Would love to see them play it exactly like they did on Rock 'N Roll Circus. With Bill Wyman on base of course.

To make it even more authentic, they can take Ronnie out of the mix entirely like they did to Brian on this version.

Quote
71Tele
To make it even more authentic, they can take Ronnie out of the mix entirely like they did to Brian on this version.

The bastids eh!?

....and have half a dozen burly gardeners stomping across da stage ....



ROCKMAN

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
71Tele
To make it even more authentic, they can take Ronnie out of the mix entirely like they did to Brian on this version.

The bastids eh!?

Yep. Poor Brian.

Hampton 1981 edges GYYYO by a length

Quote
71Tele
To make it even more authentic, they can take Ronnie out of the mix entirely like they did to Brian on this version.

Sadly, Brian took himself out of the mix.

Quote
Munichhilton
Hampton 1981 edges GYYYO by a length

A length of rubbish.

MSG 9-26-02, msg 1-16-03, St louis 12-12-97, San Diego 10-97, Orpheum 9-7-02, LA 10-31-02, chicago '99 - to name a few

Quote
JumpinJackOLantern
With Bill Wyman on base of course.

And Charlie on speed!

Quote
71Tele
To make it even more authentic, they can take Ronnie out of the mix entirely like they did to Brian on this version.

Haven't they been doing that since 1989?

Quote
jiggysawdust

Quote
71Tele
To make it even more authentic, they can take Ronnie out of the mix entirely like they did to Brian on this version.

Haven't they been doing that since 1989?

Sometimes yes, sometimes no...

Anaheim '99. They started the show with it and they were off and running.

Leon's at the Bangladesh show.

You mean with Mick struggling to stay on key?

I'll take the studio version, with the original face paint video. Despite the fact that the Stones are the greatest live band in history, some of their studio tracks are just perfect - untouchable. JJF is one, but particularly Satisfaction, Street Fighting Man (for years, just played too fast live) and Honky Tonk Women (with Keith's unreal backing vocals)



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-10-31 09:24 by drbryant.

Quote
drbryant
You mean with Mick struggling to stay on key?

I'll take the studio version, with the original face paint video. Despite the fact that the Stones are the greatest live band in history, some of their studio tracks are just perfect - untouchable. JJF is one, but particularly Satisfaction, Street Fighting Man (for years, just played too fast live) and Honky Tonk Women (with Keith's unreal backing vocals)

and Gimme Shelter. No live version comes close to the studio version IMO.

wow, completely disagree, this song was made to be played live, i dont like the studio track, i like the 94-current versions w/horns and the whole deal

I'll take the Love You Live version as my number 1. Yes loose and ragged, Mick voice was almost gone but the guitars and energy make up for all of it. Ronnie's guitar is the best anyone played overtop that JJF rhythmn.

Quote
Markdog
I'll take the Love You Live version as my number 1. Yes loose and ragged, Mick voice was almost gone but the guitars and energy make up for all of it. Ronnie's guitar is the best anyone played overtop that JJF rhythmn.

Wrong. LYL was flaccid compared to GYYO and the version in Gimme Shelter is even better than that because it has that weird lick Taylor played for a couple of measures over the verse. Fierce!

Quote
71Tele

Quote
Markdog
I'll take the Love You Live version as my number 1. Yes loose and ragged, Mick voice was almost gone but the guitars and energy make up for all of it. Ronnie's guitar is the best anyone played overtop that JJF rhythmn.

Wrong. LYL was flaccid compared to GYYO and the version in Gimme Shelter is even better than that because it has that weird lick Taylor played for a couple of measures over the verse. Fierce!

yes!