Quote
canadian.sway
I must fully back what Dave Grohl says in that brief clip for the Lemmy trailer. Look at those who live the 'image' of the rough edged rocker and look at who actually lives it. Look who makes music and tours constantly and look at who relies on re-invigorating their past and relying on others.

I do love Keith as a musician and song writer, But the man has issues with being a caricature of who he once was.

Could be but I just DL'ed a 2013 Motorhead gig and it's appalling : it's "geriatric metal", no less.
So in the end there's no diff. between living the rock life and faking it when you're in your 60's...

You Got The Silver: better then I expected!

Nice vocals and Thank you Ronnie Wood!!

Tom

Quote
sabata
You got the silver

Lovely. Thanks

-------------------
Keep On Rolling

Quote
sabata
You got the silver

Very good sound and great song but if I'm honest I must say that Keith seems somehow slow or like he is lacking energy.

I guess the age and the rolling years are finally taking its toll.

Ronnie looks much younger and energetic.

I hope Keith takes all the necessary vitamins, I mean the real vitamins.

Quote
rollingon

Quote
sabata
You got the silver

Very good sound and great song but if I'm honest I must say that Keith seems somehow slow or like he is lacking energy.

I guess the age and the rolling years are finally taking its toll.

Ronnie looks much younger and energetic.

I hope Keith takes all the necessary vitamins, I mean the real vitamins.

It's a slow song anyway...


Ronnie's doing great here but did they rehearse it before playing on stage?

From where I was I thought Keith gave YGTS a lot of heart and his vocals sounded great too...it thought it was very touching the way he and Ronnie played together and then hugged like brothers in the end.

My third show this tour and I loved every minute of each!

Dave Grohl is tiresome...all that flapping about for very little musically and what he does play is not suited to Bitch. I wasn't aware of his comments about Keith but if that's the case why the @#$%& did they let him be last night's special pest?

Let's face it Grohl will turn up to the opening of a super market if invited so not such a big attraction. Hopefully once the Stones get out of California we will see some decent guests.

Quote
crumbling_mice
Dave Grohl is tiresome...all that flapping about for very little musically and what he does play is not suited to Bitch. I wasn't aware of his comments about Keith but if that's the case why the @#$%& did they let him be last night's special pest?

Let's face it Grohl will turn up to the opening of a super market if invited so not such a big attraction. Hopefully once the Stones get out of California we will see some decent guests.

I agree totally, very odd choices for guests so far, they should pick up some real ARTISTS for guests, not some mediocre "wanna be a rock star or pop star" types. If not some real artists, then it would be better to be without guests.

Grohl's singing was awful, and his playing had nothing to do with the song.

Keith looked btw absolutely bored during the song.

Quote
sabata
Bitch
[www.youtube.com]

Dave Grohl was awesome on this song!! He deserves more! The Stones need to have Dave playing 3-4 songs every night, he could really take it all up a notch. Wouldnt that be awesome if he toured with them? Maybe someone should start a petition, or Facebook page, to get more Dave Grohl on this tour.

This is how the Stones should always sound! Really good performance. Leaves Keith without a job, of course- Ronnie seems to be able to keep up.

Max - you are being silly. Stop it, it's not big and it;s not clever. We all know Grohl is a hypocrit of the highest order and unworthy of a place on the same stage as the Stones.

Can we get a sticky thread asking, no, DEMANDING more Dave Grohl on this tour?

Quote
Lorenz
This is how the Stones should always sound! Really good performance. Leaves Keith without a job, of course- Ronnie seems to be able to keep up.

No man, Keith can still be there, doing his thing.... three guitars, it would be great with Dave up there for 4-5 songs!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-19 13:10 by Max'sKansasCity.

Quote
Max'sKansasCity

Quote
Lorenz
This is how the Stones should always sound! Really good performance. Leaves Keith without a job, of course- Ronnie seems to be able to keep up.

No man, Keith can still be there, doing his thing.... three guitars, it would be great with Dave up there for 4-5 songs!

I was just trying to point out how lost Keith looks these days, wouldn't really want him to leave the stage. I was actually really impressed at the 2nd London Gig in 2012, but the videos since then seem a bit lacklustre. Grohl really infuses some fresh energy here and lifts the performance. Best guest performance so far in my opinion - Taylor's contribution is more of nostalgic value compared.

