The ultimate duet by The Glimmer Twins, both playing keyboards as well. Brings memories of "Something Happened to Me Yesterday" and "Salt of the Earth".
My first recollection of the song, when I was a kid, was something to the effect: "shit, this is old people's boring ballad, damn way too long as well..." But I grew up...

It is a beautiful piece as hell, and constructed extremily nicely and carefully for the the Stones. I mean, from the song-writer's point of view, there is so much going on, carefully written verses, beautifully carrying a coherent story, a simple but catchy chorus (varied nicely to keep the interest), and incredibly beautiful middle eight. All working perfectly together, and there is not one second too much. It feels like they could go on forever, and tell us more. One of their best ballads ever, maybe the most mature one ever.
Keith's vocal part is one of his most heartfelt, warm ones ever. There is no need to over-interpret and act like some kind a crooner like in many of his latter efforts. It is just a natural feeling married with experience and a bit-broken voice. Irrestible.
But Jagger then... I have always had mixed feelings about that one. He seemingly was going through some strange times back then, and had some seconds thoughts what to do with his voice. How to express himself... Some of that also had occurred in some IT'S ONLY ROCK'N'ROLL tracks already, but throughout BLACK&BLUE he sounds like trying different 'tricks' by which to give his voice different color, sometimes darker (like in "Hand of Fate"), sometimes more nasal, etc. Sometimes it feels like he tries to hide his natural voice. That could be his natural habit, but I think in BLACK&BLUE he doesn't sound like he is not in control of it. (The same problem continued in the following American Tour). In "Memory Motel" he just over-does whatever he does. Still it isn't bad, but... how can I say.. a bit odd. To me it sounds like he thinks the song is too sugarish, too balladish, too middle-aged or something, and he just wants destroy the impression by 'look, I am not that serious doing this kind of thing. I am not
that yet'. He ends up sounding almsot like a caricature of himself.
But he was writing that kind of 'soft' material quite a lot during the mid-70's, but was some part of him rebelling against that tendency? 'I am not that old and boring yet?' The crisis after having turned thirty in young man's game... In SOME GIRLS he sounded like getting over it, and discovering a new Jagger persona and voice to go along the times. And it is good that he left some of the stuff on the vaults. I think he was much better mentally prepared to do justice to that kind of ballad material by the times of TATTOO YOU. For example, I don't think "Worried About You" could have been so perfect in every nuance-wisee as it is in TATTOO YOU. Especially if "Memory Motel" is any indication.
Nothing wrong with the falsetto, but it is that damn middle-range... Sometimes it sounds irrestible, even fitting, but sometimes I can't stand it at all...
- Doxa
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2015-03-24 11:52 by Doxa.