. It's embarrassing. I just think 'Oh, god, honey. You don't have to get out of the music business: become a producer, write songs. But don't leap around and try to look like you're 35.'
Quote
antiMUSIC: I was just going to ask you about Mick and Keith then.
Grace: Well, Keith, now Keith, he can play forever because he's looked like he was about 150 since he was 25
Quote
and he's rhythm and blues so he can keep going for ever...
Quote
filstan
Grace has always been outspoken. She did front a very good band back in the 60's. I saw the Airplane 3 times and they were always great. All of us are guilty of not being very diplomatic with comments sometimes, but our slip ups don't show up in the press. Not saying I agree with Grace regarding age and playing music, but for me she can say what ever she wants. She was a big star years ago, and was a radical counter culture icon of sorts. If you didn't grow up with that scene, it is hard to
explain. The Airplane were a good band in the studio and on stage, and I am happy to have seen them in their prime. As we age, growing old gracefully(no pun intended)is a project we must all eventually confront and deal with. Some do it better than others.
Quote
Glam Descendant
>Grace needs to stop trying to speak for everyone else
I believe she was expressing her personal opinion.
Quote
stoneheartedQuote
Glam Descendant
>Grace needs to stop trying to speak for everyone else
I believe she was expressing her personal opinion.
If she says she decides to retire at 50 because she felt like a jerk, then she is speaking for herself. When she says that all rock stars over 50 should retire, as the interviewer above reminds her, then she is attempting to speak for everyone else.
Quote
Jah PaulQuote
stoneheartedQuote
Glam Descendant
>Grace needs to stop trying to speak for everyone else
I believe she was expressing her personal opinion.
If she says she decides to retire at 50 because she felt like a jerk, then she is speaking for herself. When she says that all rock stars over 50 should retire, as the interviewer above reminds her, then she is attempting to speak for everyone else.
She's not attempting to speak for anyone but herself.
Quote
R
Man, Grace is a bitter old hag. Do you think, for a moment, that if there were actually a demand for her appearances she wouldn't be on stage in a heartbeat?
Quote
DanQuote
R
Man, Grace is a bitter old hag. Do you think, for a moment, that if there were actually a demand for her appearances she wouldn't be on stage in a heartbeat?
Idiot.
She retired. There was never any drop in demand. Anything with Grace Slick on vocals would do quite well, probably better than painting.
Quote
RQuote
DanQuote
R
Man, Grace is a bitter old hag. Do you think, for a moment, that if there were actually a demand for her appearances she wouldn't be on stage in a heartbeat?
Idiot.
She retired. There was never any drop in demand. Anything with Grace Slick on vocals would do quite well, probably better than painting.
Really? The last time I saw Grace she was in the '80s version of Starship, co-headling with Nightranger in a half full hockey rink. This was about 24-25 years ago which would have made her (surprise) about 50. It was NOT a good look. Not every aging rocker needs to retire - but she sure did. This was in the years before she was answering the cops knock on the door, sh-tfaced drunk, while waving a shotgun around.