But Back to hearing Brian. Watching the clip of YCAGWYW and JJF from the Circus, I can see that Brian has been turned down. SO I look at his hands to see what he might have been playing. However, if one tries to imagine actual sound coming from the motion of his strums on the guitar, it seems like he does not even match the song that they are playing. In contrast, from the outtakes of "Pa
Forum: Tell Me

Any theories as to who would have replaced Brian in 1967 had Jagger not been able to convince him to remain in the band? Taylor would have been what, 17 or 18 at the time? They probably would not have taken on such a youngster at the time, would they? Who would have come on -- would be interesting to hear your guesses.
Forum: Tell Me

His Majesty, did Mick play guitar at the Circus? I don't remember Mick doing that. I meant YCAGWYW at the Circus. Is my memory wrong? I thought he just sang and played harmonica.
Forum: Tell Me

Love that rhythm guitar that Brian plays on the Circus version of "Parachute Woman"; why in the world would they mix him out? Sounds grungy and gritty to me -- forceful, even, which is not a word I associate with Brian's guitar playing. The way he strums always seemed somewhat limp; he does not put much arm action, but is a fingers and wrist strummer. Do you have his guitar on t
Forum: Tell Me

"Stone Alone" came out long after Philip Norman's "Symphony for the Devil," which was the first pace I remember reading about Bill's role in "Jumpin' Jack Flash."
Forum: Tell Me

On the Surrey Tapes, is Brian playing the rhythm guitar and Keith the snake-like lead on the romp through "In the Midnight Hour" (or what sounds like the riff of "In the Midnight Hour")?
Forum: Tell Me

Hi everyone. I am a new member, and this is my first post. I am curious to see if anyone can post the two different mixes of the performances of "JJF" and "You Can't Always Get What You Want" from "The Rock and Roll Circus" as depicted in the "25X5" documentary and the DVD of "Rock and Roll Circus." It is my understanding that Brian is much m
Forum: Tell Me