For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
ab
An uninspired album without a keeper on it. The title track sounds like crap in E. It only came to life when played it live in B.
Quote
ryanpow
Yeah...that's not really an album
Quote
michaelsavage
Fantastic album. To me it is not the big 5 (Beggars - Ya yas- LIB - Sticky- Exile) but rather the Great Eight...continuing with GHS, IORR and Black and Blue
Quote
treaclefingers
I've always thought this was an excellent album.
If they'd have replaced Short and Curlies with Save Me it would be bullet proof.
Quote
rattler2004Quote
ab
An uninspired album without a keeper on it. The title track sounds like crap in E. It only came to life when played it live in B.
Wow, do you feel better? You post a turnoff an opinion in a thread expressing a new appreciation for an album. SHM.
One question for you, does your mother like you?
Quote
Maindefender
Despite his condition, could have used a Keith song on it. Obviously he was still creative. Would like to see GHS and IORR combined deluxe down the road!!
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
ryanpow
Yeah...that's not really an album
hey, you don't 'own' cheeky.
Quote
ryanpowQuote
treaclefingersQuote
ryanpow
Yeah...that's not really an album
hey, you don't 'own' cheeky.
I rent it. I have a lease with an option to buy.
Quote
GasLightStreet
Ha ha - Luxury never did it for me. It's too... it's over the top fake. It's too much. Musically it never goes anywhere. It's such a bland fill-in-the-numbers typical Stones open G riff song that it's a snore.
Quote
kleermakerQuote
GasLightStreet
Ha ha - Luxury never did it for me. It's too... it's over the top fake. It's too much. Musically it never goes anywhere. It's such a bland fill-in-the-numbers typical Stones open G riff song that it's a snore.
It goes nowhere, repetitive. It doesn't have a 'punch'. Second or third degree 'reggae'.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
kleermakerQuote
GasLightStreet
Ha ha - Luxury never did it for me. It's too... it's over the top fake. It's too much. Musically it never goes anywhere. It's such a bland fill-in-the-numbers typical Stones open G riff song that it's a snore.
It goes nowhere, repetitive. It doesn't have a 'punch'. Second or third degree 'reggae'.
Just like Dance Little Sister, Dancing With Mr. D, or Mannish Boy for that matter.
Sometimes, repetitive can be great.
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
kleermakerQuote
GasLightStreet
Ha ha - Luxury never did it for me. It's too... it's over the top fake. It's too much. Musically it never goes anywhere. It's such a bland fill-in-the-numbers typical Stones open G riff song that it's a snore.
It goes nowhere, repetitive. It doesn't have a 'punch'. Second or third degree 'reggae'.
Just like Dance Little Sister, Dancing With Mr. D, or Mannish Boy for that matter.
Sometimes, repetitive can be great.
Yeah but Luxury is borrrrring, unlike Brown Sugar, Jumpin' Jack Flash, Tumbling Dice, which hardly have anything going on in them as well. Monotonous songs, really... they're just great monotonous songs...
I should have been more specific about how musically Luxury doesn't go anywhere - it doesn't ever get going; there's no lift, no chug - it's reggae-wannabe-lite but that is beside the point. At least Short And Curlies takes off and moves a bit.
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
kleermakerQuote
GasLightStreet
Ha ha - Luxury never did it for me. It's too... it's over the top fake. It's too much. Musically it never goes anywhere. It's such a bland fill-in-the-numbers typical Stones open G riff song that it's a snore.
It goes nowhere, repetitive. It doesn't have a 'punch'. Second or third degree 'reggae'.
Just like Dance Little Sister, Dancing With Mr. D, or Mannish Boy for that matter.
Sometimes, repetitive can be great.
Yeah but Luxury is borrrrring, unlike Brown Sugar, Jumpin' Jack Flash, Tumbling Dice, which hardly have anything going on in them as well. Monotonous songs, really... they're just great monotonous songs...
I should have been more specific about how musically Luxury doesn't go anywhere - it doesn't ever get going; there's no lift, no chug - it's reggae-wannabe-lite but that is beside the point. At least Short And Curlies takes off and moves a bit.
I know you get it. My reply was to kleerie, who must be bored to tears with all the songs you mentioned, as well as with all the blues classics his favourite band has produced
The drums (or lack of drums) is one of the reasons why Luxury is too one-dimensional for many's likings.
When listening to the live versions, it's almost like another song, imo.
I like the idea, the sounds and especially the last minute dual Mick/Keith-vocals on the studio version, though. And Keith's ampeg-sound is beyond huge
Quote
Chris Fountain
Don't forget the power of Luxury!
Quote
DandelionPowderman
There aren't really any melodic guitars on Mr D or DLS. Yes, they both are very repetitive indeed, especially the latter.