For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
stonehearted
During the show I saw this year (Boston 2), there was a moment where I thought of the Chuck-haters (or, at the very least, detractors) here on the forum.
Chuck was doing a piano solo during one of the rocking numbers, and I was watching him play it on one of the big monitors above the stage. At the end of the solo, he lifted his right leg and dropped the bottom of his shoe on the high end of the keyboard for the final note, displaying that trademark grin as he did so.
I thought, 'Oh, there are some people on IORR who would just be completely beside themselves if they saw that.'
If you'll pardon the pun, the thought did give me a bit of a chuckle.
Quote
24FPS
And quit turning darkly dramatic songs like Midnight Rambler into plinkety-plink upbeat numbers. He doesn't stand out in a good way. I don't find myself seeking out his piano when I'm listening to the group. But when he's totally inappropriate it really sticks out. Maybe his playing with the group changed over time to where he thinks his playing is more important that it really is. It's kind of sad that they've aged so much that they have to depend on someone like Chuck to get by.
Quote
Chris FountainQuote
stonehearted
During the show I saw this year (Boston 2), there was a moment where I thought of the Chuck-haters (or, at the very least, detractors) here on the forum.
Chuck was doing a piano solo during one of the rocking numbers, and I was watching him play it on one of the big monitors above the stage. At the end of the solo, he lifted his right leg and dropped the bottom of his shoe on the high end of the keyboard for the final note, displaying that trademark grin as he did so.
I thought, 'Oh, there are some people on IORR who would just be completely beside themselves if they saw that.'
If you'll pardon the pun, the thought did give me a bit of a chuckle.
I was at the same concert - Good thing I was on Keith's side.
BTW - Stonehearted as you know that concert was officially recorded (Cameras were present). I wonder if anything will materialize of the footage.
Quote
BeastQuote
24FPS
And quit turning darkly dramatic songs like Midnight Rambler into plinkety-plink upbeat numbers. He doesn't stand out in a good way. I don't find myself seeking out his piano when I'm listening to the group. But when he's totally inappropriate it really sticks out. Maybe his playing with the group changed over time to where he thinks his playing is more important that it really is. It's kind of sad that they've aged so much that they have to depend on someone like Chuck to get by.
+1
He does that every time he plays Honky Tonk Women. Tired.Quote
stonehearted
During the show I saw this year (Boston 2), there was a moment where I thought of the Chuck-haters (or, at the very least, detractors) here on the forum.
Chuck was doing a piano solo during one of the rocking numbers, and I was watching him play it on one of the big monitors above the stage. At the end of the solo, he lifted his right leg and dropped the bottom of his shoe on the high end of the keyboard for the final note, displaying that trademark grin as he did so.
I thought, 'Oh, there are some people on IORR who would just be completely beside themselves if they saw that.'
If you'll pardon the pun, the thought did give me a bit of a chuckle.
Quote
KeithNacho
Maybe people think that he is responsible of the lack of attitude and wildnesss in RS music during last decades. He has turned sloppy R&R group in a smart music comercial machine. Where is the guitar driven sound that ruled RS music since 1968 to 1982????
He does count off the tempo to every song. I noticed on "Sweet Summer Sun" that everything seems slow. This from the band that used to play every song like it was a race to the finish. More on "Sweet Summer" later. I want to watch it again before I write a review to be fair. The initial viewing left me seriously underwhelmed for the most part. Not all of my issues are with the Stones. I enjoyed Glastonbury on YouTube much more. & I think Chuck seems like a cool guy. Just wrong for this band. Maybe if they lowered him in the mix it would help.Quote
milio77
I understand that point but seriously... ¿Do we really think that happened against the band's will?
On the other hand, I have no problems with their actual sound. After all, I don't think the "Vegas era" (as many call these last two decades) diverts than much from the golden years. Background singers? Lot of keyboards? Horn section? That's what you find in "Exile on Main St." also.
But to each his own. Everyone's free not to like Chuck and express so of course. But him being musical director and all, I don't think he's got the last word about the course the band takes. Or at least I don't picture him overtaking Mick and/or Keith.
Quote
crholmstrom
He does count off the tempo to every song. I noticed on "Sweet Summer Sun" that everything seems slow. This from the band that used to play every song like it was a race to the finish.
Quote
KeithNacho
Maybe people think that he is responsible of the lack of attitude and wildnesss in RS music during last decades. He has turned sloppy R&R group in a smart music comercial machine. Where is the guitar driven sound that ruled RS music since 1968 to 1982????
Quote
His Majesty
He does that at Hyde Park as well, at least I'm sure I saw it in the film from those two concerts.
Quote
DandelionPowderman
it was Keith finishing his piano solo