For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
EdithGroove
Does anyone have any information on the three new Stones releases on Spotify?
Quote
IrixQuote
EdithGroove
Does anyone have any information on the three new Stones releases on Spotify?
Maybe they're only Copyright-protection releases (50-years-rule) like in the recent past e.g. on YouTube or iTunes ....
Quote
Whale
Only on spotify?
Not on itunes?
Quote
DandelionPowderman
I didn't find nothing of the sort under «Albums», «Singles & EPs» or «Compilations» on Spotify..
Quote
Tornandfrayed
The Ya-Ya´s stuff is just the audio of the bonus DVD from the 2009 Super Deluxe Box Set. The DVD included alternate takes of the same tracks as on the bonus CD. There is nothing new here.
Quote
retired_dogQuote
Tornandfrayed
The Ya-Ya´s stuff is just the audio of the bonus DVD from the 2009 Super Deluxe Box Set. The DVD included alternate takes of the same tracks as on the bonus CD. There is nothing new here.
So it is quite doubtful that these are "copyright protection releases" after all. These tracks have already been released! Same story with the Ed Sullivan stuff, everything was previously released on DVD before. And if an offcial DVD release does not count in copyright terms, für most of the Ed Sullivan (up until 1967) stuff it would be too late anyway to escape the 50 years-trap...
Quote
Tornandfrayed
The Ya-Ya´s stuff is just the audio of the bonus DVD from the 2009 Super Deluxe Box Set. The DVD included alternate takes of the same tracks as on the bonus CD. There is nothing new here.
Quote
boogaloojefQuote
retired_dogQuote
Tornandfrayed
The Ya-Ya´s stuff is just the audio of the bonus DVD from the 2009 Super Deluxe Box Set. The DVD included alternate takes of the same tracks as on the bonus CD. There is nothing new here.
So it is quite doubtful that these are "copyright protection releases" after all. These tracks have already been released! Same story with the Ed Sullivan stuff, everything was previously released on DVD before. And if an offcial DVD release does not count in copyright terms, für most of the Ed Sullivan (up until 1967) stuff it would be too late anyway to escape the 50 years-trap...
If that is the case, why would they have already taken them down? They were only available for a very short time.
Quote
NathanLaze
anybody purchased them all???? dying to hear these....
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
NathanLaze
anybody purchased them all???? dying to hear these....
Haven't you heard them on Ya Yas and the Ed Sullivan-dvd?
Quote
retired_dogQuote
boogaloojefQuote
retired_dogQuote
Tornandfrayed
The Ya-Ya´s stuff is just the audio of the bonus DVD from the 2009 Super Deluxe Box Set. The DVD included alternate takes of the same tracks as on the bonus CD. There is nothing new here.
So it is quite doubtful that these are "copyright protection releases" after all. These tracks have already been released! Same story with the Ed Sullivan stuff, everything was previously released on DVD before. And if an offcial DVD release does not count in copyright terms, für most of the Ed Sullivan (up until 1967) stuff it would be too late anyway to escape the 50 years-trap...
If that is the case, why would they have already taken them down? They were only available for a very short time.
Well, apparently there's not much sense behind these releases. At least I can't see it from a copyright point of view. And I'm also not sure that "releasing" stuff for a day or two is what the EC lawmakers had in mind when they invented the "use it (within 50 years) or lose it"-provision. It's simply not a serious commercial attempt to "release material to the general public" that warrants further copyright protection. It's more like playing foul with the law. There may be judges who don't like small dirty tricks like this...
Quote
boogaloojefQuote
retired_dogQuote
boogaloojefQuote
retired_dogQuote
Tornandfrayed
The Ya-Ya´s stuff is just the audio of the bonus DVD from the 2009 Super Deluxe Box Set. The DVD included alternate takes of the same tracks as on the bonus CD. There is nothing new here.
So it is quite doubtful that these are "copyright protection releases" after all. These tracks have already been released! Same story with the Ed Sullivan stuff, everything was previously released on DVD before. And if an offcial DVD release does not count in copyright terms, für most of the Ed Sullivan (up until 1967) stuff it would be too late anyway to escape the 50 years-trap...
If that is the case, why would they have already taken them down? They were only available for a very short time.
Well, apparently there's not much sense behind these releases. At least I can't see it from a copyright point of view. And I'm also not sure that "releasing" stuff for a day or two is what the EC lawmakers had in mind when they invented the "use it (within 50 years) or lose it"-provision. It's simply not a serious commercial attempt to "release material to the general public" that warrants further copyright protection. It's more like playing foul with the law. There may be judges who don't like small dirty tricks like this...
It's possible they were altered slightly and copyrighted again. Some people have said the reason the On Air BBC vault release was officially released in fake stereo was so they could copyright the material as the bootlegs have most of the same material in mono.