Tell Me :  Talk
Talk about your favorite band. 

Previous page Next page First page IORR home

For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.

Goto Page: 12Next
Current Page: 1 of 2
Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: RollingStonesFan ()
Date: February 27, 2020 10:17

Did you ever reflect on which were the last live-debuts of songs the Rolling Stones never played live before (beside songs of a new album or covers they didn't publish on a studio-album)? @hockenheim95 and me did so and we found out that the last songs of this category must have been:

- Under The Boardwalk (2013-06-21 Philly)
- Emotional Rescue (2013-05-03 LA)
- She Was Hot (2006-10-11 Chicago)
- Sway (2005-10-24 Columbus)

This list wasn't complete if we don't list the songs they performed for the first time for a longer time:

- Harlem Shuffle (2019-08-05 NY) last time: 1990
- Mercy Mercy (2019-07-03 Landover) last time: 1969
- Sad Sad Sad (2019-06-21 Chicago) last time: 2002
- Fool To Cry (2018-05-22 London) last time: 1999
- The Worst (2018-05-17 Dublin) last time: 1995
- Play With Fire (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1990
- Dancing With Mr. D (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1973

I'm pretty sure this list istn't complete at all. But it's a beginning. Any suggestions for more songs we didn't tink About?



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 10:27 by RollingStonesFan.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 10:23

That Hamburg show was not great but the setlist was fantastic

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 10:38

Quote
RollingStonesFan
Did you ever reflect on which were the last live-debuts of songs the Rolling Stones never played live before (beside songs of a new album or covers they didn't publish on a studio-album)? @hockenheim95 and me did so and we found out that the last songs of this category must have been:

- Under The Boardwalk (2013-06-21 Philly)
- Emotional Rescue (2013-05-03 LA)
- She Was Hot (2006-10-11 Chicago)
- Sway (2005-10-24 Columbus)

This list wasn't complete if we don't list the songs they performed for the first time for a longer time:

- Harlem Shuffle (2019-08-05 NY) last time: 1990
- Mercy Mercy (2019-07-03 Landover) last time: 1969
- Sad Sad Sad (2019-06-21 Chicago) last time: 2002
- Fool To Cry (2018-05-22 London) last time: 1999
- The Worst (2018-05-17 Dublin) last time: 1995
- Play With Fire (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1990
- Dancing With Mr. D (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1973

I'm pretty sure this list istn't complete at all. But it's a beginning. Any suggestions for more songs we didn't tink About?

– Lady Jane, London Nov 29, 2012. Last time: 1967.
– The Last Time, Toronto, Sept. 4, 1997. Last time: 1966.
– Parachute Woman, Boston, Sept. 8, 2002. Last time: 1968.
– Salt Of The Earth, Atlantic City, Dec 19, 1989. Last time: 1968.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: erikjjf ()
Date: February 27, 2020 10:50

Quote
RollingStonesFan
- The Worst (2018-05-17 Dublin) last time: 1995

Also played in 2005.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: hockenheim95 ()
Date: February 27, 2020 10:58

Quote
DandelionPowderman
Quote
RollingStonesFan
Did you ever reflect on which were the last live-debuts of songs the Rolling Stones never played live before (beside songs of a new album or covers they didn't publish on a studio-album)? @hockenheim95 and me did so and we found out that the last songs of this category must have been:

- Under The Boardwalk (2013-06-21 Philly)
- Emotional Rescue (2013-05-03 LA)
- She Was Hot (2006-10-11 Chicago)
- Sway (2005-10-24 Columbus)

This list wasn't complete if we don't list the songs they performed for the first time for a longer time:

- Harlem Shuffle (2019-08-05 NY) last time: 1990
- Mercy Mercy (2019-07-03 Landover) last time: 1969
- Sad Sad Sad (2019-06-21 Chicago) last time: 2002
- Fool To Cry (2018-05-22 London) last time: 1999
- The Worst (2018-05-17 Dublin) last time: 1995
- Play With Fire (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1990
- Dancing With Mr. D (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1973

I'm pretty sure this list istn't complete at all. But it's a beginning. Any suggestions for more songs we didn't tink About?

