For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
NICOS
Who is playing solo on this one? I think I know who´s playing solo from ´67 and on but before that
Play it loud.............
I wonder why this ever was questioned? I'm not picking on you DoomandGloom I'm just wondering because I have seen various people question this over the years. I think all the Stones have said that the slide was played by Brian. So where did the rumour start that it was somebody else?Quote
DoomandGloom
Does Brian play slide on "No Expectations.
Quote
BJPortugalQuote
NICOS
Who is playing solo on this one? I think I know who´s playing solo from ´67 and on but before that
Play it loud.............
Well, it must be Keith... but this cover is great... Love it!
Quote
ovalvoxQuote
BJPortugalQuote
NICOS
Who is playing solo on this one? I think I know who´s playing solo from ´67 and on but before that
Play it loud.............
Well, it must be Keith... but this cover is great... Love it!
Sorry but this Brian playing. Want proof? Saturday club. They play It's Over Now. Mick States "while Brian changes guitars." Brian switches from hIs Vox to his Gretsch. He spends part of the song adjusting the volume. And his Gretsch had an unmistakeable sound. Keith never played that style. Brian plays the same way on the first version of Time On My Side.
Quote
BJPortugalQuote
ovalvoxQuote
BJPortugalQuote
NICOS
Who is playing solo on this one? I think I know who´s playing solo from ´67 and on but before that
Play it loud.............
Well, it must be Keith... but this cover is great... Love it!
Sorry but this Brian playing. Want proof? Saturday club. They play It's Over Now. Mick States "while Brian changes guitars." Brian switches from hIs Vox to his Gretsch. He spends part of the song adjusting the volume. And his Gretsch had an unmistakeable sound. Keith never played that style. Brian plays the same way on the first version of Time On My Side.
If you say so... i am not and expert on see "whats Brian or whats Keith" Great to know that..
Quote
tonterapiI wonder why this ever was questioned? I'm not picking on you DoomandGloom I'm just wondering because I have seen various people question this over the years. I think all the Stones have said that the slide was played by Brian. So where did the rumour start that it was somebody else?Quote
DoomandGloom
Does Brian play slide on "No Expectations.
Quote
stonesnowQuote
tonterapiI wonder why this ever was questioned? I'm not picking on you DoomandGloom I'm just wondering because I have seen various people question this over the years. I think all the Stones have said that the slide was played by Brian. So where did the rumour start that it was somebody else?Quote
DoomandGloom
Does Brian play slide on "No Expectations.
Brian played slide on No Expectations at the Rock n Roll Circus.
Quote
ovalvox
It only makes sense that Brian played lead on Tell Me. Keith certainly wasn't going to write it on a 12 string acoustic guitar and then tell Brian he had to play it while Keith played a different part. More proof is the Red Skelton hour. They mime to it but it is clear that Keith is miming the 12 string acoustic part and Brian is miming the 6 string electric part. No solo of course because it was the American version. Another tidbit is Brian on the same show deliberately plays the chords on the wrong frets on Its All Over Now. He's not playing in the key of G. Probably was bored with all the miming they did in the mid 60's.
Quote
BlueQuote
ovalvox
It only makes sense that Brian played lead on Tell Me. Keith certainly wasn't going to write it on a 12 string acoustic guitar and then tell Brian he had to play it while Keith played a different part. More proof is the Red Skelton hour. They mime to it but it is clear that Keith is miming the 12 string acoustic part and Brian is miming the 6 string electric part. No solo of course because it was the American version. Another tidbit is Brian on the same show deliberately plays the chords on the wrong frets on Its All Over Now. He's not playing in the key of G. Probably was bored with all the miming they did in the mid 60's.
and what a pleasing solo it is, too bad it was eliminated in the American version, in the end what a terrific song with a great sound, both with Keith's 12 string and electric from Brian, Mick sang it perfectly. A classic, loved it since first hearing it back in 64.
Quote
ovalvoxQuote
BlueQuote
ovalvox
It only makes sense that Brian played lead on Tell Me. Keith certainly wasn't going to write it on a 12 string acoustic guitar and then tell Brian he had to play it while Keith played a different part. More proof is the Red Skelton hour. They mime to it but it is clear that Keith is miming the 12 string acoustic part and Brian is miming the 6 string electric part. No solo of course because it was the American version. Another tidbit is Brian on the same show deliberately plays the chords on the wrong frets on Its All Over Now. He's not playing in the key of G. Probably was bored with all the miming they did in the mid 60's.
and what a pleasing solo it is, too bad it was eliminated in the American version, in the end what a terrific song with a great sound, both with Keith's 12 string and electric from Brian, Mick sang it perfectly. A classic, loved it since
first hearing it back in 64.
It's amazing. For years I listened to it and never knew there was a solo on it. Only in America would they worry that a song was to lengthy and cut out a 10 second solo.
Thanks...One more question. Dave Mason to my knowledge also appears on "Beggars" , is that true? Hard to believe Ry is only on one song after all the fuss made through the years but I'll take you on your expertise.Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Brian does play slide on NE. One of his very last great contributions to the Stones' canon.
Ry Cooder plays mandolin on "Love in Vain". He looks to have been around for that first batch of LIB sessions in earl;y '69, right after the R&R Circus. What is odd though is that "Jamming w/ Edward" comes out after the second batch of sessions in April '69.
It seems MT was very quickly announced as official member. This did not happen until May, which was in mid LIB session. he did HTW and "Live with Me".
looking at sessionography he also contributed to a number of tracks in those sessions; many of which show up on "Metamorphosis". (I Dont Know Why, Jivin Sister Fanny, Im Goin Down)
Quote
DoomandGloomThanks...One more question. Dave Mason to my knowledge also appears on "Beggars" , is that true? Hard to believe Ry is only on one song after all the fuss made through the years but I'll take you on your expertise.Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Brian does play slide on NE. One of his very last great contributions to the Stones' canon.
