For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
firebird
It seems like I am the only one who does not like it. Lisa is a way better singer technically, she has the better voice, a wider range and shows more musicality. She is singing harmonics where Florence Welch is just doubling Micks notes.
Look at this version
This is at least ten times better than what Florence Welch did
Quote
maumau
so as rolling stones fans we should judge music and performances from the standpoint of virtuosism...
Quote
firebirdQuote
maumau
so as rolling stones fans we should judge music and performances from the standpoint of virtuosism...
No, of cause you can judge it from any standpoint you prefer. Im just trying to explain why i personally don't like the version with florence Welch
Never seen this one before,F%$#$%# unbelievable! Bring back Lisa 98'ST.Louis is a really good one too. I think Lisa will be taking the lead anyways in Brooklyn it's her hometown.Quote
maumauQuote
firebird
It seems like I am the only one who does not like it. Lisa is a way better singer technically, she has the better voice, a wider range and shows more musicality. She is singing harmonics where Florence Welch is just doubling Micks notes.
Look at this version
This is at least ten times better than what Florence Welch did
so as rolling stones fans we should judge music and performances from the standpoint of virtuosism...
Sure that's why Keith is totally blown away after hearing it through the monitors like at his grin at the end of it.Quote
Fullerblindboy69
While she does deliver alot of emotion, she is singing flat on many of the notes. And the Stones themselves look and sound uninspired, there is no real musical tension in a song that demands it.
Quote
stonesfrkkSure that's why Keith is totally blown away after hearing it through the monitors like at his grin at the end of it.Quote
Fullerblindboy69
While she does deliver alot of emotion, she is singing flat on many of the notes. And the Stones themselves look and sound uninspired, there is no real musical tension in a song that demands it.
Quote
maumauQuote
firebird
It seems like I am the only one who does not like it. Lisa is a way better singer technically, she has the better voice, a wider range and shows more musicality. She is singing harmonics where Florence Welch is just doubling Micks notes.
Look at this version
This is at least ten times better than what Florence Welch did
so as rolling stones fans we should judge music and performances from the standpoint of virtuosism...
Quote
Silver Dagger
The song is about danger and threat and she brought that element out better than anyone since Merry Clayton. Florence was dangerous live, she took the game to Mick and you can tell he wasn't sure how far she was going to go with it.
This was true art, unfolding under our very eyes. It wasn't about slick, Vegas-style showbiz with every move choreographed to boring perfection. Rock'n'roll at its finest.
And to round off an incredible performance she humbled herself at the end by graciously kissing all 4 Stones and in doing so endeared herself to thousands of Stones fan. God bless her for that.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Silver Dagger
The song is about danger and threat and she brought that element out better than anyone since Merry Clayton. Florence was dangerous live, she took the game to Mick and you can tell he wasn't sure how far she was going to go with it.
This was true art, unfolding under our very eyes. It wasn't about slick, Vegas-style showbiz with every move choreographed to boring perfection. Rock'n'roll at its finest.
And to round off an incredible performance she humbled herself at the end by graciously kissing all 4 Stones and in doing so endeared herself to thousands of Stones fan. God bless her for that.
You got it, mate