Tough task, especially taking into account very multiple criteria :
setlist, performance, crowd etc...

2005 :
MSG 9
Giants 8.5

2006 :
Milano 8
Paris 9
Nice 8

2007 :
Lyon 9.5
Paris 8.5
O2 #3 8.5
Werchter 8

[doctorstonesblog.blogspot.com]

2006

Twickenham 1 - 7/10
Twickenham 2 - 9/10

2007

O2 1 - 8/10
02 3 - 8/10

2006

Sheffield 7/10 - would have been 8/10 but it poured down all night.

2007

Barcelona 9/10
London #3 10/10

2008

MSG 11/10

2006
Horsens Denmark 8/10

2007
Gothenburg Sweden 9/10
Copenhagen Denmark 10/10

2008
?

Interesting that the 2nd O2 show was rated best by many.
Btw: it was

Fenway 1... 5/10
Fenway 2...6/10
Hartford... 6/10
MSG 05... 8/10
Beacon II ... 10/10

i was at one show only.

02 centre 26th/8/2007.

possibly the last stones concert ever, hopefully not.

give it 8 out of 10.

loved "she was hot", "you got the silver" and "cant you hear me knocking".

also seen "i,ll go crazy", "aint too proud to beg", "i wanna hold you" and "you got me rocking", songs i had never heard live before.

all the rest ive seen before.

rest of the concert was good but the set list could have been better.

the venue was fantastic and i was up in the top tier, near the bottom of it.

enjoyed the whole experience of seeing the stones in london cos i came down from glasgow to stansted early sunday morning and went back to stansted after the show for an early monday morning flight back up to glasgow.

had a few pints aswell.

would do it all again if the opportunity arises.

Why on earth do I do this. Have to stop watching that movie with the lists
(Don't remember the name now).

Fenway I - 9,9 (Just because of not knowing the set list - Shattered, which I hate live ruined the 10. Sorry Stonesdoug).
MSG II - 9
Chicago UC1 - 7,9 (Mick sick)
Munich - 7,5 (Just felt something was missing and wrong, don't ask me what.)
Berlin - 8
Cologne - 8,5
Stuttgart - 9 (Mick jumping down and "shacking hands" with him gives this one an extra 0,4.
Halifax - 8 or 10 (If there's a list of the warmest (Circus Krone?), this was cold after 8 hrs of rain).
Brussels/Werchter - 8
Frankfurt - 7,5 (sound)
Paris - 9,9
Copenhagen - 9,95
Oslo - 8,9
Dusseldorf - 8,5
Hamburg - 8,5

Thanks boys and Lisa

TE
Oslo



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2007-09-07 18:29 by TE.

My 16 shows in 7 countries

2006
MSG I New York : 9
MSG II New York : 9
Horsens Denmark : 7
Hannover Germany : 8
Berlin Germany : 6
Twick I London : 7
Twick II London : 7

2007 :
Lyon France : 5
Barcelona Spain : 9
S.Sebastian Spain : 8
Göteborg Sweden : 3
Copenhagen Denmark : 9
Hamburg Germany : 7
O2 I London : 7
O2 II London : 10
O2 III London : 6


Nice to meet you in New York + London bv !!

Buenos Aires I&II: 11 (Sorry for 11 but it was a different concerts than the others, it was an unforgetable experience!)
Twickenham 2: 8'5
Amsterdam: 8
Barcelona: 10
San Sebastian: 9
El Ejido: 9
Lausanne: 9
Slane: 10
O2 III: 9

Some of this shows I was in 1st row so, I enjoyed very much!



Edited 4 time(s). Last edit at 2007-09-07 19:34 by JordiStones.

2005

Philadelphia 1 : 6
Philadelphia 2 : 4
(or maybe it is the opposite)

2006

Boston 1 : 8
Boston 2 : 9
San Juan : 6
Shangai : 9
Twickenham 1 : 6-7
Twickenham 2 : 6-7


2007

Paris : 6-7
Lyon : 6-7
London 1 : 8
London 2 : 10
London 3 : 8


This is just an impression, depends much on your seat, besides I am not very found of stadium. London II was really excellent.

LA Forum 10/10
Beacon Nov 1 9/10
Vancouver 9/10
Boise 9/10
London 02 Aug 23 9/10
Seattle 2006 8.5/10
Las Vegas March 2006 8/10
London 02 Aug 26 8.5/10
Boston Gillette 9/10
Rome 8.5/10

2006:

Berlin - 8


2007:
Hamburg - 10

2006

munich 7,5

stuttgart 9

2007

franfurt 7

barcelona 10

It's an impressive number of shows most of you went to! I "only" got to see them twice. First in Bergen, and then the last O2 show. The first one was the best IMO...But then again, the London experience...

