For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
sotob
Was hoping to buy this from Amazon Prime Video, but I don't see it listed as an option.
Quote
dedospegajososQuote
hockenheim95Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
hockenheim95Quote
dedospegajososQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
hockenheim95Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
hockenheim95Quote
Muddyw
Now let's hope it is mixed decent, like the Mocambo Live, and it won't sound anything like Live Licks or Four Flicks. There is something off on those.
I am 99% Sure it'll be the same mix as the BBC Broadcast from 2022. Guitars upfront!
Judge yourself:
[m.youtube.com]
I hope you're right, although many other releases shown on tv got a (often inferior) remix later. A couple of tracks were also included on Live Licks, so it will be interesting doing a comparison later.
First half of SCB is Keith re-learning the song. The last half is fantastic, with an unbelievable energy
But the Wiltern show from BBC is already a new mix from 2022. You're refering to Live Broadcasts (PPV) like Newark, Bremen, Licks NYC which were priginally a live mix. They remixed them for the releases.
That is indeed a good point, although it begs the question: Why did they show parts of it on the BBC and didn't release it last year? A teaser?
Anyways, I'm looking forward to hearing what Ronnie really played on CYHMK prior to his solo (haven't watched the BBC broadcast, if it's there).
CYHMK from live licks is not overdubbed.
Just as Rocks Off wasn't edited? Then how can we hear Keith 2 times on the Intro?
Edited and overdubbed are completely different.
Where did I say that they're the same? They just did both things very obvious
on Live Licks.
Thats not true¨, its just Keith, then Ronnie joins, where did this idea came from I never understood, its obviously Ronnie on standard tuning, you will see in March
Quote
StonedRambler
I actually think the mix is quite good this time compared to other releases. Not perfect but good.
The guitars are a bit loud but maybe they just listened to all the folks here always complaining that the guitars are too quiet.
I like it but gotta admit it brings out the sloppiness in the guitar section. Especially Keith is noodling around a lot.
I don't think I've ever heard them do it poorly. Personally, my favorite is Rock And Roll Circus, but any version is excellent.Quote
Wuudy
What a beautiful song is No Expectations. This rendition doen't beat the Stripped one in my opinion but Jaggers voice is stunning on this one!
Quote
RobertJohnsonQuote
Muddyw
Well, with the exception of Mocambo there is no hope on a decent, well mixed and produced live album release.
Compared to the quality of the sound mix on the third side of LYL, the complete release is also an outright downgrade.
Quote
rogerriffin
Spotify shows 2022 as release date!
Quote
RollingFreak
Very good recording. Any Stones release is better than nothing. Sound is good, playing is good, and its a cool club show with an interesting setlist. About all you can ask for.
Having said that, and I'm sure its a broken record excuse, but it just comes so late for it to matter. I'm glad the Stones started opening their vaults in 2011, we've gotten a lot of great shows from it. It REALLY sucks it happened so late, cause most of these are nothing more than a footnote to most of us. I guess there are a bunch of you that will listen to it religiously, but I think most of us, like I just did, will listen to it once and thats about it. I can't see why I'd ever revisit this. Its fine, but its not them in their prime. Its not even something I really haven't heard before. The Olympia show from the Four Flicks box set will mean more because I've listened to it for over 20 years. Thats just how it is. Same with Bruce Springsteen's live archives. Its nice, and it'll be great for future generations, maybe, cause they will have that readily available to listen to. But most of these late releases won't overshadowed stuff we've heard for decades, and there was a medium to release this stuff back then. Sure, hindsight is 20/20, but to me if I'm being completely honest, its a nice Stones show from 20 years ago that was fun to hear once and now I'll never put it on again.
Maybe I'm alone in my thoughts, and I don't mean to be a downer if this isn't the right place for that. Don't want to rain on the parade of a release people are happy with.
Quote
dedospegajososQuote
dedospegajososQuote
hockenheim95Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
hockenheim95Quote
dedospegajososQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
hockenheim95Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
hockenheim95Quote
Muddyw
Now let's hope it is mixed decent, like the Mocambo Live, and it won't sound anything like Live Licks or Four Flicks. There is something off on those.
I am 99% Sure it'll be the same mix as the BBC Broadcast from 2022. Guitars upfront!
Judge yourself:
[m.youtube.com]
I hope you're right, although many other releases shown on tv got a (often inferior) remix later. A couple of tracks were also included on Live Licks, so it will be interesting doing a comparison later.
First half of SCB is Keith re-learning the song. The last half is fantastic, with an unbelievable energy
But the Wiltern show from BBC is already a new mix from 2022. You're refering to Live Broadcasts (PPV) like Newark, Bremen, Licks NYC which were priginally a live mix. They remixed them for the releases.
That is indeed a good point, although it begs the question: Why did they show parts of it on the BBC and didn't release it last year? A teaser?
Anyways, I'm looking forward to hearing what Ronnie really played on CYHMK prior to his solo (haven't watched the BBC broadcast, if it's there).
CYHMK from live licks is not overdubbed.
Just as Rocks Off wasn't edited? Then how can we hear Keith 2 times on the Intro?
Edited and overdubbed are completely different.
Where did I say that they're the same? They just did both things very obvious
on Live Licks.
Thats not true¨, its just Keith, then Ronnie joins, where did this idea came from I never understood, its obviously Ronnie on standard tuning, you will see in March
So, how about that Ronnie guitar on CYHMK?? Hi Hockenheim95!
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
dedospegajososQuote
dedospegajososQuote
hockenheim95Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
hockenheim95Quote
dedospegajososQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
hockenheim95Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
hockenheim95Quote
Muddyw
Now let's hope it is mixed decent, like the Mocambo Live, and it won't sound anything like Live Licks or Four Flicks. There is something off on those.
I am 99% Sure it'll be the same mix as the BBC Broadcast from 2022. Guitars upfront!
Judge yourself:
[m.youtube.com]
I hope you're right, although many other releases shown on tv got a (often inferior) remix later. A couple of tracks were also included on Live Licks, so it will be interesting doing a comparison later.
First half of SCB is Keith re-learning the song. The last half is fantastic, with an unbelievable energy
But the Wiltern show from BBC is already a new mix from 2022. You're refering to Live Broadcasts (PPV) like Newark, Bremen, Licks NYC which were priginally a live mix. They remixed them for the releases.
That is indeed a good point, although it begs the question: Why did they show parts of it on the BBC and didn't release it last year? A teaser?
Anyways, I'm looking forward to hearing what Ronnie really played on CYHMK prior to his solo (haven't watched the BBC broadcast, if it's there).
CYHMK from live licks is not overdubbed.
Just as Rocks Off wasn't edited? Then how can we hear Keith 2 times on the Intro?
Edited and overdubbed are completely different.
Where did I say that they're the same? They just did both things very obvious
on Live Licks.
Thats not true¨, its just Keith, then Ronnie joins, where did this idea came from I never understood, its obviously Ronnie on standard tuning, you will see in March
So, how about that Ronnie guitar on CYHMK?? Hi Hockenheim95!
It was nice to hear what he really played. Two string-shapes instead of heavy open G-chords, like on Live Licks.