Re: JJ Flash Live? w/ Brian
Date: May 18, 2006 02:13
neptune Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Mathijs Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > The back-up you hear is Keith and Jimmy Miller,
> > all guitars are by Keith.
>
> Here you go again denying Brian credit for playing
> on another track. How do you know Brian did not
> play on it? From the sources I've read, Brian
> does play on the studio version of JJF, most
> probably those lead high-note licks during the
> chorus. It's interesting those lead chorus riffs
> are never played during any live version of JJF
> over the past 30 years. If Keith had played those
> lead lines, one would think he would play them
> live. Anyway, you seem to derive pleasure from
> discrediting Brian at every turn. Hey, maybe that
> wasn't Brian playing the slide in Little Red
> Rooster . . .
You did not understand what I have said. The "live" audio you hear on this video was recorded the day before the video was shot, and according to various sources -Bill Wyman, Jimmy Miller - Brian did not attend the taping of the new audio version. Further to that, I don't HEAR Brian playing -all guitars I personally hear on THIS version are by Keith, not Brian.
On the official studio version, you clearly hear Brian -he's playing the sitar-like descending phrases.
I am not against Brian -his contributions until 1967 can be mind bogling. But ever since early 1968, his contributions are virtually zero. He just didn't play anything interesting anymore, except for the slide on No Expectations. He just wasn't part of the Stones anymore since very early 1968.
Mathijs