For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Doxa
Even though some individual tracks are stellar (and all-over rather high quality)I have never get used to the 'nature' of album. Pretty hard to call it as a "live album". A strange combition of real live tracks and then these studio tracks, which reflect the then popular "unplugged" concept, and I don't it works very well. I think the television version, including wonderful version of "Gimme Shelter" is - and works - better.
But still my favourite late-day Stones album, thanks to those surprisingly fresh versions of old songs (esp. "The Spider And The Fly", "Wild Horses", "Love In Vain"). Damn good "feel" in them. But they should have left Dylan's masterpiece alone, one of their worst artistic choices ever (and damn, they even made a video of it).
- Doxa
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Doxa
Even though some individual tracks are stellar (and all-over rather high quality)I have never get used to the 'nature' of album. Pretty hard to call it as a "live album". A strange combition of real live tracks and then these studio tracks, which reflect the then popular "unplugged" concept, and I don't it works very well. I think the television version, including wonderful version of "Gimme Shelter" is - and works - better.
But still my favourite late-day Stones album, thanks to those surprisingly fresh versions of old songs (esp. "The Spider And The Fly", "Wild Horses", "Love In Vain"). Damn good "feel" in them. But they should have left Dylan's masterpiece alone, one of their worst artistic choices ever (and damn, they even made a video of it).
- Doxa
I don't disagree about it being a poor artistic choice. However, the rendition was excellent. In fact one of the best concert performances they ever have done, imo.
Quote
DoxaQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Doxa
Even though some individual tracks are stellar (and all-over rather high quality)I have never get used to the 'nature' of album. Pretty hard to call it as a "live album". A strange combition of real live tracks and then these studio tracks, which reflect the then popular "unplugged" concept, and I don't it works very well. I think the television version, including wonderful version of "Gimme Shelter" is - and works - better.
But still my favourite late-day Stones album, thanks to those surprisingly fresh versions of old songs (esp. "The Spider And The Fly", "Wild Horses", "Love In Vain"). Damn good "feel" in them. But they should have left Dylan's masterpiece alone, one of their worst artistic choices ever (and damn, they even made a video of it).
- Doxa
I don't disagree about it being a poor artistic choice. However, the rendition was excellent. In fact one of the best concert performances they ever have done, imo.
I agree that play it rather well, but I think that - that they play it well according to their own standards - actually shows how the song is "too big" for them to have anything to say of it, or even do some kind of justice to it. The song just loses its magic, and sounds like "any other" song; technically or formally okay, but no real substance. And I think recording a version of maybe the most important rock track ever, was a rather cheap shot - I'm looking for their version of "A Day In The Life" or "Hey Jude"...
I think it says a lot that there was some years ago a thread here at IORR of best Dylan's covers, and no one suggested this...
- Doxa
Quote
triceratops
Rolling Stones Stripped
or
Eric Clapton doing Layla and Crossroads Unplugged?
The Stones!!!!
You can find it here [bootleg-rambler.blogspot.com]Quote
Aquamarine
I love Stripped. I wish I had its Companion.
Quote
Godxofxrock9You can find it here [bootleg-rambler.blogspot.com]Quote
Aquamarine
I love Stripped. I wish I had its Companion.
Quote
open-g
The only recording where they played "Shine A Lightning" live!
Quote
TheGreek
this whole unplugged thing was such a flash in the pan so to speak thing ,that lasted a couple of years then faded out. what a load. some artists material in my mind does not translate that well to acoustic unplugged instruments .
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
DoxaQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Doxa
Even though some individual tracks are stellar (and all-over rather high quality)I have never get used to the 'nature' of album. Pretty hard to call it as a "live album". A strange combition of real live tracks and then these studio tracks, which reflect the then popular "unplugged" concept, and I don't it works very well. I think the television version, including wonderful version of "Gimme Shelter" is - and works - better.
But still my favourite late-day Stones album, thanks to those surprisingly fresh versions of old songs (esp. "The Spider And The Fly", "Wild Horses", "Love In Vain"). Damn good "feel" in them. But they should have left Dylan's masterpiece alone, one of their worst artistic choices ever (and damn, they even made a video of it).
- Doxa
I don't disagree about it being a poor artistic choice. However, the rendition was excellent. In fact one of the best concert performances they ever have done, imo.
I agree that play it rather well, but I think that - that they play it well according to their own standards - actually shows how the song is "too big" for them to have anything to say of it, or even do some kind of justice to it. The song just loses its magic, and sounds like "any other" song; technically or formally okay, but no real substance. And I think recording a version of maybe the most important rock track ever, was a rather cheap shot - I'm looking for their version of "A Day In The Life" or "Hey Jude"...
I think it says a lot that there was some years ago a thread here at IORR of best Dylan's covers, and no one suggested this...
- Doxa
I agree - but I had to point out how well they played it. And I've never heard an open G-tuned guitar sound so beautiful.
Quote
AquamarineQuote
TheGreek
this whole unplugged thing was such a flash in the pan so to speak thing ,that lasted a couple of years then faded out. what a load. some artists material in my mind does not translate that well to acoustic unplugged instruments .
When it worked, sometimes magic happened, though, like Nirvana.
Quote
Aquamarine
I love Stripped. I wish I had its Companion.