Sports column in the daily newspaper by Jerry Sullivan:
Winning will not erase Big Ben's past
Steelers' quarterback missed four games after being accused of sexual assault twice in a nine-month spanI'll admit, I'm not objective on this one. I'm rooting against the Steelers in the Super Bowl today. To be more specific, I'm rooting against Ben Roethlisberger.
Too often, we confuse victory with virtue. Athletes commit all manner of indiscretions. But fans are desperate for any reason to forgive, any sign of contrition in their fallible heroes. Win the big game and it's a tale of human redemption.
Sorry, I'm not ready for Roethlisberger to win a third Super Bowl and tell the world he's headed to Disneyworld after being named the MVP.
It's too soon. Less than a year ago, "Big Ben" was accused of sexual assault for the second time in nine months. He never was charged with a crime. Still, commissioner Roger Goodell felt Roethlisberger's boorish and borderline criminal behavior warranted a six-game suspension, which was later reduced to four games.
Roethlisberger claims to be a new man. He's no longer the guy who mistreated waitresses, bolted on bar tabs and had his posse clean up after him. He wants to be a role model. Big Ben wouldn't reflect on his troubles during Super Bowl week. He quoted from the Bible. That night, he was seen throwing down rum and Cokes in a piano bar at 1 a.m.
Last week, I saw a report from the U.S. Department of Justice, estimating that one in five college women will be sexually assaulted. I have two daughters in college, one in graduate school, one a freshman.
A father worries. I tell my girls that even the good guys are trouble. Roethlisberger is not one of the good guys. He's no role model. The guy has a lot of nerve to even utter those words. The role models are the guys who never need a lesson in how to treat women, the ones who never use fame, money and power to intimidate.
Maybe Roethlisberger really is a changed man. Maybe it's easier to sell the transformation when you have a $100-million contract and a legion of supporters. Is he somehow more likely to reform than all those anonymous abusers on college campuses who have no fan clubs?
Roethlisberger doesn't need to be glorified. He needs to be humbled. I'm not sure the outcome of today's game will make a difference, one way or the other. The world won't be any safer for young women if he gets his butt kicked. That doesn't mean I won't enjoy seeing it.
I'm pulling for the better man today, Aaron Rodgers. OK, I'm less than objective, but I feel Rodgers is a better quarterback than Roethlisberger right now. He's been the best player of the NFL postseason and is getting his due as one of the great young quarterbacks in the game.
Rodgers is the real redemption song. He appears to be a decent guy. There hasn't been a whiff of controversy during his six years in tiny Green Bay. Rodgers has been wise enough to strike up a friendship with Packers legend Bart Starr. Now there's a role model for you.
It hasn't been easy for him. Rodgers lasted until the 24th pick of the 2005 draft. Experts felt he was too stiff mechanically. He wasn't a good enough athlete. For three years, he sat behind Brett Favre in Green Bay. Favre was upset with the choice and did nothing to help mentor Rodgers.
When Rodgers finally got a chance to start after Favre's departure in 2008, he proved his critics wrong. He threw for 4,000 yards his first two seasons and fell just short this year. Say what you will about quarterback ratings: Rodgers' career rating of 98.4 is the best in history.
Nowadays, the experts rave about Rodgers' consistency, his smooth mechanics and lightning-quick release. Rodgers has been a revelation in the postseason. His performance at Atlanta (31 for 36, 366 yards, 3 TDs) was one of the most efficient in history.
Rodgers is mobile with a cannon of an arm. That's a dangerous combination, one that could give the Steelers fits. Teams with an elite quarterback and deep receiving corps tend to do well against the Pittsburgh blitzes. If you attack them through the air and make them use extra defensive backs, you can move the ball on them.
Tom Brady went 30 for 43 for 350 yards and three TDs this year in a big win. Drew Brees beat them, going 34 for 44 for 305 yards and two TDs. Rodgers was 26 for 48 for 383 yards and three TDs in a 37-36 loss a year ago. Kurt Warner was 31 for 43 for 377 yards and three TDs in the Super Bowl two years ago.
The Steelers' defense is the best in the league against the run. But you don't need to run that much to beat them. As the Pats and Saints proved, you can throw 40-plus times, mix in 20 runs and win. The Cardinals ran just 12 times in Super Bowl XLIII and nearly pulled off the upset.
Rodgers has as much an arm as the other three QBs, and he can run. He had 356 yards rushing and four TDs this season. He'll buy time with his legs against an aggressive Pittsburgh defense eager to knock him out of the game.
The Packers have a gifted stable of wide receivers. Indoors, on a fast surface, Rodgers will have a big game if he avoids the blitz and make accurate throws in four- and five-receiver sets.
Roethlisberger has won two Super Bowls. He's tough. Like Rodgers, he makes plays on the move. But the Steelers' offensive line is weak and compromised by injuries.
Big Ben will make his share of big plays. Rodgers will make one or two more. It should be close. There's always a chance Roethlisberger will pull out another Super Bowl and establish himself as one of the great QBs of all time.
It'll take a lot more than that for me to believe he's turned into a great guy
by Jerry Sullivan the Buffalo News Senior Sports Columnist