For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
uhbuhgullayew
Looking forward to the Dirty Work Bonus tracks.
Quote
Doxa
I think EXILE bonus has stronger individual tracks (a true gem: "Plundered My Soul"), but SOME GIRLS bonus works better as a whole - its standard is higher over-all. Both are great reminders of the greatness of the band - and I can't recall when I have been so thrilled for having a new Stones tune to go crazy aboout as I did with "Plundered My Soul". I hope there is more vaults stuff to come.
- Doxa
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
uhbuhgullayew
Looking forward to the Dirty Work Bonus tracks.
Those may surprise you big time, as you obviously haven't heard them?
Quote
uhbuhgullayewQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
uhbuhgullayew
Looking forward to the Dirty Work Bonus tracks.
Those may surprise you big time, as you obviously haven't heard them?
What I've heard I like quite a bit.
Quote
Doxa
I think EXILE bonus has stronger individual tracks (a true gem: "Plundered My Soul"), but SOME GIRLS bonus works better as a whole - its standard is higher over-all. Both are great reminders of the greatness of the band - and I can't recall when I have been so thrilled for having a new Stones tune to go crazy aboout as I did with "Plundered My Soul". I hope there is more vaults stuff to come.
- Doxa
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
uhbuhgullayewQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
uhbuhgullayew
Looking forward to the Dirty Work Bonus tracks.
Those may surprise you big time, as you obviously haven't heard them?
What I've heard I like quite a bit.
OK, so you're informed
Quote
MunichhiltonQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
uhbuhgullayewQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
uhbuhgullayew
Looking forward to the Dirty Work Bonus tracks.
Those may surprise you big time, as you obviously haven't heard them?
What I've heard I like quite a bit.
OK, so you're informed
Crushed Pearl is an unfinished classic...DP, I agree about We Had It All but I've never considered it a Stones song. I think there are only 2 or 3 Stones on it?
Quote
Thrylan
I am an Exile man, but prefer the SG Bonus, slightly. I love you too much is my fave, with Claudine as a close second. Yellow Cab is hot too. I have always been an avid boot collector, and while the Exile stuff is good, they left alot off in favor of weaker material. Traveling Man is hotter than any of what they used,(I think the Black Crows lifted its riff for Sting Me.) Alas, greed, don't make me re-buy albums I already own.......dont rehash greatest hit.....FL, GRRR- Give me a four disc boot comp, without the slick production. Would be nice.
Quote
Doxa
DandelionPowderman tends to critizise the "hard rocking" versions of 1972/73 to lack some of the "swing" or "groove", and I as often tend to protest that, but I think his description is true in the case of "Rocks Off" during Taylor days. Some of the "roll" element is lost. In modern versions they try to do more homage to that element, but I think that's damn hard thing to do convincingly. Te recapture that EXILE feel, which seemed to be a kind of once in a life time thing. When all the stars were in a right order.
- Doxa
Quote
seitanQuote
Thrylan
I am an Exile man, but prefer the SG Bonus, slightly. I love you too much is my fave, with Claudine as a close second. Yellow Cab is hot too. I have always been an avid boot collector, and while the Exile stuff is good, they left alot off in favor of weaker material. Traveling Man is hotter than any of what they used,(I think the Black Crows lifted its riff for Sting Me.) Alas, greed, don't make me re-buy albums I already own.......dont rehash greatest hit.....FL, GRRR- Give me a four disc boot comp, without the slick production. Would be nice.
My understanding is that Traveling Man belongs to Sticky Fingers era, - if they reissue Sticky F someday, then maybe we will have Traveling Man as a bonus track.
Quote
drbryant
For Exile, I would have preferred the unfinished session tapes. I find the additions jarring. i realize I am probably in the minority.