For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
S.T.PQuote
dcba
Not really, cassette copies of the multitracks have been circulating since 1975... and unlike the recent flood of new studio material they're not mp3-sourced.
Are you refering to the few tracks with overdubs that exist on boots like "Keep Your Motor Running" or something else?
Quote
24FPS
Just give us a great 'Rocks Off' live from '72.
Quote
TravelinManQuote
S.T.PQuote
dcba
Not really, cassette copies of the multitracks have been circulating since 1975... and unlike the recent flood of new studio material they're not mp3-sourced.
Are you refering to the few tracks with overdubs that exist on boots like "Keep Your Motor Running" or something else?
Yeah, I believe so.
[www.rollingstonesnet.com]
Quote
yearsinthemaking
The overdubs on the "Keep Your Motor Running" boot are terrible. They are so obvious and poorly done. I can't imagine those were anything other than raw early efforts that were not seriously considered for release. The overdubs on GYYYO and LYL are more polished but are still often awful (Happy and Keith adding backing for Tumbling Dice!!!)
Quote
Eleanor RigbyQuote
yearsinthemaking
The overdubs on the "Keep Your Motor Running" boot are terrible. They are so obvious and poorly done. I can't imagine those were anything other than raw early efforts that were not seriously considered for release. The overdubs on GYYYO and LYL are more polished but are still often awful (Happy and Keith adding backing for Tumbling Dice!!!)
The overdubs on Ya Ya's are not awful at all...in any way. It has only been for a few particular audio nutters to pick apart the overdubs for anyone to notice.
99.9% of listeners wouldnt even know there were overdubs...well done I say.
Agree with the Keep The Motor Running...these are noticeable and terrible!
Note also - many overdubs on L&G Video/dvd releaee!!!
Its just a farce...
Quote
yearsinthemaking
I think the overdubs in L&G are limited to Happy. There may be others. As far as GYYYO I think the main issue is that they are just unnecessary. It's a live show. Why fake it? They are tasteful as opposed to many of them on LYL
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
yearsinthemaking
I think the overdubs in L&G are limited to Happy. There may be others. As far as GYYYO I think the main issue is that they are just unnecessary. It's a live show. Why fake it? They are tasteful as opposed to many of them on LYL
What do you think is overdubbed on Happy?
Quote
yearsinthemaking
Keith's singing seems to be at a level that he never reached on any of the other versions of Happy during the '72 tour. For example the outtake version from one of the other Texas shows is much more similar to all of the other versions vocally. It's not as obvious to me as Happy on LYL. I'm not certain that it is a vocal overdub but it's just sonically so much better than any other STP show from a vocal standpoint
Quote
jbwelda
>Carol and Little Queenie. And it’s not even noticeable on these two weakest tracks on the album
They are, in my opinion, by a long shot, the BEST songs on the album.
Quote
S.T.P
I like overdubs if they use it to fix something that went wrong, but when they start reorganize a song with backup vocals like on SFM in '69 and TD or ADTL one Keep Your Motor Running, I'm out!
Quote
Taylor1
... those boring Chuck Berry boogies...