Ry Cooder plays mandolin on "Love in Vain". He looks to have been around for that first batch of LIB sessions in earl;y '69, right after the R&R Circus. What is odd though is that "Jamming w/ Edward" comes out after the second batch of sessions in April '69.
It seems MT was very quickly announced as official member. This did not happen until May, which was in mid LIB session. he did HTW and "Live with Me".
looking at sessionography he also contributed to a number of tracks in those sessions; many of which show up on "Metamorphosis". (I Dont Know Why, Jivin Sister Fanny, Im Goin Down)
Thanks... There's a person who knows their stuff!!!Quote
BJPortugalQuote
DoomandGloomThanks...One more question. Dave Mason to my knowledge also appears on "Beggars" , is that true? Hard to believe Ry is only on one song after all the fuss made through the years but I'll take you on your expertise.Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Brian does play slide on NE. One of his very last great contributions to the Stones' canon.
Ry Cooder plays mandolin on "Love in Vain". He looks to have been around for that first batch of LIB sessions in earl;y '69, right after the R&R Circus. What is odd though is that "Jamming w/ Edward" comes out after the second batch of sessions in April '69.
It seems MT was very quickly announced as official member. This did not happen until May, which was in mid LIB session. he did HTW and "Live with Me".
looking at sessionography he also contributed to a number of tracks in those sessions; many of which show up on "Metamorphosis". (I Dont Know Why, Jivin Sister Fanny, Im Goin Down)
Guitar on Dear Doctor, shehnai on Street Fighting Man, and maybe mellotron on Factory Girl, i suppose.
It's the solid technique and the Ry Cooder presence in that era... Glad to know it's Jones, expertly played...Quote
tonterapiI wonder why this ever was questioned? I'm not picking on you DoomandGloom I'm just wondering because I have seen various people question this over the years. I think all the Stones have said that the slide was played by Brian. So where did the rumour start that it was somebody else?Quote
DoomandGloom
Does Brian play slide on "No Expectations.
Quote
BJPortugalQuote
DoomandGloomThanks...One more question. Dave Mason to my knowledge also appears on "Beggars" , is that true? Hard to believe Ry is only on one song after all the fuss made through the years but I'll take you on your expertise.Quote
Palace Revolution 2000
Brian does play slide on NE. One of his very last great contributions to the Stones' canon.
Ry Cooder plays mandolin on "Love in Vain". He looks to have been around for that first batch of LIB sessions in earl;y '69, right after the R&R Circus. What is odd though is that "Jamming w/ Edward" comes out after the second batch of sessions in April '69.
It seems MT was very quickly announced as official member. This did not happen until May, which was in mid LIB session. he did HTW and "Live with Me".
looking at sessionography he also contributed to a number of tracks in those sessions; many of which show up on "Metamorphosis". (I Dont Know Why, Jivin Sister Fanny, Im Goin Down)
Guitar on Dear Doctor, shehnai on Street Fighting Man, and maybe mellotron on Factory Girl, i suppose.
Just like he did on the album version.Quote
stonesnow
Brian played slide on No Expectations at the Rock n Roll Circus.
Brian played on all the songs but can only be heard on NE and SFTD. I think Keith has said that Brian played bad so they turned off his amp. But some people claim that he is more audible on the bootleg versions of the show and that he plays alright. From what I can see he doesn't play anything wrong. But he is shaky and doesn't look to be either comfortable or feeling well. He needed a brake and professional help at that point. Poor guy.Quote
ovalvox
The RRC was awesome. It was just pure 60's. Brian was carried like Tony Sanchez said in his book but he played. He looked defeated at that point but managed a decent performance considering. He played Flash well. His slide was decent as well. He was a bit shaky on You Can't t Always get what you want. He sounded out of tune because he was having trouble barring the C chord extending his baby finger. He should have played it in open C like Keith did when he did it in the studio. He played Expectations in open E. The other bands were awesome. The Who. Jethro Tull. The Dirty Mac minus Yoko's hideous performance.
The mandolin is mellotron. The fiddle is real.Quote
Mathijs
It's Nicky Hopkins on mellotron (fiddle) on FG.
Quote
tonterapi
The mandolin is mellotron. The fiddle is real.
Quote
tonterapiJust like he did on the album version.Quote
stonesnow
Brian played slide on No Expectations at the Rock n Roll Circus.
I've always found it weird that they decided to perform NE at RnR despite the fact that they didn't know whom of Brian's inner demons they were going to meet for the day. Anyway, he managed to do it and played good.Brian played on all the songs but can only be heard on NE and SFTD. I think Keith has said that Brian played bad so they turned off his amp. But some people claim that he is more audible on the bootleg versions of the show and that he plays alright. From what I can see he doesn't play anything wrong. But he is shaky and doesn't look to be either comfortable or feeling well. He needed a brake and professional help at that point. Poor guy.Quote
ovalvox
The RRC was awesome. It was just pure 60's. Brian was carried like Tony Sanchez said in his book but he played. He looked defeated at that point but managed a decent performance considering. He played Flash well. His slide was decent as well. He was a bit shaky on You Can't t Always get what you want. He sounded out of tune because he was having trouble barring the C chord extending his baby finger. He should have played it in open C like Keith did when he did it in the studio. He played Expectations in open E. The other. bands were awesome. The Who. Jethro Tull. The Dirty Mac minus Yoko's hideous performance.The mandolin is mellotron. The fiddle is real.Quote
Mathijs
It's Nicky Hopkins on mellotron (fiddle) on FG.