– Lady Jane, London Nov 29, 2012. Last time: 1967.
– The Last Time, Toronto, Sept. 4, 1997. Last time: 1966.
– Parachute Woman, Boston, Sept. 8, 2002. Last time: 1968.
– Salt Of The Earth, Atlantic City, Dec 19, 1989. Last time: 1968.

Here we could discuss if the Circus performances are really live as they did multiple takes of the songs in a studio with a live audience. Salt of the earth wasn't even played it was just vocals over a backing Tracks.

My Main question is - was there any other live debut after "Under the boardwalk"?

And we can add Silver Train to the second list which had a break of 41 years between the 4 performances in 1973 and the three performances in 2014.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: Harry ()
Date: February 27, 2020 11:19

They played "Under the boardwalk" few times early 1965 at Australasian & Singapore Tour between 22.01.65-16.02.65. Debut probably was 22.01.65 Sydney,Australia Agricultural Hall



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 11:22 by Harry.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: hockenheim95 ()
Date: February 27, 2020 11:28

Quote
Harry
They played "Under the boardwalk" few times early 1965 at Australasian & Singapore Tour between 22.01.65-16.02.65. Debut probably was 22.01.65 Sydney,Australia Agricultural Hall

Never heard that before. I don't think any recordings survived from that era?! Are there any sources for this? I looked at zentgraf and he mentions this song but says it is unverified

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: erikjjf ()
Date: February 27, 2020 11:48

2000 Light Years From Home (Glastonbury 2013; 1990)
Can't Be Seen (Oslo 2014; 1990)
Mixed Emotions (2016; 1990)
Around And Around (Newark 2012; 1977)
I Wanna Be Your Man (London 2012; 1964)
I'll Go Crazy (Werchter 2007)
Learning The Game (Austin 2006)
I'm Free (Beacon 2006; 1969)
Champagne And Reefer (Beacon 2006)
Little T&A (Boston 2006; 1982)
As Tears Go By (LA 2005; 1966)
Salt Of The Earth (Twickenham 2003; 1989)
The Nearness of You (Cirkus Krone 2003)
She Smiled Sweetly (Roseland 2002; 1967)
That's How Strong My Love Is (Roseland 2002; 1966)
Ain't Too Proud To Beg (Roseland 2002; 1976)
Thru And Thru (MSG 2002)
Walk And Don't Look Back (Aragon 2002)
Everybody Needs Somebody To Love (Orpheum 2002; 1981)
Dance Part 1 (Orpheum 2002)
Going To A Go-Go (Orpheum 2002; 1982)
Rock Me Baby (Orpheum 2002)
Hand Of Fate (Orpheum 2002; 1977)
Loving Cup (Boston 2002; 1972)
Love Train (Boston 2002)
Mannish Boy (Boston 2002; 1986)
Neighbours (Boston 2002; 1982)
If You Can't Rock Me (Toronto 2002; 1976)
Stray Cat Blues (Toronto 2002; 1976)
Torn And Frayed (Toronto 2002; 1972)
I Can't Turn You Loose (Toronto 2002)
Heart of Stone (Toronto 2002; 1965)
Can't You Hear Me Knocking (Toronto 2002)
Little Queenie (Toronto 1997; 1973)
19th Nervous Breakdown (Toronto 1997; 1967)
Crazy Mama (Chicago 1997; 1977)
Waiting On A Friend (Albuquerque 1997; 1982)
When The Whip Comes Down (LA 1997; 1982)
All About You (Chicago 1997)
Wanna Hold You (Chicago 1997)
Sister Morphine (Chicago 1997)
She's A Rainbow (Chicago 1997)
Time Is On My Side (Osaka 1998; 1982)
Moonlight Mile (Oakland 1999)
Some Girls (Oakland 1999)
You Got The Silver (Oakland 1999)
Route 66 (Oakland 1999; 1977)
Get Off Of My Cloud (Philadelphia 1999; 1976)
I Got The Blue (Hartford 1999; 1971)
Melody (Shepherds Bush 1999; 1977)



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 13:59 by erikjjf.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 12:13

Quote
hockenheim95
Quote
DandelionPowderman
Quote
RollingStonesFan
Did you ever reflect on which were the last live-debuts of songs the Rolling Stones never played live before (beside songs of a new album or covers they didn't publish on a studio-album)? @hockenheim95 and me did so and we found out that the last songs of this category must have been:

