For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
ironbelly
Actually, 1CD version of Honk (that one was available in the USA) has a lot of edits.
03. Miss You (Single Version) [0:03:34.41]
06. Fool To Cry (Short Edit) [0:04:06.47]
08. Beast Of Burden (Short Edit) [0:03:27.72]
09. It's Only Rock'n'Roll (But I Like It) (Short Edit) [0:04:10.54]
12. Mixed Emotions (7" Version) [0:04:00.44]
13. Don't Stop (Single Edit) [0:03:29.16]
16. Rain Fall Down (Radio Edit) [0:04:01.23]
18. Emotional Rescue (Short Edit) [0:03:42.38]
19. Saint Of Me (Radio Edit) [0:04:08.61]
Quote
LeonidP
Almost certain that Rewind had edits (but not 100%)
Quote
rocker1
Thanks for sharing this. The shortened Beast of Burden edit is an abomination. However, one edit that actually enhances a song is the edit on live version (from Detroit ‘78) of When the Whip Comes Down on Sucking in the Seventies. It just slices an unfocused part towards the end, if you compare it to the original from Detroit. I’ve always loved that track on SITS.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
LeonidP
Almost certain that Rewind had edits (but not 100%)
I thought so, too. ER?
Nothing looks edited on Atlantic-RSR Rewind (1971-1984) [7 90176-2]Quote
wiredallnightQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
LeonidP
Almost certain that Rewind had edits (but not 100%)
I thought so, too. ER?
No. I have the CDCBS 450199 2 and all songs have the original album lengths. ER is 5.37.
Quote
ironbellyNothing looks edited on Atlantic-RSR Rewind (1971-1984) [7 90176-2]Quote
wiredallnightQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
LeonidP
Almost certain that Rewind had edits (but not 100%)
I thought so, too. ER?
No. I have the CDCBS 450199 2 and all songs have the original album lengths. ER is 5.37.
4:49 01-Miss You
3:51 02-Brown Sugar
4:34 03-Undercover of the Night
3:35 04-Start Me Up
3:40 05-Tumbling Dice
2:23 06-Hang Fire
5:10 07-It's Only Rock N' Roll (But I Like It)
5:40 08-Emotional Rescue
4:27 09-Beast of Burden
5:06 10-Fool To Cry
4:38 11-Waiting on a Friend
4:34 12-Angie
3:25 13-Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)
Quote
ironbelly
According to Rarities Done Right by B. D. Eikenberry (version January, 2023)
Rewind (1971-1984)
1984 UK and Malaysian compilation cassette
• Emotional Rescue [Rewind edit] (3:37) Another unique edit of Emotional Rescue that may possibly be found on other editions of Rewind.
Emotional Rescue
1980 7” promotional single RS-20001, short backed with long (LP) version
• Emotional Rescue [Short Version] (4:11)
Nothing to do with Rewind LP or CD.
Quote
HalfNanker
how about the Some Girls' 8 track tracks. they are not all the same either!
Quote
ironbelly
I can add another rare (or weird) compilation with an edit.
Credits to rogerriffin for detailed information about that CD.
16 Éxitos De Oro
CDEPR 810 109-2
CD issued in 1990
Matrix: 810109-2 01@
MADE IN USA BY PDO
Mexico only
[www.discogs.com]
14. Simpatia Por El Diablo (Sympathy For The Devil) (Edit) 4:33 Track faded in mastering after after the last verse. It is not that infamous edit that was used on 1973 Dutch single [Decca 6103 066]
Quote
rocker1
Thanks for sharing this. The shortened Beast of Burden edit is an abomination. However, one edit that actually enhances a song is the edit on live version (from Detroit ‘78) of When the Whip Comes Down on Sucking in the Seventies. It just slices an unfocused part towards the end, if you compare it to the original from Detroit. I’ve always loved that track on SITS.
Quote
Quique-stone
Thanks for all the usefull infos!
As we say in England, it can get a bit trainspottery (c) Mick Jagger.Quote
24FPS
My god, who has the time to research such minutiae? What does it mean in the end?