Sacrilege - it's as if they ripped the heart and soul out of it and turned it into a messy turd.

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......

[www.youtube.com]


sacrilige?
its like a crucifixation?
hmmm, this could be interesting.

sacrilege
noun
the misuse or desecration of anything regarded as sacred or as worthy of extreme respect:

to play Mozart's music on a kazoo is sacrilege

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......

Problem is: I know Tyler can sing a lot better than this, but it’s almost as Jim Carrey’s version of I Am The Walrus. And the band sounds like a regular bar band. I thought the solo was pretty good though.

JumpingKentFlash

Oh dear .... harsh pushed bar-band r.r.r..r..rock …



ROCKMAN

Awful. Wow.

oh jeez... so this how it sounds like if a Rolling Stones song is done by a 'proper' rock and roll singer... some bloody generic screamings and no any idea of expression or distinctivity in voice or, to not forget the most important thing, sex - in doing the actual verses and chorus... having judged a bit too many 'talent' shows or what?

A great reminder by Tyler and whatever the band is how authentic and unique Jagger & co are. Not that idea is to copy the Stones (I hope not). But they just make a great song to sound so damn lame. Adding nothing, taking anything great out of it.

Never would waste another three minutes or so again with that muzak.

- Doxa



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2018-08-31 01:15 by Doxa.

I got a minute in and had to stop.


"As we say in England, it can get a bit trainspottery"



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2018-08-31 01:37 by Deltics.

to not forget the most important thing, sex

Yeah that's what is always there in a Stones song …………



ROCKMAN

Quote
Hairball
sacrilege
noun
the misuse or desecration of anything regarded as sacred or as worthy of extreme respect:

to play Mozart's music on a kazoo is sacrilege

well good enough for me; i haven't been inspired to take that 2nd trip yet, frankly.




wait a second,,,
no i gotta go back to not reading you...
i consder that a challenge. man, some people can fart mozart, and dude,
maybe that video will bring some moron the help he needs?
did you ever even freakin think of that??
I"m betting 'no,' son.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2018-08-31 01:26 by hopkins.

Quote
Rockman
to not forget the most important thing, sex

Yeah that's what is always there in a Stones song …………

some are about drugs rocky, pay attention.

…… I aint payin nobody … they all owe me ……



ROCKMAN

whoa.
first schllid.
then you.

whoa,..
take it easy kids ok?

geezuzz

Quote
hopkins
some people can fart mozart...

Lol...and it would probably sound better than Tyler's Brown Sugar cover.

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......

Saw this tune with Steven and Nuno today. I dig it. It's not The Stones, but doesn't try to be. On the other hand I'd "bust-a-nut" for Tyler most every time.

Quote
Hairball

Quote
hopkins
some people can fart mozart...

Lol...and it would probably sound better than Tyler's Brown Sugar cover.

ok that vocal does suck.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2018-09-01 00:11 by hopkins.

Quote
hopkins

Quote
Hairball

Quote
hopkins
some people can fart mozart...

Lol...and it would probably sound better than Tyler's Brown Sugar cover.

ok that vocal does suck.
for once you have me.
this one time.
ok.
i didn'tlisten again and i'm the firsat guy who posted it;
and guess what?
i wish i didn't.
i hope you're happy now.
i'm a better man for telling the truth Hairball.
and i'm STILL gonna have to see every fricken song that's ever
been thought of being recored ever in the history of pop music and the world...
and a particular page here;
posteed:
by 'someone'
but i'm not the kind of guy to throw shade when i'm fessin up hairball.
not me man.
so i am not mentioning any names

You can always edit your original post and delete link so we can pretend it never happened?
I think that would make almost everyone happy!

Cheers hopkins -

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......

terrible awful shitty version of Brown Sugar.....as for the political nature of Joe Perry..he lives here in the conservative bastion of SW Florida known as Sarasota.

But I know what I (don'T) like....

Disappointing.
Surprisingly for both Tyler and the band.

Seems like this version should have been titled "take one".

As suspected I don't like it nearly as much as the original, but I don't hate it either. It's not bad for what it is, though I don't see myself playing it often.

Tyler is the weak link here, imo. Rhythm, timing, soul, punch and danger - it's all peeled off. It's unsexy. It's rubbish. Disappointing...

It was interesting that they stayed so close to the original, sound-wise, regarding the circumstances (Bettencourt usually plays different styles). For the band, that worked for a while, imo. Then, all of a sudden, they skipped a chorus after the guitar solo, turned the beat down 50 percent and made the whole damn thing halt and stumble - right when they (imo) should have put that thing in 5th gear!

It's good fun, hearing cover versions of your favourite songs - but the task of re-creating the magic or creating something new and worthwhile might have been too big for these guys.

This left me puzzled, just like Aerosmith's horrendous version of You Gotta Move did (there are other good songs on Bobo, though).

Basically I agree with most of the criticisms I've read. But also I think some of us are missing the point that it's a cover song done as a tribute to legacy type music. It's never going to compete with our cherished favorites and if you look at it this way maybe you can can avoid disappoinment. This is my perspective on the subject. Maybe not popular though.

a very, véry 'impotent' version -
the song, its writers, ànd the performers here as well (including Steven Tyler) completely unworthy.

