Quote
boston2006

Let me get in here before the hoards of whiners showup and start bitching.... and say THANKS FOR POSTING!!! Great to hear em live.. and thanks to the badass who video taped this....GOOD JOB!

Before I retort to the art of bitching, all credits to whomever made the effort to film this. Whip is among my favourite latter day live Stones number. It works well.
They have managed to make a bore out of Shattered though. Which is a pitty since it's a good, relatively new, rocker. A real "upper" handled the right way.

Who is singing backup on "Whip"?

Quote
71Tele
Who is singing backup on "Whip"?

I think it's Chuck...or Bernard under the stage.

Seriously, though - based on the JJF clip, I'm guessing Chuck and Darryl did all the backing vocs for the evening.

Think I've got the name for the tour - "The Moss Has Gathered".

I think these videos just saved me a lot of money. Charlie sounds good.

Quote
Jah Paul

Quote
71Tele
Who is singing backup on "Whip"?

I think it's Chuck...or Bernard under the stage.

That's what I was afraid of...

Quote
71Tele
Who is singing backup on "Whip"?

Chuck AND Darryl

Shattered = One Of the Worst = Zzzzzzzzzzzzz

When the Whip Comes down = Semi Punk = Zzzzzzzzzz

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
71Tele
Who is singing backup on "Whip"?

Chuck AND Darryl

actual Rolling Stones are no longer allowed to sing, or what?

Those were real slow versions, what the heck happened to Shattered?? Ronnie plays good though.

Same singing, same notes from Ronnie, same tired riffing from Keith. Mick should try to do something new to this song. It used to be great. FFS!Why not try something else, put Ronnie on Open E acoustic like the studio version, Keith could do it in standard at the same time like in rock n roll circus and Mick could just once try to sing it like he meant it.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-10-31 18:46 by Redhotcarpet.

Quote
Redhotcarpet
Why not try something else, put Ronnie on Open E acoustic like the studio version, Keith could do it in standard at the same time like in rock n roll circus and Mick could just once try to sing it like he meant it.

If you really knew this band, you'd know that they'd never do any of that. Accept it and move on.

Quote
Justin

Quote
Redhotcarpet
Why not try something else, put Ronnie on Open E acoustic like the studio version, Keith could do it in standard at the same time like in rock n roll circus and Mick could just once try to sing it like he meant it.

If you really knew this band, you'd know that they'd never do any of that. Accept it and move on.

Stop whining. Take what's given to you. Drink the Kool Aid.

This Kool Aid tastes weird. What did StonesTod put in it?

did Mick sing, "I was gay in New York and a maniac in LA"

more poltical correctness, i guess. I know Mick has been doing that for years in certain songs, it's a shame they care about such stuff now...just sing them as you wrote them.

Quote
Redhotcarpet
and Mick could just once try to sing it like he meant it.

I think Mick was a bit knackered at that point.

Bless him, he was still trying though.

We're not in 1981 anymore... he threw a few karate moves.

Quote
HalfNanker
did Mick sing, "I was gay in New York and a maniac in LA"

more poltical correctness, i guess. I know Mick has been doing that for years in certain songs,

Political correctness? I think not. At least not with the word "fag". I mean, if you're going to keep "Some Girls" as is, why bother changing "Whip"? They did it normally (albeit badly) on the BB tour. Stray Cat Blues has been all over the map, but I gather Mick just feels less creepy singing 16 or 19 instead of 13. Can't say I blame him.

Quote
Justin
This Kool Aid tastes weird. What did StonesTod put in it?

Are you referring to what part of his anatomy he put in it?

It isn't polite to ask, just freakin' drink it already.

Sound is really good, they must be using an analog soundboard. Great instrument separation.

Quote
carlorossi

Quote
HalfNanker
did Mick sing, "I was gay in New York and a maniac in LA"

more poltical correctness, i guess. I know Mick has been doing that for years in certain songs,

Political correctness? I think not. At least not with the word "fag". I mean, if you're going to keep "Some Girls" as is, why bother changing "Whip"? They did it normally (albeit badly) on the BB tour. Stray Cat Blues has been all over the map, but I gather Mick just feels less creepy singing 16 or 19 instead of 13. Can't say I blame him.

He no longer sings some girls, as is, anymore and at times skips the Kennedys verse in Sympathy and leaves out the last line in Rambler as well.

is mick doing the hi-step move he did in 78 at around 1:46? it looks like he could be but can't tell for sure.