For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
keefriffhard4life
which boxset is better? the 1990 boxset or the one from a few years ago called THERE IS A SEASON?
Quote
Edith GroveQuote
RSbestbandever
a hidden gem called Truck Stop Girl.
Written by Lowell George and Bill Payne:
Quote
Woody24
Their cover of Dylan's "My Back Pages," is an absolute classic from that era.
Quote
Silver Dagger
This song rocks. Great guitars too.
Quote
2000man
Quote
tipps
Where is the original lead singer now cant recall his name?
Quote
keefriffhard4life
which boxset is better? the 1990 boxset or the one from a few years ago called THERE IS A SEASON?
Quote
Rev. Robert W.
Honestly, I cannot think of a box that has ever done a better or more thoughtful job of presenting a band's history.
Quote
Rev. Robert W.Quote
keefriffhard4life
which boxset is better? the 1990 boxset or the one from a few years ago called THERE IS A SEASON?
The 1990 box was a mind-bender. At four CDs, it anthologized the released material perfectly. Add to that a bounty of excellent, truly memorable unreleased stuff--including the long-discussed, but not even (to my knowledge) bootlegged Gram Parsons Sweetheart vocals and outtakes. Oh yeah, a then-recent performance with Dylan of "Mr. Tambourine Man" and four fine-to-excellent new recordings from McGuinn, Hillman and Crosby.
Honestly, I cannot think of a box that has ever done a better or more thoughtful job of presenting a band's history. They certainly deserved it--arguably the most underrated band in the annals of rock'n'roll.
Of course, instead of remastering The Byrds, Columbia/Legacy decided to milk the fans by cooking up There Is A Season. Better sound...perhaps. But without the 1990 recordings and a bunch of the rarities on the 1990 set, it's actually more worthwhile to seek out the excellent expanded and annotated remasters of the original albums--at least up through 1970's (Untitled). Top notch all the way, really.
Expanded, remastered and lovingly presented...hmmm...trying to think of another catalogue I'd like to see handled along these lines.
PS: The two-disc Sweetheart was a massive letdown for me. Lots more alternates, but nothing of any importance that couldn't be found on the single disc remaster. Also padded out with some, but not all, of Gram's earlier (superb) International Submarine Band recordings. No Grand Ole Opry performances, no Gram-period live material at all, which is a shame, as they got into some wonderfully strange stuff spanning the "old" hits and the newer lineup--"Eight Miles High" with a banjo, and so on...