Not that easy, many good songs on these records. In random order.

1. Star Star
2. Coming Down Again
3. Winter
4. 100 Years Ago
5. Dance Little Sister
6. It's Only Rock'n'Roll
7. If You Really Want to Be My Friend
8. Time Waits For No One
9. Crazy Mama
10.Hand of Fate
11.Memory Motel
12.Hey Negrita



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016-03-13 10:30 by bobo.

Heartbreaker
Angie
Coming down again
100 Years ago
Winter
Till the next goodbye
If you really want to be my friend
Time waits for no one
Fingerprint file
Hand of fate
Memory motel
Crazy Mama

Heartbreaker

Aint Too Proud to Beg

100 Years Ago

Hot Stuff

Coming Down Again

Silver Train

Luxury

Till the Next Goodbye

Its Only Rock n Roll

Angie

Fingerprint File

Time Waits for No One

Doo Doo Doo Doo Heartbreaker
Star Star
100 Years Ago
Dance Little Sister
If You Cant Rock Me
Aint Too Proud To Beg
Fingerprint File
Hot Stuff
Hey Negrita
Hand Of Fate
Memory Motel
Crazy Mama

A masterpiece, a masterpiece, this compilation is a masterpiece, congrats to myself

This must be the nicest fan-made Stones-comp ever, sublime and breathtaking from start to finish.

Interesting point but it won't work as these 3 albums have a specific musical identity. Can you imagine going from "Winter" into "Crazy Mama"?
Urgh not me.

It'd work better with albums from the "golden era" imo.

Quote
dcba
Interesting point but it won't work as these 3 albums have a specific musical identity. Can you imagine going from "Winter" into "Crazy Mama"?
Urgh not me.

It'd work better with albums from the "golden era" imo.

You are right about "specific musical identity" especially for Black And Blue. But then REWIND shouldnt be allowed also, it´ a much more mixed bag.

I do not need to imagine going from Winter to Crazy Mama, Winter is too bad (should say: too boring) to be ever on my personal compilation which is truly great.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016-03-13 12:37 by HMS.

100 years ago
Can you hear the music
Coming down again
Angie
If you can't rock me
IORR
Luxury
Fingerprint File
Hot stuff
Memory Motel
Hey negrita
Fool to cry

Quote
latebloomer
Too hard, I don't like this game.

Agreed - I like the albums just as they are and/or for what they are.
I couldn't even come up with no where near 12 to leave off of GHS, IORR, and BNB...Cherry Oh Baby is the only real candidiate for deletion imo.

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......

Hand of Fate
Memory Motel
Crazy Mama
If you can't rock me
Ain't to proud to Beg
It's only Rock and roll
Time waits for no one
Dancin with Mr D
Coming Down Again
Heartbreaker
Angie
Winter

Hot stuff
100 years ago
Coming down again
Hand of fate
Luxury
Memory motel

Hey negrita
Ain't to proud to beg
Winter
Dance little sister
@#$%&
Time waits for no one

Could you imagine including Sticky Fingers and Exile (minus BN and chopping Sticky, Exile, GHS and IORR albums down to one like they did for MADE IN THE SHADE?...an almost impossible task...

Could you imagine the arguments they must have had putting together that track listing?

PECMAN



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016-03-13 18:25 by Pecman.

winter
heartbreaker
mr d
100 years ago
time waits for no one
dance little sister
fingerprint file
if you can't rock me
hand of fate
crazy mama
hot stuff
memory motel

The album would be called "Hand of Fate."

1. If You Can't Rock Me
2. Star Star
3. Crazy Mama
4. Winter
5. Hand of Fate
6. Luxury
7. 100 Years Ago
8. Ain't Too Proud To Beg
9. Silver Train
10. Memory Motel
11. Time Waits For No One
12. It's Only Rock 'N' Roll

If you consider the importance the Stones gave to these albums in the form of single-releases (a- plus b-side), later album releases (sampler, live), Videos or tv-appearances or live performances (regularity or reoccurence, Mocambo Show = possible choice for Love You Live) then the choice would be this:
- Angie
- Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)
- Silver Train (I count the Johnny Winter version as an extra plus over Dancing with Mr D)
- Star Star

