After these 5 shows who can you elect as "Miss Gimme Shelter" ?
You can take everything into account : the wardrobe, the voice, the sex appeal, the performance itself...

Personally I was very impressed by Florence for the voice and the performance.
For the wardrobe Lady Gaga is for sure unbeatable.><

Let us know what is your opinion

Florence

[ I want to shout, but I can hardly speak ]

Bono

Florence... runner up Lisa if Florence is unable to do it.

Florence for the sheer energy

Quote
pilou
After these 5 shows who can you elect as "Miss Gimme Shelter" ?
You can take everything into account : the wardrobe, the voice, the sex appeal, the performance itself...

Personally I was very impressed by Florence for the voice and the performance.
For the wardrobe Lady Gaga is for sure unbeatable.><

Let us know what is your opinion

Taking everything into account, I'm going to have to go with Lady GooGoo. I'll take all the crap that may come with that vote, but I have to call it as I see it. Also, I would have to rank Florence Welch at the bottom of the "Miss Gimme Shelter" pile, as her voice did not come close to doing the song justice (to put it as kindly as I can).

Other than some grainy cell phone video, GaGa is the only one I saw. She was fun. I would like to hear a really good quality version of Mary J. because I know she has a hell of a voice. I'd be interested to hear Florence, because apparently she was very good, but from what I've heard of her voice (I've seen her on SNL and a couple other things) I wouldn't have thought she'd have the right voice for GS.

gaga by far, the others arent worthy of being on the same stage.

Florence

What a drag it is gettin' old

Lisa, seemed like she had something to prove. That is just what I thought, at the concert.

I plan on going through the GS, back to back, and seeing which one I like best.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-16 20:35 by MingSubu.

Brenda

Lisa Fischer no doubt!

Been Stoned since 1964 and still am!

Lisa by far.

Florence Welch by a country mile. Lady Gaga just screamed and everything about her seemed contrived and forced. Mary Blige was good but not as good as Flo. Or Lisa for that matter.

JumpingKentFlash

Lisa

-------------------
Keep On Rolling

For my ears Florence has won, for my eyes however Lady Gaga has won

Lady Gaga was as gaga as usual, but even if her vocals were not so great, she brought in some crazy energy which fitted into the show. All the women did a good job.

Quote
Slick
gaga by far, the others arent worthy of being on the same stage.

my aren't you a 'little monster'

Lisa & the Mick all the way :E

Lisa!!! And Florence is second. Gaga is in last place.

Florence

"Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience." Mark Twain

Quote
treaclefingers

Quote
Slick
gaga by far, the others arent worthy of being on the same stage.

my aren't you a 'little monster'

it is what it is lol.

Florence

(I assume were only talking about this tour - otherwise, Merry Clayton is far better)

Lisa

Kanye

Taking Lisa out of the equation as she has not 'guested' on Gimme Shelter, I'd vote for Florence for sheeer energy and in doing so gave the song a fresh feel. Blige was ok in a sterile kinda way, Gaga, well, she gave i her all and seemed to be enjoying it, but for me she didn;t bring anything new to it.

Lisa has always nailed Gimme Shelter and has had the months of rehearsals to to get to that pint and then the many months and years of singing it live so she hs an advantage over all the guests.

florence of course

Lisa of course

Jan Richards

[www.stonesondecca.com]

Lisa's the best. But out of the 3 guests...Gaga.

Okay, compromise, Florence voice and Gaga's body.