Band (seperate instruments) & vocals seem miles away from each oher...
Why didn't they simply gather together in the studio, and do a couple of 'live' recordings??
I mean: it's a tribute to the studio, nót its mixing console, after all...?!?

Well, now that I've finally gotten around to listening to this, I realize this is one of those cover versions you'll sit through once and never spin again. It's, IMHO, the kind of version that'd be played at a bar in Vegas to get the crowd pumped up. As the saying goes, "Nice try, but no cigar."

i'm sorry and WILL Hairball.
i am sorty to refernce my OWN old nonsense.

i think it was inappropiate and insenzsitive.

you're one of the most informed and articulate,
and the diverse tastes
and styles in your canon of reference,
just REALLY show my own lack of creative open-ness to enjoy
the ones i am famliar with, and get into the ones i am only vaguely,
if at all, familiar with.

i think i broke my own trust and agreement with myself by subtly slamming
your posting name,
or not so subtly.
it wasn't funny and it was casually insensitve
and i'm ashamed of myself.
whoa, i just came across this and apprecaite
you and would appreciate forgivenss.
i am genuinely sorry and do not
repsect the way i behaved,
or actually really feel that way about you at all.
please forgive me...



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2018-09-01 00:17 by hopkins.

Easy, hopkins. You don't deserve the self-flagellation unless you enjoy that sort of thing.

Besides, as your namesake wrote on the back of JAMMING WITH EDWARD, "No wonder they keep me down in the @#$%& basement."

thanks no i don't ; i just have been in rough times.
and maybe am projecting too much, but i'm pretty much more senstive
than I'd like to admit in certain circumstances, and a kind, or nasty
little word can really mean a lot for me....lol no i'm not too much of a sop,
and regardless of any opinions on any thread...for all kinds of reasons
i really need to bust myself; i don't mope about it lol, he's smart enough
to take a crack; i don't ride it like the surf ; but you helped me rite here
to lighten up; you had mah back budd. when it comes to the final armageddon i've been reading about i want to run with the rockers, even if they dig Chubby Checker i mean whatever, he'd sign up with the rockers...
hell, i'm runnin' with the rockers right now...
an day long since the break of day. i see a texas license plate
and I'm playing the same two chords over and over as fast as i can...
it's called 'buddy holly' its totally nuts, i dig it...
btw i'm goin there now to post Mashed Potatoe Time by Dee Dee Sharp with Chubbby Checker; i better not see a bunch of ...... hairball come home.
i've been a bad hopkins; rocky wants me out of the corner dude...
come on....what have youi been listening to....
come on dude, i deserve it....what?

seriously Rocky, as a matter of personal principle despite anything else.
i never want to contribute to having someone less than free about expressing;
especially here where i know a lot of us have had their feelings hurt or got hot over something; i am so mostly past that now; i do dig the op to bust myself but, hell, we can take it...
we're all MEN on a rs board; exept the chicks little ladies babes women who are out Superiors. jusst go with this guys, it makes things a LOT easier trust me --sssh just pretend ou're listening, nod every now and then tell them you understand that youdidn't understand at the time but now you fully understand and thank them a LOT for telling you; how it's made you a better smaller man and shit; just do it man, you want to things to be 'happy' don't you? I know you do sssshhh
Men who dress in red feathers and tights with very keen eye-shadoe maybe,
but men nonethe less Rocky
you should know tha tdude do not getr me started
oh damn i'm already start5ed; who am i kidding?
not hairball. not hairball.

----

seriously do regret it tho Hairball and wud be good to enjoy each other.



Edited 4 time(s). Last edit at 2018-09-01 05:41 by hopkins.

Not trying to speak for Hairball, but I thought the exchange was in good fun. Some people like Steven Tyler's version and some don't. There isn't a right and wrong.

I enjoy your posts. They're like being dropped in a literary labyrinth while tripping on acid. I always finish The Adventure and think in spite of everything, I know what you meant.

Mind you, I just flew from Texas back to Ohio, am working my butt off through a holiday weekend, and went Vegan 3 1/2 weeks ago for a serious health reason. So long story short, my own perspective is a bit shaken.

That said, hopkins, all is well and if everyone doesn't love you, I doubt they feel different about you than they did before. Hairball is a good guy. Passionate about the band. Opinionated like most of us. I don't think any of us mean any lasting harm to the rest. Not even lem. (Yes, I'm teasing my old sparring partner if he reads this).

Quote
Rocky Dijon
Not trying to speak for Hairball, but I thought the exchange was in good fun.

Yeah that's the way I saw it also. As the late great Laker announcer Chick Hearn used to say - "No harm, no foul"!
I actually met good old Chick once at a bar in a hotel the Lakers were staying at back in the '80's during the "showtime years" with Kareem, Magic Johnson, etc. Didn't care about meeting any of them, but Chick Hearn was like a Saint, and I had to approach and thank him for all the years of listening to him announce Lakers games on the radio and tv. He was the nicest celebrity I've ever met! But before I digress into a hopkins style tangent ( ) which I always like to read by the way, I'll leave it at that.

Cheers hopkins - no harm, no foul...it's only rock and roll (but we like it)!



Francis Dayle "Chick" Hearn (November 27, 1916 – August 5, 2002)

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......