- Ain't too Proud to Beg (a bit to hard to drop though only non-Jagger-Richards song)
- Fingerprint File
- If You Can't Rock Me
- It's Only Rock'n'Roll

- Crazy Mama
- Fool to Cry
- Hand of Fate
- Hot Stuff

It's Only R & R
Can You Hear The Music
Star Star
Memory Motel
Hey Negrita
Ain't Too Proud To Beg

Silver Train
Coming Down Again
Till The Next Goodbye
Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)
Hand Of Fate
Winter

----------------------
These did make the cut -- not my fault, I didn't make the 12 song rule! But they were painful to leave off:

If You Really Want To Be
Angie
100 Years
Cherry Oh Baby
Melody
Hide Your Love
If You Can't Rock Me

Quote
JohnnyBGoode
The album would be called "Can't Be Seen."

1. Undercover Of The Night
2. Fight
3. Mixed Emotions
4. Can't Be Seen
5. Almost Hear You Sigh
6. She Was Hot
7. Had It With You
8. Wanna Hold You
9. Sad Sad Sad
10. All The Way Down
11. One Hit (To The Body)
12. Slipping Away

In looking over some of your selections, I'm wondering if you might reconsider "Won't Be Heard" as your title?

whats the reason to merge those threads into one? its a different thing...

Compose your own Stones album.
No thanks, I like the Stones albums just the way they made them and the way I first heard them.

In no particular order.

Dancing With Mr. D
Heartbreaker
Hide Your Love
Star Star
If You Can't Rock Me
Ain't Too Proud To Beg
It' Only Rock 'N' Roll
Dance Little Sister
Fingerprint File
Hand Of Fate
Hey Negrita
Crazy Mama

Quote
guitarbastard
whats the reason to merge those threads into one? its a different thing...

It is very uncomfortable this way. I guess the reason of merging several threads is that bv isn´t very fond of the "pick 12 tracks from..."-idea. (can´t imagine why, btw). Members seem to like the idea, though.

Yep, kill this thread. The joy is gone.

I've got my personal playlist.

Compile the best songs from U,DW,SW and create a terrific 12-Track-album!

Mixed emotions
Tip you up
Too Tough
Harlem Shuffle
Slipping Away

Sad Sad Sad
Break the spell
She was hot
Almost Hear you sigh
Wanna Hold You
Had with you
Sleep Tonight


Pick 12 Songs From GHS, IORR and BNB And Make Your Album

If You can't rock me
Silver train
Hey Negrita
Star star
Angie

Fingerprint file
IORR
Hide your love
Hand of fate
Crazy Mama



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016-03-16 13:15 by pepganzo.

OK then:

1. Down Home Girl
3. Good Times, Bad Times
3. Route 66
3. Everybody Needs Somebody To Love
4. Family
5. Don't Lie To Me
6. Tell Me (Long version)

1. The Last Time
2. Around and Around
3. Little Queenie (from ya yas)
4. Long Long While
5. That's How Strong My Love Is
6. It's All Over Now

PHEW! Maybe 12 of their best songs on the same album...

2 1 2 0

Quote
Come On
OK then:

1. Down Home Girl
3. Good Times, Bad Times
3. Route 66
3. Everybody Needs Somebody To Love
4. Family
5. Don't Lie To Me
6. Tell Me (Long version)

1. The Last Time
2. Around and Around
3. Little Queenie (from ya yas)
4. Long Long While
5. That's How Strong My Love Is
6. It's All Over Now

PHEW! Maybe 12 of their best songs on the same album...

Track 3 on side 1 sounds interesting. What's on track 2, a secret message?

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
Come On
OK then:

1. Down Home Girl
3. Good Times, Bad Times
3. Route 66
3. Everybody Needs Somebody To Love
4. Family
5. Don't Lie To Me
6. Tell Me (Long version)

1. The Last Time
2. Around and Around
3. Little Queenie (from ya yas)
4. Long Long While
5. That's How Strong My Love Is
6. It's All Over Now

PHEW! Maybe 12 of their best songs on the same album...

Track 3 on side 1 sounds interesting. What's on track 2, a secret message?

Printing errors on vinyl is very valuable

2 1 2 0