- Under The Boardwalk (2013-06-21 Philly)
- Emotional Rescue (2013-05-03 LA)
- She Was Hot (2006-10-11 Chicago)
- Sway (2005-10-24 Columbus)

This list wasn't complete if we don't list the songs they performed for the first time for a longer time:

- Harlem Shuffle (2019-08-05 NY) last time: 1990
- Mercy Mercy (2019-07-03 Landover) last time: 1969
- Sad Sad Sad (2019-06-21 Chicago) last time: 2002
- Fool To Cry (2018-05-22 London) last time: 1999
- The Worst (2018-05-17 Dublin) last time: 1995
- Play With Fire (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1990
- Dancing With Mr. D (2017-09-09 Hamburg) last time: 1973

I'm pretty sure this list istn't complete at all. But it's a beginning. Any suggestions for more songs we didn't tink About?

– Lady Jane, London Nov 29, 2012. Last time: 1967.
– The Last Time, Toronto, Sept. 4, 1997. Last time: 1966.
– Parachute Woman, Boston, Sept. 8, 2002. Last time: 1968.
– Salt Of The Earth, Atlantic City, Dec 19, 1989. Last time: 1968.

Here we could discuss if the Circus performances are really live as they did multiple takes of the songs in a studio with a live audience. Salt of the earth wasn't even played it was just vocals over a backing Tracks.

My Main question is - was there any other live debut after "Under the boardwalk"?

And we can add Silver Train to the second list which had a break of 41 years between the 4 performances in 1973 and the three performances in 2014.

Yeah, that's true. However, they did perform the songs in front of an audience, so... At least Mick did sing live on Salt Of The Earth.

There are many more songs that can be added to the list(s). She Smiled Sweetly is one of them, with a big time span between performances.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: nick1970 ()
Date: February 27, 2020 13:53

This is interesting. It says 19th nervous breakdown 1997... this is the first time I have seen this listed. Are there anymore details??

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: hockenheim95 ()
Date: February 27, 2020 13:56

Quote
nick1970
This is interesting. It says 19th nervous breakdown 1997... this is the first time I have seen this listed. Are there anymore details??

Here we go!!

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 13:57

.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 14:08 by DandelionPowderman.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: hockenheim95 ()
Date: February 27, 2020 14:00

On Light The Fuse it is a "blues Version" of the song. The B2B Tour Version is the fast one

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 14:02

.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 14:08 by DandelionPowderman.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: Harry ()
Date: February 27, 2020 14:09

Quote
hockenheim95
Quote
Harry
They played "Under the boardwalk" few times early 1965 at Australasian & Singapore Tour between 22.01.65-16.02.65. Debut probably was 22.01.65 Sydney,Australia Agricultural Hall

Never heard that before. I don't think any recordings survived from that era?! Are there any sources for this? I looked at zentgraf and he mentions this song but says it is unverified

[rocksoff.org] there is probably not any recordings.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 14:10 by Harry.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 14:14

No. That was from 2005. They performed "19th Nervous Breakdown" quite regularly in '97 and a couple of times in '98.

This is when they stuck with the rare songs and you had more than a 10 to 15 % chance of catching it at the show you attend.

Also,"The Worst" was performed at every concert (except for the bomb threat show) for the first stretch of the '05 tour until they went out west.And they also played it a few rare times in 2002 and Australia 2003.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 14:20

Quote
Winning Ugly VXII
No. That was from 2005. They performed "19th Nervous Breakdown" quite regularly in '97 and a couple of times in '98.

This is when they stuck with the rare songs and you had more than a 10 to 15 % chance of catching it at the show you attend.

Also,"The Worst" was performed at every concert (except for the bomb threat show) for the first stretch of the '05 tour until they went out west.And they also played it a few rare times in 2002 and Australia 2003.

And for the first few shows in 2018.





[www.youtube.com]



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 14:20 by DandelionPowderman.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: MisterO ()
Date: February 27, 2020 15:21

IIRC....."Might as well get juiced" was only played once at Madison Square Garden in 97 or 98...?

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 15:31

Quote
MisterO
IIRC....."Might as well get juiced" was only played once at Madison Square Garden in 97 or 98...?

Same with How Can I Stop and Already Over Me.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: Elmo Lewis ()
Date: February 27, 2020 15:55

One could make a great setlist of unplayed songs, starting with "Out Of Time".