I'm as guilty as anyone else when it comes to bitching and moaning about this tour and the guests (specifically Katy Perry, John Mayer), but when you're there in the moment watching the live show - rather than dissecting some cell phone video looking for technical flaws - what you get is Dave's contagious enthusiasm. It raised the bar for the rest of the show.

wow rocken

Feel The Fear
And Do It Anyway

Quote
DeanGoodman
I'm as guilty as anyone else when it comes to bitching and moaning about this tour and the guests (specifically Katy Perry, John Mayer), but when you're there in the moment watching the live show - rather than dissecting some cell phone video looking for technical flaws - what you get is Dave's contagious enthusiasm. It raised the bar for the rest of the show.

I think the contagious enthusiasm comes through in the video... to be there feeling it live must have been spectacular.

Quote
JumpinJeppeFlash
Anybody know if Keith played on you got the silver, or did Ronnie do the guitarpart?

Very good Ronnie job during YGTS, he purely leads the song. Keith good vocals, however he does not play anymore. He seems very slow, in good shape, but yes, very slow and a bit tired.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-19 13:37 by roby.

Quote
DeanGoodman
I'm as guilty as anyone else when it comes to bitching and moaning about this tour and the guests (specifically Katy Perry, John Mayer), but when you're there in the moment watching the live show - rather than dissecting some cell phone video looking for technical flaws - what you get is Dave's contagious enthusiasm. It raised the bar for the rest of the show.

You are right that there is enthusiasm which is great per se, just the singing and playing wasn't really great in my opinion.

On the other hand, Keith seems to be lacking energy, he seems a little bit tired, and not very emotionally involved somehow, I have been listening and watching to 81/82 shows and it's hard to believe we are talking about the same person. This lack of enthusiasm has been there since 89 (from time to time), there has not been a whole concert from beginning to end since 89, that Keith's involvement would have been 100%, In Jagger's case he can still be nearly 100% involved in one concert from beginning to end, which saves the situation for the Stones. Of course it's only human and very common that performance level declines after 40, there are also exceptional people who can keep their performance level at very high level even in their 70s and Jagger is obviously one of these people.

That Dave Grohl really seems to bring Mick to life........it was the same with IORR on Saturday Night Live a while back.........

Quote
rollingon

Quote
DeanGoodman
I'm as guilty as anyone else when it comes to bitching and moaning about this tour and the guests (specifically Katy Perry, John Mayer), but when you're there in the moment watching the live show - rather than dissecting some cell phone video looking for technical flaws - what you get is Dave's contagious enthusiasm. It raised the bar for the rest of the show.

You are right that there is enthusiasm which is great per se, just the singing and playing wasn't really great in my opinion.

On the other hand, Keith seems to be lacking energy, he seems a little bit tired, and not very emotionally involved somehow, I have been listening and watching to 81/82 shows and it's hard to believe we are talking about the same person. This lack of enthusiasm has been there since 89 (from time to time), there has not been a whole concert from beginning to end since 89, that Keith's involvement would have been 100%, In Jagger's case he can still be nearly 100% involved in one concert from beginning to end, which saves the situation for the Stones. Of course it's only human and very common that performance level declines after 40, there are also exceptional people who can keep their performance level at very high level even in their 70s and Jagger is obviously one of these people.

You're right. Keith does seem disengaged.

Quote
drbryant
In all seriousness, though, I've always found it odd that people who can get so much enjoyment from repeated listenings to the same albums at home seem uninterested in hearing those same songs played live more than once.

In all seriousness, album "setlists" can't be changed, but live setlists are not engraved in stone...at least that's how it should be.

Front Row

You Got the Silver- beautiful. Ronnie played it so well, and I love that they used a different arrangement from the ABB tour. If Keith is barely going to strum his guitar, I wish he'd pull out the trenchcoat and ciggie, and really give the vocal everything like he did on the Shine a Light movie.

I find it notable that nobody discusses the second half of the show, as if there's a implicit acknowledgement that it's purely going through the motions.
Enquiring minds want to know, how was Miss You?

SFTD... 3:26, Keith tries an approach... No, thanks guy.

Quote
GrandToad

Quote
WindyHorses
What would Bill say?

He would say, "I got the silver"

Just Loved Bitch!!!

Grohls energy and enthusiasm @#$%& the Stones up... Just Great !!!
Thanks Dave.

Jeroen

Quote
roby
SFTD... 3:26, Keith tries an approach... No, thanks guy.

Wow. I am stunned how neutered SFTD is. The solo is down to a few notes over four bars or so. As an end to the main set it is shocking how little energy the performance has, as if they just wanted to get it over with.