For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
andrewt
Always dug this version:
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
Godxofxrock9
i think its always worked better live
I agree...very rare in the Stones catalogue in that regard.
Midnight Rambler is the only other tune that immediately comes to mind.
Quote
andrewt
Always dug this version:
Quote
andrewt
Always dug this version:
Quote
seitan
Keith said in an interview that he wrote it with Mick. - Mick wrote the lyrics. Keef wrote the music.
Quote
drewmasterQuote
andrewt
Always dug this version:
Wow!! This really kicks the studio version's ass. Everything works here and lifts the track to a much higher plane. Thanks andrewt.Quote
seitan
Keith said in an interview that he wrote it with Mick. - Mick wrote the lyrics. Keef wrote the music.
This surprises me too. Seitan, do you have the source for this interview? Thanks.
Drew
Quote
andrewt
Always dug this version:
Quote
wanderingspirit66Quote
drewmasterQuote
seitan
Keith said in an interview that he wrote it with Mick. - Mick wrote the lyrics. Keef wrote the music.
This surprises me too. Seitan, do you have the source for this interview? Thanks.
Drew
There is no need for another source. It is now stated here - in iorr. If it is stated multiple times on iorr, then it becomes a source onto itself.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
andrewt
Always dug this version:
Perfection!
Quote
Doxa
Yeah, one of their best songs from their late period. Musically no equavalent in their earlier material, so also a rare moment of inspiration and creativity, thereby richening their musical vocabulary. The beginning reminds me of "Papa Was A Rolling Stone", if any prior 'source' needs to be mentioned.
That said, I have always felt that the original studio version is a bit underworked, so the song's full potentiality can be heard better in live versions. That's why I take the NO SECURITY version to be THE version (the strong audience reaction - was it in Argentina? - helps nicely the version to 'flow').
I have always thought the song to be a pure Jagger's brain child so that odd quote by Keith sounds confusing to my ears. I never heard it either. If true, a rare glimpse of the Glimmer Twins being able to produce together something novel and memorable since the 70's.
- Doxa
Quote
wanderingspirit66Quote
Doxa
Yeah, one of their best songs from their late period. Musically no equavalent in their earlier material, so also a rare moment of inspiration and creativity, thereby richening their musical vocabulary. The beginning reminds me of "Papa Was A Rolling Stone", if any prior 'source' needs to be mentioned.
That said, I have always felt that the original studio version is a bit underworked, so the song's full potentiality can be heard better in live versions. That's why I take the NO SECURITY version to be THE version (the strong audience reaction - was it in Argentina? - helps nicely the version to 'flow').
I have always thought the song to be a pure Jagger's brain child so that odd quote by Keith sounds confusing to my ears. I never heard it either. If true, a rare glimpse of the Glimmer Twins being able to produce together something novel and memorable since the 70's.
- Doxa
The song is of course fantastic - on record and live; but which odd quote Doxa? There is no quote from Keith - just quotes from iorr members who purport some nonsense, repeat it often enough until others start believing that there was a quote from Keith
Quote
DandelionPowderman
The only Keith-quote I've seen on this song is this:
"Out of Control has that bass riff from Papa Was a Rolling Stone... (H)ey, if anybody can do that (joke), it's us (laughs). Mick played the harmonica solo on that one. He's getting better, man".
- Keith Richards, 1997
[timeisonourside.com]
Quote
DandelionPowderman
The only Keith-quote I've seen on this song is this:
"Out of Control has that bass riff from Papa Was a Rolling Stone... (H)ey, if anybody can do that (joke), it's us (laughs). Mick played the harmonica solo on that one. He's getting better, man".
- Keith Richards, 1997
[timeisonourside.com]
Quote
stoneheartedQuote
DandelionPowderman
The only Keith-quote I've seen on this song is this:
"Out of Control has that bass riff from Papa Was a Rolling Stone... (H)ey, if anybody can do that (joke), it's us (laughs). Mick played the harmonica solo on that one. He's getting better, man".
- Keith Richards, 1997
[timeisonourside.com]
Funny how they would give the (musically) Mick song Anybody Seen My Baby a kd Lang co-credit (at Keith's insistence), but the (musically) Keith song Out Of Control doesn't give co-credit to Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong--and from what we have learned lately Barrett Strong sure could have used the publishing.[www.nytimes.com]
Quote
stoneheartedQuote
DandelionPowderman
The only Keith-quote I've seen on this song is this:
"Out of Control has that bass riff from Papa Was a Rolling Stone... (H)ey, if anybody can do that (joke), it's us (laughs). Mick played the harmonica solo on that one. He's getting better, man".
- Keith Richards, 1997
[timeisonourside.com]
Funny how they would give the (musically) Mick song Anybody Seen My Baby a kd Lang co-credit (at Keith's insistence), but the (musically) Keith song Out Of Control doesn't give co-credit to Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong--and from what we have learned lately Barrett Strong sure could have used the publishing.[www.nytimes.com]
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
stoneheartedQuote
DandelionPowderman
The only Keith-quote I've seen on this song is this:
"Out of Control has that bass riff from Papa Was a Rolling Stone... (H)ey, if anybody can do that (joke), it's us (laughs). Mick played the harmonica solo on that one. He's getting better, man".
- Keith Richards, 1997
[timeisonourside.com]
Funny how they would give the (musically) Mick song Anybody Seen My Baby a kd Lang co-credit (at Keith's insistence), but the (musically) Keith song Out Of Control doesn't give co-credit to Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong--and from what we have learned lately Barrett Strong sure could have used the publishing.[www.nytimes.com]
Well, it is a Mick-song, and the bass riff isn't really a rip-off. If one could rip off feel, it would have been, though
However, they did indeed rip off the Faces arrangement of another Temptations-tune, and used it on OOC:
Quote
elunsi
"I had written a lot of songs coming into this project that I´d already done. I´d written them and thy were all finished and completed. I didn´t really necessarily know we were going to do a Stones record at that point...(I wrote)Anybody Seen My Baby, Saint of Me...Gunface, Out of Control, Might As Well Get Juiced."
- Mick Jagger 1997