Munich 6,5 (Great sound but band on autopilot)
Glasgow 8 (Crap sound but band really trying)
Brno 9 (Great sound, band superb and me FOS for about 80 dollars)

Dearest TE, Too Tough and Stones Bernard, you all rated last year's Cologne rather high - the show in which Ronnie himself claimed he "hit rock bottom"?! I felt ashamed to my best friend and his son seeing that performance. Unfortunately, Frankfurt 2007 was great despite something very essential ... the sound. Lucky though, I was consoled by Dusseldorf. Count me in again for the pre-50-Licks-tour in (fill in the gap)

JJHMick Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Dearest TE, Too Tough and Stones Bernard, you all
> rated last year's Cologne rather high - the show
> in which Ronnie himself claimed he "hit rock
> bottom"?! I felt ashamed to my best friend and his
> son seeing that performance. Unfortunately,
> Frankfurt 2007 was great despite something very
> essential ... the sound.

maybe it was BECAUSE of the bad sound that it seemed so good

Nice 9
Budapest 8.5 (crowd 10+! )

I am rating these in order and somewhat in tiers

I am not assigning points



1) O2 II (Best show of tour and (my) best show ever in 32 years, 45 shows which included 27 on this tour alone)



2) Beacon II

3) Twickenham I


Tier 4, all close together,but in the following order:

MSG Jan 06 I

MSG Jan 06 II

Lyon

O2 III

Denver

O2 I

Missoula

Twickenham II

Paris 07


5) Hollywood Bowl I and II (been so long, can't differentiate)

6) Vancouver

7) Lausanne



The Plexiglass



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-09-08 04:04 by timbernardis.

Hi JJHMick,
Know what you mean.
I "should" have given it less points.
But it's a stupid 1-10 and I will still stand at 8 or whatever I gave them.
It was a comedy show for us up front. Sad of cource to see Ronnie in that stage but half fun to see angry Jagger and Keith laughing his pants off.
Was an all time low for Ronnie but it didn't spoil my night (OK Razorlight).
As tears go by and she's so cold. Get off my cloud at the B-stage. Yes, had a ball. But agree with you. We all witnessed Ronnie's life took an U-turn (according to himself).

TE
Oslo

JJHMick Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Dearest TE, Too Tough and Stones Bernard, you all
> rated last year's Cologne rather high - the show
> in which Ronnie himself claimed he "hit rock
> bottom"?! I felt ashamed to my best friend and his
> son seeing that performance. Unfortunately,
> Frankfurt 2007 was great despite something very
> essential ... the sound. Lucky though, I was
> consoled by Dusseldorf. Count me in again for the
> pre-50-Licks-tour in (fill in the gap)

2005
_____

Hartford- raw and raunchy and ful of energy
Fenway I
Fenway 2

2006
________
Gillette stadium, foxboro
MSG, 2nd show
Boston TD Banknorth, 2nd show
Boston, TD Banknorth, 1st show- exrremely loud...loud...loud

Key arena 2005- 8/10

Quest Field 2006- 10/10

My Blog
[stonesrockforever.blogspot.com]

2006

MSG I--8.5
MSG II--8.75 SWAY!!

Radio City Music Hall--6

Giants Stadium --5





Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-09-08 07:17 by Bingo.

2005

SF 1- 8/10-sweet viginia in Norther California!
Denver 9/10- killer Midnight Rambler

2006

Vegas (march) 9/10 great hearing Gimme Shelter
Vegas (Nov.) 9.5/10- awesome show

London 1-9/10
London 2 10/10 amazing!

Might have liked 02/03 a bit more, but wow, they are good! I also might be a high scorer, but I sure loved the shows!

Anaheim 11/4/05 7


Hollywood Bowl 11/6-8/05
(I snuck in both nights making the overall experience a 10)

San Diego 11/11/05 10 (onstage seats and top notch performance)

Fresno 11/20/05 7 (average show but a lot of fun due to surrounding events and getting a great seat)

Forum 3/6/06 10 (amazing show even from the top of the arena)

Dodger Stadium 11/22/06 7

1. MGM Grand Vegas 3/06
2. Fenway Park Boston (Opener)
3. MGM Grand Vegas 11/06
4. Paris 6/07
5. Fenway Park Boston (2nd show--only one song different from opener)
6. Frankfurt 6/07 (My favorite setlist, but sound quality was worst of all shows)

2005:
Moncton - 10

2006:
Twick 1 - 10
Twick 2 - 10
Glascow - 10
Sheffield - 10
Cardiff - 10
Bergen - 10
Horsens - 10

2007:
Lyon - 10
San Sebastian - 10
Dublin - 10

I rate the other shows i went to also as 10 lol

Life's just a cocktail party on the street

Twick 1 - 8
Sheffield - 9 they played brilliantly when the rain came down. Worked the crowd really hard and got the place jumping.

O2 2 - 10 what can I say apart from great. probably one the best gigs I have ever been to. Midnight Rambler.....amazing.

NickB

You can't always get what you want.....

www.myspace.com/thesonkings

Budva 09.07. audience 8/ Stones 7
Belgrade 14.07. audience 10/ Stones 11