-



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2007-06-25 21:12 by schillid.

Wow...very, very nice.

If used for the t-shirt, just don't print it too big. It will look richer and more, shall we say "appropriate" for those of us over 35, if it was smaller placed on the breast). IMHO.

I still like the concept, but I think the, well, how can I explain this... the 'schwung' is less. Seperating the bandmembers in the image has made it more rigid. Maybe too rigid. Maybe it has something to do with the heads of Mick, Ronnie and Charlie, that seem to be placed on one horizontal line. Less 'movement' than in the concept picture.

That said, let's move on to the positive aspects: the faces are much more recognizable, which is very nice. The letters are not translucent anymore, you don't see the O shine through the I anymore, which makes it very clear.

Charlie and Keith are transferred very good, Mick and Ronnie are still very 'photoshopped', if you see what I mean. (around the hair)

Don't get me wrong: I'm trying to point things out, that in my opinion are holding the design back from its full potency. It is still growing, and I still like the idea very much.

Jelle



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-02-07 18:33 by sluissie.

inopeng Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Wow...very, very nice.
>
> If used for the t-shirt, just don't print it too
> big. It will look richer and more, shall we say
> "appropriate" for those of us over 35, if it was
> smaller placed on the breast). IMHO.


Couldn't have said it any better, even if I am still under 35 LOL.
Why not a grey shirt instead of these too classic black shirts ?

[doctorstonesblog.blogspot.com]

really nice work Schillid - thank you for all your good hard work.
Keith looks great! so do the colours; and i like the style of the letters a lot.

do the outlines of the others look a lot more artificial than Keith's? (especially Mick, and Ronnie's hair)
and ... does Charlie now look closer to the front than Keith?
and ... sorry but ... it's not the image of Mick i'd choose.

sorry if i'm out of line - i'm just sayin, because you asked.

Great job, schillid! You da man!

Jagged photoshop cuts will disappear... that's the easy part.

I agree that it's losing something from the original though. I will go back and check later.

like it...but keith, ron & charlie...have basically the same expression.
re: photo choice.....any more variety? ronnie smiling? keith glaring?
mick & charlie are fine.

i also agree with what openg & doc said (size).

and i agree with all the positives...

schillid....you did a great job. i/we don't mean to be picky.
people who do creative/subjective things open themselves up.....it's unfair. i know.


IORR............but I like it!

I agree about facial expressions. They're all looking down (excpt mj). I'd like especially to see Keith or Ronnie looking at the other guy... BV?

NICE !!!

>> like it...but keith, ron & charlie...<<

smile: yeah, they're all transfixed by our left breasts :E

>> I'd like especially to see Keith or Ronnie looking at the other guy <<

that would be beautiful

>> schillid....you did a great job. i/we don't mean to be picky. <<

absolutely.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-02-07 19:12 by with sssoul.

sweet neo con Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> we don't mean to be picky.
> people who do creative/subjective things open
> themselves up.....it's unfair. i know.


I can take it.

Nice.......IMO, either Ron and Charlie or Keith and Charlie should be changed, so they are looking at a different focal point.

Otherwise, looks great.

But nice to have the detail of Charlie's drum in the picture.

Ideally:



Mick looking at audience (the pic we have is fine)

switch keith and Ron positions
Ronnie------->Keith-------> Charlie looking down (the pic we have is fine)

"----->" = where RW and KR are looking

Manofwealthandtaste Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> nice to have the detail of Charlie's drum in the picture.


I had hoped to have keth and ron's guitars in it too.

schillid Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Manofwealthandtaste Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > nice to have the detail of Charlie's drum in the
> picture.
>
>
> I had hoped to have keth and ron's guitars in it
> too.


Still quite cool to have their guitar straps, thus showing they are 'in action' rather than standing at a Press shoot.

>> I had hoped to have Keith and Ron's guitars in it too. <<

great idea - part of at least one guitar would be cool
have some of this very creative 4-colour popcorn :E

with sssoul Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> have some of this very creative 4-colour popcorn


Do you know if the popcorn is CMYK or not?

>> Do you know if the popcorn is CMYK or not? <<

smile: nah, but if you hum a few bars i'll try to wing it :E

-



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2007-02-08 04:12 by schillid.

I much prefer the original, as seen on this page: [www.iorr.org]

Any reason you can't use that one? Looks perfect to me.

yes...actually i agree with ohnonotyouagain...i like the feel of those images across the IORR. if it's ok to use those images....that's my vote.




IORR............but I like it!

sweet neo con Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> yes...actually i agree with ohnonotyouagain...i
> like the feel of those images across the IORR. if
> it's ok to use those images....that's my vote.
>
> [www.iorr.org]


Me too, I think it's better when Stones are spread around, inside the letters, instead of this version...but it's good work, schillid, you made the first version too

Seriously
I will obviously need to go back and examine my earlie design.

I gotten too far away from it

oh is this the thread for us to say what we personally want?? provide comments on things that should be changed???

i understood shirt deal was done?

IORR............but I like it!

I was just asking for people's reaction to the logo...

We now rejoin the main thread ...

i like the original images but in the new layout - i like how each one is in a letter.

I think the design flows better with the overlap in the original.