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: Erik_Snow ()
Date: February 27, 2020 15:55

Quote
DandelionPowderman
Quote
MisterO
IIRC....."Might as well get juiced" was only played once at Madison Square Garden in 97 or 98...?

Same with How Can I Stop and Already Over Me.

You mean Lowdown, not Already Over Me

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: erikjjf ()
Date: February 27, 2020 15:55

Quote
DandelionPowderman
Quote
MisterO
IIRC....."Might as well get juiced" was only played once at Madison Square Garden in 97 or 98...?

Same with How Can I Stop and Already Over Me.


Already Over Me was also played in Portland and Las Vegas.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 16:21

Quote
Erik_Snow
Quote
DandelionPowderman
Quote
MisterO
IIRC....."Might as well get juiced" was only played once at Madison Square Garden in 97 or 98...?

Same with How Can I Stop and Already Over Me.

You mean Lowdown, not Already Over Me

I forgot Lowdown, but meant AOM smiling smiley

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: bakersfield ()
Date: February 27, 2020 17:17

....someone said earlier: 'The Hamburg show was not great but the set list was fantastic'. This make Mick's point for him, I think. The songs they play best now are the ones we call warhorses. Anyone who endured'Shattered' at Manchester will know what I mean. I love that tune - it's one of my top 10 stones songs, but they played it so slowly and tentatively that I would rather they hadn't bothered.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 17:23

Quote
bakersfield
....someone said earlier: 'The Hamburg show was not great but the set list was fantastic'. This make Mick's point for him, I think. The songs they play best now are the ones we call warhorses. Anyone who endured'Shattered' at Manchester will know what I mean. I love that tune - it's one of my top 10 stones songs, but they played it so slowly and tentatively that I would rather they hadn't bothered.

The show was both great and not so great. Highlights were Play With Fire, Mr D, Out Of Control, the B&L-tracks and Under My Thumb – in addition to some of the warhorses. So, it's not really that black and white, imo smiling smiley

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: Christiaan ()
Date: February 27, 2020 20:29

Jump On Top Of Me, Paradiso, Amsterdam. 27th of May 1995
The Nearness Of You, Cirkus Krone, Munich. 8th of June 2003
It Won’t Take Long, Hollywood Bowl, Hollywood. November 6th of 2005
As Tears Go By, Hollywood Bowl, Hollywood. November 6th of 2005
Going Down (Jeff Beck cover, he played along) O2, London. November 25th of 2012
One More Shot, O2, London. November 25th of 2012
I happened to be there with this live debuts.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-02-27 20:35 by Christiaan.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: Christiaan ()
Date: February 27, 2020 20:33

They played only one time in 1986, at the 100 Club, a memorial for Ian (Stu) Stewart. They played Mannish Boy then?

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: Christiaan ()
Date: February 27, 2020 20:37

Quote
Christiaan
They played only one time in 1986, at the 100 Club, a memorial for Ian (Stu) Stewart. They played Mannish Boy then?

Yes, looking at this site of Rocks Off

[rocksoff.org]

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Date: February 27, 2020 20:41

Quote
Christiaan
Jump On Top Of Me, Paradiso, Amsterdam. 27th of May 1995
The Nearness Of You, Cirkus Krone, Munich. 8th of June 2003
It Won’t Take Long, Hollywood Bowl, Hollywood. November 6th of 2005
As Tears Go By, Hollywood Bowl, Hollywood. November 6th of 2005
Going Down (Jeff Beck cover, he played along) O2, London. November 25th of 2012
One More Shot, O2, London. November 25th of 2012
I happened to be there with this live debuts.

Going Down is not a Jeff Beck-tune. Written by Don Nix. Made immortal by Freddie King.

They also played Doom And Gloom for the first time in London on Nov 25, 2012, btw.

Re: Live performed songs never or rarely played before
Posted by: DrPete ()
Date: February 27, 2020 20:41

Kansas City in 2015 in KC had not been played since 64 or even 63

Goto Page: 12Next
Current Page: 1 of 2


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Online Users

Guests: 683
Record Number of Users: 184 on May 17, 2018 22:46
Record Number of Guests: 4101 on December 24, 2020 10:57

Previous page Next page First page IORR home