For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Cristiano RadtkeQuote
IrixQuote
mitch
"Funny" detail: the tape indicates this track has been recorded the 5/10/74, more than one year and half after the Goats Head Soup release... even after the It's Only Rock'n Roll sessions!
[Twitter.com] · [www.Facebook.com] · [www.Instagram.com]
The runtime of the 2020 released 'Scarlet' is 3m:44s - [Music.Apple.com] .
"Subject: Cockroaches"
Quote
jbwelda
So what the heck do we really have here?
Quote
Rockman
Scarlet .... hang with it
It slowly creeps up and gets ya ....
Quote
IrixQuote
Hairball
Is it a mistake listing?
Looks like, since [Music.Apple.com] doesn't mention Jimmy Page (and Amazon didn't for Track 11,12 before Scarlet). Also, the whole Track-order is currently mixed up on [www.Amazon.com] .
Quote
NICOSQuote
IrixQuote
Hairball
Is it a mistake listing?
Looks like, since [Music.Apple.com] doesn't mention Jimmy Page (and Amazon didn't for Track 11,12 before Scarlet). Also, the whole Track-order is currently mixed up on [www.Amazon.com] .
Here Jimmy Page is mentioned..
[music.apple.com]
Quote
maumauQuote
Rockman
Scarlet .... hang with it
It slowly creeps up and gets ya ....
it does actually, with a little help from my grappa
Quote
TravelinMan
I feel like some of his inflections on the first verse sound modern. He doesn’t sound at all like the Exile reissue though, and I don’t think that has to do with technology.
Respectfully disagree.Criss Cross doesn’t go anywhere? I It grooves along like a ride .Its not meant to stop for a guitar solo or chorus.It just has a great groove with great guitar from KeithQuote
Four Stone Walls
Anyway, the lyrics are good. The chord progression in the chorus is superb and unexpected which is why it is a far better Sonny than Cross Cross Man which has a great sound and pace but never goes anywhere.Scalet has a college story too, presumably sketched out by Keith.
Especially good is the rift infectiously lively. Far better than anything on IORR which are all so full and monolithic and frankly limited in conception. Here Keith knows he's gotta goodun.
And it's infact into Black and Blue. The missing link. It leads into Not Stuff (slower), Hey Metrics, there's essentially the same motif in the lead riff in Crazy Mama. Perhaps in Slave too.
Sure the One you Need was Keith's only attempt at a rocker since IORR .... and then this. Vive la difference.
Dancing with Mr D was his last great riff before this.
It belongs far more to Black and Blue period than GHS, with Ronnie's basement the probable incubation place.
I suppose it's possible Jagger did some vocals on it AFTER October at beginning of December '74 session ( when they tried Cherry On Baby? - not sure).
Quote
georgelicks
The vocals are from 2020, I don't know how some people don't hear it, Mick didn't sing like that in 1974.
Keith vocals are from 1974, most of Mick's new vocals are very well double tracked with Keith, it works great and that's why some people can be confused.
Quote
georgelicks
The vocals are from 2020, I don't know how some people don't hear it, Mick didn't sing like that in 1974.
Keith vocals are from 1974, most of Mick's new vocals are very well double tracked with Keith, it works great and that's why some people can be confused.
Quote
MaindefenderQuote
georgelicks
The vocals are from 2020, I don't know how some people don't hear it, Mick didn't sing like that in 1974.
Keith vocals are from 1974, most of Mick's new vocals are very well double tracked with Keith, it works great and that's why some people can be confused.
So it is Keith’s vocals, that’s great thanks.
Quote
georgelicks
The vocals are from 2020, I don't know how some people don't hear it, Mick didn't sing like that in 1974.
Keith vocals are from 1974, most of Mick's new vocals are very well double tracked with Keith, it works great and that's why some people can be confused.