For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Turner68
i find an odd definition of mick taylor songs on this thread ... some songs named are just songs he plays on, and some are songs that he claims to have had a part in writing... mixing the two together is a little strange... is "gimme shelter" a "mick taylor song"? is "100 years ago" one of the 3 favorite songs for some IORRians from the entire "golden age"?
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
Quote
kleermaker
Here's one of those songs from his solo album in a live version (first time he performed it live). I can recommend it:
Quote
Turner68Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
gosh i am new here but i hope you are joking.... mick and keith wrote the song and recorded it before taylor was in the band....
Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
Turner68Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
gosh i am new here but i hope you are joking.... mick and keith wrote the song and recorded it before taylor was in the band....
Of course I'm not joking. We are talking about two different versions,Taylor had his hand in the Philly version, lifted it to another level. This version wouldn't exist without him. if I'm not mistaken, At least that what's this thread all about.
Quote
Turner68Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
Turner68Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
gosh i am new here but i hope you are joking.... mick and keith wrote the song and recorded it before taylor was in the band....
Of course I'm not joking. We are talking about two different versions,Taylor had his hand in the Philly version, lifted it to another level. This version wouldn't exist without him. if I'm not mistaken, At least that what's this thread all about.
well sure but then how does pointing out that the song exists because mick and keith wrote it diminish taylor's role?
Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
Turner68Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
Turner68Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
gosh i am new here but i hope you are joking.... mick and keith wrote the song and recorded it before taylor was in the band....
Of course I'm not joking. We are talking about two different versions,Taylor had his hand in the Philly version, lifted it to another level. This version wouldn't exist without him. if I'm not mistaken, At least that what's this thread all about.
well sure but then how does pointing out that the song exists because mick and keith wrote it diminish taylor's role?
Because you're new here, perhaps?
Quote
Turner68
gosh i am new here but i hope you are joking.... mick and keith wrote the song and recorded it before taylor was in the band....
Quote
triceratopsQuote
Turner68
gosh i am new here but i hope you are joking.... mick and keith wrote the song and recorded it before taylor was in the band....
All well and good but Mick Taylor owns and controls that version "Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
And he played with the same virtuoso domination in other shows from that era/ So much so that you could have had Sammy Hagar singing on "Gimme Shelter" and no one would have noticed the difference.[/quote
That's not a good thing; that is part of the problem.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
No, but he wouldn't have had a song to play on if it wasn't for Mick and Keith. Somehow people tend to forget that...
Quote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
LuxuryStonesQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
triceratopsQuote
stewedandkeefed
"Gimme Shelter" from Philadelphia 7/21/72 - early show
That is my number four. Mick Taylor owns that (version) so thoroughly I can see why people got jealous and pushed him out
Great version indeed. Wouldn't have been without Mick and Keith, though..
You never miss a chance to diminish Taylor's role back in the days, do you?
No, but he wouldn't have had a song to play on if it wasn't for Mick and Keith. Somehow people tend to forget that...
He could have played with anyone back in '72. But this is a waste of energy, certainly on a "favorite Mick Taylor Stones songs" thread. So forget it.